High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 P&H CK 6176

Achhar Singh & Ors. vs Baljit Kaur & Ors.

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 16 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Harkesh Manuja, J
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
SAO-40-2018 (O&M), SAO-41-2018 (O&M), SAO-42-2018 (O&M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

46 paragraphs · 3,717 words

HARKESH MANUJA, J. (ORAL)

Vide this common order, abovementioned three appeals shall stand disposed of as they arise from common judgment dated 20.03.2018 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana.

For convenience, the facts are culled out from SAO-40-2018.

2.

By way of present appeal(s), challenge has been laid to the order dated 20.03.2018 passed by the Court of learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana whereby, judgment and decree dated 08.11.2011 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Samrala was set aside and the matter was remanded to learned trial Court for fresh adjudication after permitting respondent-defendant No.1 to examine Ujjagar Singh as a witness and thereafter, affording the appellants-plaintiffs an opportunity to lead rebuttal evidence. The remand was also founded upon amendment of the plaint.

3.

Briefly stating, dispute in the present case, relates to the estate left by Nahar Singh who owned land measuring 16 kanals 4 marlas forming part of revenue estate of Village Baghaur, Tehsil Samrala, District Ludhiana. Out of the said land, 10 kanals 16 marlas was originally owned by Nahar Singh whereas 5 kanals 8 marlas was devolved upon him by way of inheritance from his deceased brother Bhajan Singh who predeceased Nahar Singh. The following two suits came to be filed with respect to the aforesaid estate:-

CIVIL SUIT No.92 of 09.04.2003 titled Civil Suit No.98 of “Achhar Singh and Ors. Vs. Kesar Singh” 25.04.2003 titled “Achhar Singh and Ors. Vs. Baljit Kaur”

The appellants-plaintiffs being the collaterals Suit filed by three of the of Nahar Singh filed a suit for declaration and appellants with respect to permanent injunction qua his estate on the 64 kanals 12 marlas of basis of will dated 31.03.1981 whereby, the land including the land subject land was to devolve upon the which was subject matter appellants as well as respondent No.1 in of civil suit No.92 of equal share (1/5th). The prayer made by the 09.04.2003. The prayer appellants-plaintiffs in their suit is extracted clause therein is hereunder:- extracted hereunder:-

Suit for declaration to the effect that the plaintiffs and

Suit for the grant of permanent defendant No. 2 are the true owner and in possession of the injunction restraining the land/property detailed as under:-defendants

(i)

Land measuring 5K-9M i.e. 4/5 share out of land measuring 6K-16M comprised in Khewat No. 242, 244, Khatauni No. 275,

(i)

From disposing or cause to 277, 279, 276, Rect. No. 49, Killa No. 21, Rect. No. 50, Killa dispossess the plaintiffs from No. 25, 15, 16, Rect. No. 51, Killa No. 4/1, 15/1, 16/1, Rect. No. and interfering or cause to 52, Killa No. 1, 10/1, Rect. No. 51, Killa No. 5, 6/2 and Khasra Nos. 375, 376, 339, 340, 52/1/2. interfere into the possession of

(ii)

Land measuring 3K-4M i.e. 4/5 share out of land measuring the plaintiffs over the land 4K-0M comprised in Khewat No. 246, Khatauni No. 279 and measuring 64K-12M comprised land measuring 2K-16M comprised in Khewat No. 246, in Khewat No.242, 244, Khatauni No. 279, Khasra Nos. 375, 376, Rect. No. 49, Killa No. 16/1, 16/2, 17/1; Rect. No. 41, Killa No. 11, 19/2, 19/3, Khatauni No.275, 277 Rect. No. 20/1, 20/2. 49, Killa No. 21, Rect. No. 50, as entered in the Jamabandi for the year 2000-2001, Killa No. 25, Rect. No. 51, Killa situated in the revenue estate of Baghaur, H.B. No. 118, No. 4, 5/1, 15, 16, Rect. No. 52, Tehsil Samrala, District Ludhiana alongwith the share of Killa No. 1, 10/1, Rect. No. 51, joint electric tubewell of 5 BHP bearing account No. A- Killa No. 5, 6/2, as entered in 3557 as well as the share and turn of the said electric the Jamabandi for the year 2000-tubewell/Bore, Motor, Kotha, Chubacha etc. electric, 2001; Chah, Sham lat, Trees and all other rights appurtenant to

