Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 08 NCDRC CK 6782

Aastha Hospital, Multi Specialty Hospital and Trauma Centre & Ors. vs Malkeet Kaur

National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission · Decided on 5 August 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Dr. Inder Jit Singh, Presiding Member · Shashi Nandkeolyar, Member
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
NC/RP/838/2026 (Against the Order dated 09.01.2026 in Appeal No.398 of 2017 of the State Commission Haryana) WITH NC/IA/8907/2026 (Condonation of Delay), NC/IA/8908/2026 (Stay), NC/IA/8909/2026 (Exemption from filing the certified copy)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

10 paragraphs · 1,349 words
1.

Heard learned counsel for the petitioner.

2.

The RP has been filed with a delay of 36 days as per calculations made by the Registry. An IA/8907/2026 has been filed seeking condonation of the delay. The delay in filing the RP is condoned after considering the reasons stated therein and the case is taken up on merits.

3.

The challenge is to the order dated 09.01.2026 of the State Commission vide which first appeal filed by the petitioner herein was dismissed and the order of the District Commission was upheld. Earlier, the District Commission, vide its order dated 09.01.2017, allowed the complaint with the following directions.

'9. Thus, as a sequel to our above discussion, we allow the present complaint and direct the opposite parties to pay a sum of Rs.5,10,755/- to the complainant jointly and severally within a period of two months, failing which the complainant will be entitled to interest on the said amount @9% per annum from the date of order till actual payment. A copy of this order be supplied to the parties as per rules. File be consigned to record room after due compliance."

4.

As has been held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in catena of judgments1 revisional jurisdiction of the National Commission is extremely limited, it should be exercised only in case as contemplated within the parameters specified in the provision i.e. when State Commission had exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law or had failed to exercise jurisdiction so vested or had acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction so vested illegally or with material irregularity. It is only when such findings are found to be against any provisions of law or against the pleadings or evidence or are found to be wholly perverse, a case for interference may call for at the second appellate (revisional) jurisdiction. In exercising of revisional jurisdiction the National Commission has no jurisdiction to interfere with the concurrent findings recorded by the District Forum and the State Commission which are on appreciation of evidence on record. In the present case, there are concurrent findings of both the fora below with respect to medical negligence on the part of the OP Doctors. During the hearing, our attention was drawn to certain medical literature to contend that CBD is a known complication of such operations. Further, drawing our attention to the discharge summary of DMC, Ludhiana, it was argued that even the Doctors, having put question marks in the discharge summary, were not sure of the CBD injury. Reliance was also placed on this Commission's order dated 09.11.2012 in OP/114/1999 to argue that CBD injury is a known complication of laparoscopic cholecystectomy procedure.

5.

We have carefully gone through the orders of the State Commission, District Commission, other relevant records, and the contention of the petitioner herein. The State Commission, after due appreciation of the facts of the case and the evidence before it, in particular the affidavit evidence of Dr. Chiranjiv Singh Gill, Professor of Surgery, General Surgery Department Dayanand Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana, came to the conclusion that there was medical negligence on the part of the OP Doctors in not taking proper post-operative care of the complainant, and agreed with the findings of the District Commission in this regard. Extract of the relevant paragraphs of the order of the State Commission is reproduced below:

10.

Admittedly, on 22.7.2013 complainant was admitted in the hospital of appellants and her gall bladder was removed by appellant No.3/doctor by way of surgery. Admittedly, she was discharged from the hospital on 24.07.2013. Complainant was advised bed rest for 10 days and was asked to come again for check-up on 30.07.2013. After four-five days from the operation, complainant felt severe abdominal pain and started vomiting. Complainant was again admitted in the hospital on 30.07.2013 but when complainant got no relief, she was taken to Dr. Gagandeep Goyal of Bathinda who got conducted report of CECT abdomen from Dr. G.S. Shekhawat, M.D. (Radio Diagnosis) on 05.09.2013. As per the said report there was significant amount of free fluid in perihepatic, perihepatic region, paracolic gutters and pelvis and after MRCP of complainant on 06.09.2013 reported that bile surrounding the CHD near cystic duct stump. Complainant was taken to Dayanand Medical College & Hospital, Ludhiana on 07.09.2013 where after various tests, the doctors found that there was collection of bile in the abdomen and bile leak was present due to injury to the bile duct. Dr. Chiranjiv Singh Gill, Professor of Surgery, General Surgery Department, Dayanand Medical College and Hospital Ludhiana, who treated the complainant at the said hospital has tendered his affidavit on 26.05.2016 and has testified that the patient Malkeet Kaur wife of Sh. Mawa Singh was admitted in their hospital on 07.09.2013 with complaint of distension and pain of abdomen for past 20 days. On examination of the entire medical record of the patient, it revealed that she was operated upon for removing gall bladder at Aastha Hospital, Sirsa, Haryana. At Bathinda the patient was diagnosed with Ultra Sound and C.T. Scan of abdomen and it was found that there has been massive collection in abdomen. Somebody has tried ERCP (Endoscopic Retro Cholangiogram Pancreatogram) but failed to cannulate common bile duct. He has further testified that on 06.09.2013, the patient was operated upon by him for draining the bilious fluid approximately four liters collected in the abdomen. As it was a case of bile leak from common bile duct so definitive procedure for repair of CBD is always done at a later stage, however, before it the life saving draining is done with immediate effect. Patient remained sick and on ventilator for few days but was saved and discharged on 24.09.2013 with drains in side abdomen. Since there had been a need of repair of CBD, the patient was advised to come for the same later on as per protocol. He has further testified that on the perusal of entire earlier medical record of the patient, the deponent found that there had been CBD injury/ clipping but the doctors at Sirsa failed to diagnose the same. It was the duty of the doctor to get the patient diagnosed through some Specialist Radiologist. At the time of removal of gall bladder only cystic duct was to be clipped whereas the common bile duct was clipped and injured which led to leakage of bile juice. There had been failure of diagnoses post-operational complications. A perusal of the history/treatment record of complainant and affidavit of Dr. Chiranjiv Singh Gill reflects that appellant No.3 was negligent while conducting operation of complainant as at the time of removal of gall bladder. There was medical negligence on the part of appellants in not taking proper post-operative care of the complainant. In wake of above discussion, this Commission has arrived at an inescapable conclusion that learned District Consumer Commission has examined all relevant facets/evidence brought on record. There is no fallacy, legal or factual committed by learned District Consumer Commission while passing impugned order dated 09.01.2017. This order is affirmed, maintained and upheld. Present appeal is hereby dismissed being devoid of merit

6.

After careful consideration of the entire facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the considered view that the State Commission has passed a well-reasoned order, and we do not find any reason to interfere with its findings. There is no illegality or material irregularity in the orders of the State Commission. Hence, the order of the State Commission is upheld and, consequently, the RP/838/2026 is dismissed.

7.

All other pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed off.

Footnotes

  1. 1.Ruby (Chandra) Dutta vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2011) 11 SCC 269, Sunil Kumar Maity vs. State Bank of India and Ors. (2022) SCC OnLine SC 77, Lourdes Society Snehanjali Girls Hostel and Another Vs. H & R Johnson (India) Limited and Ors. (2016) 8 SCC 286, T. Ramalingeswara Rao (Dead) Through Legal Representatives and Anr. Vs. N. Madhava Rao and Ors. (2019) 4 SCC 608, Rajiv Shukla Vs. Gold Rush Sales and Services Limited and Anr. (2022) 9 SCC 31