AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard counsel for the appellant. All the cases involve similar issues; hence; they have been taken up together. However, FA/84/2026 is taken as the lead case. The challenge is to order dated 27.07.2022 of State Commission vide which the complaint was dismissed for want of prosecution. The said order is reproduced below:
"Shri Asadullah Khan, learned counsel for complainant pleads no instructions in the matter.
Shri V.K Saxena, learned counsel for opposite party.
This complaint is pending since 19.5.2009. Since learned counsel for complainant pleads no instructions in the matter, it seems that the complainant is also not interested in pursuing the case, therefore, intimating the complainant about the pendency of complaint, by issuing Service Post Card, is not necessary in this matter, because if the complainant was interested in the case, its authorized representative should have remained present
2 In view of the above, complaint is dismissed for want of prosecution."
The review filed against the said order was also dismissed vide the State Commission's order dated 30.10.2025 on merits as well as on account of limitation, having been filed with a delay of 11 months. The present FA has been filed with a delay of 1243 days, as per the calculations made by the Registry. An IA/1512/2026 has been filed seeking condonation of delay, in which the period of delay mentioned is 877 days. If counted from the date of the review order i.e. 30.10.2025, the delay will come to 66 days.
Although the reasons for delay are not found convincing, in the interest of justice, we allow the delay and decide to take up the case on merits.
Coming to the merits of the case, with respect to dismissal of the complaint by the State Commission for want of prosecution vide order dated 27.07.2022, which has been reproduced above, the counsel for the appellant herein argued that initially the complainant was one M/s Bhatia International Ltd., whose name was subsequently changed to Asian Natural Resources (India) Limited. It went into the CIRP process; a moratorium was imposed on it; later, it went into liquidation, and somewhere in 2021, the present appellant i.e. Aavya Real Estate LLP, became the assignee of the erstwhile M/s Bhatia International Ltd./ Asian Natural Resources (India) Limited. The perusal of the record shows that in the consumer complaint, the name of the complainant is shown as M/s Bhatia International Ltd, but in the review application, the name Aavya Real Estate LLP has been reflected, which means the State Commission has taken note of the assignment in favour of the present appellant. After, careful consideration of the entire facts and circumstances of the case, although we do not find any illegality or material irregularity in the orders of the State Commission in dismissing the consumer complaint for want of prosecution on account of the counsel for the complainant pleading no instructions and the complainant themselves not coming forward before the State Commission, we are of the considered view that the interest of justice would be served if the appellant herein is given another opportunity of presenting his case before the State Commission.
Accordingly, we allow the present FA/84/2026 and remand the matter back to the State Commission for fresh disposal on merits after hearing both sides. This is subject to the imposition of cost of Rs.25,000/- to be deposited in the Legal Aid Account of the State Commission within three weeks from today. As soon as the cost is deposited, the State Commission will issue notice to the OPs in said case i.e. the Insurance Company and proceed to dispose of the matter on merits after hearing both sides. It is made clear that we have made no observations on the merits of the case, and the State Commission is free to consider all aspects of the case. It is also made clear that if the appellant herein fails to deposit the cost of Rs.25,000/- in the Legal Aid Account of the State Commission within three weeks, the remand order shall stand withdrawn and FA/84/2026 shall stand dismissed.
FA/85/2026 to FA/89/2026
As these FAs, involving similar facts and issues, these are also disposed of in terms of the above stated orders in FA/84/2026, and these cases are also remanded back to the State Commission for fresh disposal on merits, subject to the condition of depositing Rs.25,000/- in the Legal Aid Account of the State Commission in each of these cases.
With the above said order, all the FAs covered under this order stand disposed of.
Pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed off.
The Registry may send a copy of this order directly to the respondent Insurance Company as well, in addition to sending to the counsel as per the prevailing practice.