(ii)

From interfering or cause to the land/estate owned by Sh. Nahar Singh deceased, and interfere into the exclusive user the impugned sale deed dated 9.3.1995 (Vasika No. 4458 by the plaintiffs over the electric dated 22.3.1995) regarding land measuring 10K-10M, tubewell of 5 BHP bearing which has been executed by late Sh. Nahar Singh in favour account No. A-3557 of defendant No. 1, Kesar Singh, is wrong, illegal, installed/existing in the suit land fictitious, fraudulent, without consideration and void and detailed above. Situated in the the same is illegal, false and does not bind upon the rights revenue estate of Baghaur, H. of the plaintiffs in respect of their share in dispute i.e. the No. 118, Tehsil Samrala, District estate of Sh. Nahar Singh deceased and the impugned Ludhiana, except by adopting orders dated 11.2.2003 passed by the Assistant Collector due course of law. 2nd Grade, Samrala in the mutation No. 2827 regarding the inheritance of Sh. Nahar Singh is wrong, illegal and void and the alleged will dated 27.1.2003 purported to have been executed by Sh. Nahar Singh deceased in favour of defendant No. 1 is wrong, false, fictitious, fraudulent and void document.

AND

Suit for the grant of permanent injunction restraining the defendant No. 1 from selling or alienating in any manner, and from creating any burden on the suit land fully detailed in the above heading of the plaint No. 2B/27 and also restraining defendant No. 1 from dispossessing or cause to dispossess the plaintiffs from and from interfering or cause to interfere into the possession of the plaintiffs over the land/property detailed as under:-

(i)

Land measuring 64K-12M comprised in Khewat No. 242, 244, Khatauni No. 275, 277, Rect. No. 49, Killa No. 21, Rect. No. 50, Killa No. 25, 15, Rect. No. 51, Killa No. 4/1, 15/1, 16/1, Rect. No. 52, Killa No. 1, 10/1, Rect. No. 51, Killa No. 5, 6/2, as entered in the Jamabandi for the year 2000-2001.

(ii)

Land measuring 2K-16M comprised in Khewat No. 246, Khatauni No. 279, Khasra Nos. 375, 376, as entered in the Jamabandi for the year 2000-2001, containing the house/boundary etc. shown as Red in the site plan attached and bounded as under:-

East: Agricultural land of Bhind Singh etc. sons of Sh. [illegible] Singh.

West: Metalled Road (Phirni).

North: House of Mastan Singh and Labh Singh sons of Sh. Bakshish Singh

South: House and Abadi of Gurmail Singh son of Sh. Kaka Singh.

4.

The Civil Suit No.92 dated 09.04.2003 titled as “Achhar Singh and Ors. Vs. Kesar Singh” filed at the instance of appellants was contested by respondent-defendant No.1 inter alia on the ground that the earlier Will dated 31.03.1981 stood revoked by the testator Nahar Singh who later executed another registered Will dated 27.01.2003 whereby respondent-defendant No.1 was exclusively bequeathed the entire estate besides even relying upon registered sale deed dated 09.03.1995 qua the land measuring 9 kanals 10 marlas forming part of the suit property been transferred also by deceased-Nahar Singh in favour of respondent-defendant No.1. The learned trial Court consolidated both the aforementioned suits and vide judgment and decree dated 08.11.2011 partly decreed the suit for declaration and dismissed the suit for permanent injunction. The relevant para No.19 of the aforesaid judgment is extracted hereunder:-

“19.

As a sequel to the findings under the above said issues, the main suit i.e. Civil Suit No. 92 of 9.4.2003 titled as Achhar Singh and others Versus Kesar Singh and others is partly decreed and the consolidated suit i.e. Civil Suit No. 98 of 25.4.2003 titled as Achhar Singh and others Versus Baljit Kaur and others is hereby dismissed. It is hereby declared that out of the property originally owned by Nahar Singh i.e. 10K-16M as detailed in head note of plaint as no relief has been claimed in this suit regarding property allegedly inherited by Nahar Singh from Bhajan Singh, the plaintiffs and defendant No. 1 are owner to the extent of 1/5 share each in property measuring 1K-16M. As 9K-10M of land was already sold out by Nahar Singh to defendant No. 1 vide sale deed dated 9.3.1995 on the basis of Will dated 27.1.2003, the orders passed by revenue authorities regarding inheritance of deceased Nahar Singh on the basis of Will dated 27.1.2003 are liable to be ignored and are hereby set aside. Further, the defendant No. 1 is restrained from alienating the above mentioned share of the plaintiffs out of the property in dispute. Decree sheet be prepared separately in both the suits. Copy of this judgment be also placed on the file of consolidated suit. The consolidated suit is hereby consigned to the record room.”

5.

Being aggrieved of the aforementioned judgment and decree dated 08.11.2011, the following appeals/cross-objections came to be preferred by the affected parties:-

a)

Civil Appeal No. 168 of 11.01.2012 titled “Kesar Singh Vs. Achhar Singh and Ors.”

b)

Civil appeal No.196 dated 03.03.2012 titled “Achhar Singh Vs. Kesar Singh”

c)

Civil Appeal No.106 of 29.10.2014 titled “Achhar Singh Vs. Baljeet Kaur”

6.

During pendency thereof, the appellant-plaintiff filed an application seeking amendment of plaint so as to include the relief of declaration as well as permanent injunction qua the entire estate left by deceased-Nahar Singh i.e. the land parcel including 5 kanals 8 marlas of land inherited by him from his deceased brother Bhajan Singh; which inadvertently was earlier not mentioned in the plaint. The said prayer for amendment was allowed by learned First Appellate Court vide order dated 29.01.2018. Operative part of the said application is reproduced hereunder:-

6.

As regards the question of decision of appeal alongwith the application for amendment of plaint is concerned, the law relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondents/defendants is not applicable to the case in hand as in that case, the learned lower Appellate Court allowed the appeal as well as the application for amendment of pleadings and remanded the matter to the learned lower court for decision afresh and in that case, the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court was dealing with the question as to if the matter could have been remanded to the lower court without decision of the appeal or not. But, in the present case, the question is with regard to amendment of plaint and the counsel for the appellants/applicants has stated that he does not want to lead any evidence as the parties have led evidence with regard to the entire facts. He wants to make amendment in the head note of the plaint and relief clause only. The facts of the present case are quite distinguishable and in the present case, the application for amendment of the plaint can be decided before the decision of the appeal and in case the respondents/defendants require to lead any evidence, then the same can be got recorded by referring the matter to the learned lower court.

7.

Simultaneously, an application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 also came to be filed by respondent-defendant No.1 seeking permission to examine Ujjagar Singh as a witness as he could not be examined inter alia on the ground that during the period when evidence of respondent-defendant No.1 was being recorded by learned trial Court, he was out of India. Pertinently, Ujjagar Singh happens to be the second attesting witness to the Will dated 27.01.2003 executed by Nahar Singh in favour of respondent-defendant No.1. The said application filed at the instance of respondent-defendant No.1 was opposed by the appellant-plaintiff however, the same came to be allowed by the learned First Appellate Court vide its order dated 20.03.2018 with the following observations:-

21.

Furthermore, this is a case with regard to interpretation of Will alleged to have been executed by Nahar Singh on 27.1.2003, whereby he has cancelled the earlier Will executed in favour of the plaintiffs and defendant in equal share. It is well settled law that executant of the Will cannot come present and depose before the court with regard to his having executed the Will as the Will is to operate after his death and it is the solemn duty of the court to give effect to the wishes of the dead executant. In the present case DW4 Karnail Singh attesting witness has not supported the case of the appellant/defendant but has admitted his signatures on the Will. He has admitted that it was scribed by Amrik Singh. He has admitted that the second witness was Ujjagar Singh and he is not available in India but he has denied its due execution and attestation. The Will is duly registered document. The appellant/defendant has examined the scribe and official from the office of Sub Registrar. So in such circumstances, only attesting witness Karnail Singh cannot be allowed to hold the appellant/defendant to ransom by coming to the conclusion that the testimony of Ujjagar Singh cannot be permitted to be recorded at the appellate stage particularly when Ujjagar Singh was not available in India at the time when the appellant/defendant was leading evidence during the course of trial and away to UAE. In such circumstances, the case is made out to allow the appellant/defendant to examine Ujjagar Singh as a witness in order to prove the Will dated 27.1.2003.

25.

In such circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that in this case the judgment and decrees passed by the learned lower court are required to be set aside and case is required to be remanded to the learned lower court for fresh decision after affording appellant/defendant Kesar Singh an opportunity to examine Ujjagar Singh as a witness and thereafter affording Achhar Singh etc. an opportunity to lead rebuttal evidence. As such the appeals as well as the cross-objections are allowed and impugned judgment and decrees are set aside and the case is remanded to the learned lower court for fresh decision after affording opportunities to the parties as directed above. The parties through counsels are directed to appear before the successor of learned lower court of Sh. Raman Sharma, Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Samrala on 3.4.2018 at 9.30 a.m. A copy of this judgment be placed on the other connected appeal and cross-objection file. Lower Court files be returned alongwith a copy of this judgment. Appeal files be consigned to the record room.

Assailing the aforesaid decision, the present appeals have been preferred.

8.

Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant submits that the learned First Appellate Court went wrong while allowing the prayer made for production of additional evidence in the form of Ujjagar Singh who happened to be the second attesting witness to Will dated 27.01.2003. He points out that the present was not a case where the evidence sought to be produced at the stage of First Appeal was not within the knowledge of respondent-defendant No.1 despite due diligence. Learned counsel contends that respondent-defendant No.1 neither made any effort to summon Ujjagar Singh during trial nor even applied before the learned trial Court for issuance of commission for his examination in terms of Order XXVI Rule 5 CPC. Learned counsel thus submits that respondent-defendant No.1 could not have been permitted to fill up the lacunae in his evidence at the stage of first appeal and improve the case after an adverse finding was recorded by the learned trial Court. He places reliance upon “N. Kamalam v. Ayyaswamy”, “AIR 2001 SC 2802.

Learned counsel further contends that respondent-defendant No.1 never remained vigilant to pursue his cause. He points out that the first appeal at his instance was filed in January 2012 whereas the application under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC was filed after a gap of more than 5 years i.e. in November, 2017 and thus, the same could not have been entertained. In this regard he places reliance upon decision rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Gobind singh and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.” reported as 2026(4) SCC 130.

Learned counsel further submits that the learned First Appellate Court exclusively went on to adjudicate upon the application made by respondent-defendant No.1 for seeking permission to lead additional evidence and did not examine the evidence which already formed part of the records. In this regard, learned counsel for the appellant places reliance upon Gobind Singh’s case (Supra).

In the alternate learned counsel submits that once sufficient material in the form of evidence held by parties was available on record, learned First Appellate Court at best could have called upon the learned trial Court for submission of its report with respect to the additional evidence rather than setting aside the judgment and decree dated 08.11.2011 passed by the learned trial Court and calling upon it to re-decide the matter.

9.

On the other hand, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondents submits that present was not a case wherein respondent-defendant No.1 ever remained negligent in pursing his cause. He submits that the evidence of respondent-defendant No.1 before the learned trial Court was recorded between from 02.06.2010 to 01.09.2011 and the said period, second attesting witness, namely, Ujjagar Singh was out of India. From the entries made in the passport, he submits that Ujjagar Singh left India and remained abroad(UAE) between 14.04.2010 and 05.03.2012. Learned counsel further submits that evidence of Ujjagar Singh who happened to be second attesting witness to Will dated 27.01.2003 executed in favour of Nahar Singh was very much essential for complete and effective adjudication of case in hand as the same was going to help even the learned trial Court to adjudicate upon the lis between the parties in an effective manner particularly, when the validity of the Will is principal issue between the parties.

Learned counsel further submits that application preferred at the instance of respondent-defendant No.1 seeking permission to examine Ujjagar Singh was an act of due diligence and was therefore rightly accepted by the learned First Appellate Court. Learned counsel contends that in the given facts and circumstances wherein the deposition of Ujjagar Singh was to be recorded in additional evidence followed by grant of permission in favour of appellants-plaintiffs to rebut the same, remand was the most suitable course and was therefore rightly adopted by learned trial Court rather than calling upon learned trial Court to submit its report as regards additional evidence. Learned counsel thus submits that the decision rendred by learned First Appellate Court was based on proper appreciation of the facts and circumstances and thus, calls for no interference.

10.

I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the paper book.

11.

One of the issue between the parties to the lis pertains to the validity of Will dated 27.01.2003 executed by deceased-Nahar Singh in favour of respondent-defendant No.1. In order to prove the same, respondent-defendant no.1 produced one of the attesting witness, namely, Karnail Singh (DW-4) so as to fulfill the requirement of Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 read with Section 68 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The evidence of respondent-defendant No.1 commenced on 02.06.2010 and it concluded on 01.09.2011. During the said period, the deposition of DW-4 namely, Karnail Singh got concluded on 10.02.2011. The other attesting witness namely, Ujjagar Singh could not be examined as he had left India for the UAE on 14.04.2010 and came back on 05.03.2012 whereas, by that time the suit stood concluded before the learned trial Court i.e. on 08.11.2011.

12.

Upon appreciation of the evidence available on record, the learned trial Court vide its judgment dated 08.11.2011 went on to record that the Will dated 27.01.2003 was not proved in accordance with law as Karnail Singh-DW-4 did not prove the valid attestation and the same was therefore, discarded, though the first appeal was filed in January 2012, wherein, the application for seeking additional evidence so as to examine the second witness to the Will namely, Ujjagar Singh was filed. In the humble opinion of this Court, the non-examination of Ujjagar Singh who happened to be the second attesting witness to the Will dated 27.01.2003, in the given facts and circumstances of the present case, particularly, when he had already left for the UAE and remained there between 14.04.2010 to 05.03.2012 cannot be termed to be an act of negligence or deliberate withholding on the part of the respondent-defendant No.1. Mere fact that the respondent-defendant No.1 did not chose to avail of the procedure prescribed under Order 26 Rule 5 of CPC for examination of Ujjagar Singh through Commission cannot by itself, be construed as a lack of due diligence or bona fides.

13.

The question about validity of Will dated 27.01.2003 being the bone of contention between the parties, no jurisdictional error can be found with the well-reasoned discretion exercised by learned First Appellate Court while permitting respondent-defendant No.1 to lead additional evidence in the form of examination of the second attesting witness namely, Ujjagar Singh. However, in the given facts and circumstances, wherein the parties to the suit already led their evidence on all the issues and findings were recorded thereupon by the learned trial Court, rather than setting aside the judgment of the learned trial Court and remitting the matter in its entirety for a fresh trial, the learned First Appellate Court was required to call for a report from the learned trial Court on the additional evidence led by respondent-defendant No.1 in the form of examination of second attesting witness to the Will dated 27.01.2003 namely, Ujjagar Singh and also the evidence in rebuttal thereto by the appellant-plaintiff. The amendment of plaint also did not require de novo trial particularly, when the learned First Appellate Court itself observed that no additional issue was required to be framed and appellants stated that they did not intend to lead further evidence on account of amendment. Therefore, ends of justice would met if additional evidence is recorded in accordance with order XLI Rule 28 CPC and transmitted to the learned First Appellate Court for consideration along with evidence already on record.

14.

Accordingly, the present appeals are disposed of in the above terms while upholding the grant of permission to lead additional evidence in favour of respondent-defendant No.1 subject to the modification that the learned First Appellate shall call for a report thereupon from the learned trial Court on the additional evidence led by the parties and thereafter, proceed to adjudicate upon the appeal on its merits afresh.

15.

Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.

16.

A photocopy of this order be placed on connected case files.