AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
This writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, whereby the petitioner has sought a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing respondent no. 2 to register him as a Pharmacist.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner, who belongs to the Scheduled Caste category, passed his Class X examination in the year 2019 and subsequently appeared in the Joint Entrance Examination Polytechnic (JEEP-2021), securing Rank 137. Thereafter, upon being declared passed in the Class XII examination conducted by the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE), he participated in the counselling process and was granted admission to the two-year Diploma in Pharmacy (D.Pharma) course at Government Polytechnic College, Lohaghat, after submitting all his educational documents. Although his overall result in the Class XII examination was declared as Pass, he had secured 20 marks in Biology theory and 29 marks in practicals, aggregating to 49 marks. The petitioner successfully completed the D.Pharma course in the year 2023, securing First Division, and thereafter completed the mandatory three-month practical training under Regulation 20 of the Education Regulations framed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948. Upon completion of the diploma course and practical training, the petitioner approached the Uttarakhand Pharmacy Council seeking registration as a Pharmacist. However, his application was not processed. Subsequently, upon seeking information under the Right to Information Act, 2005, he was informed that he was not eligible for registration on the ground that he had allegedly failed in Biology in his Class XII examination and, therefore, did not fulfil the eligibility criteria prescribed under Section 32(2) of the Pharmacy Act, 1948. The Pharmacy Council also acknowledged a lapse on the part of the concerned institution in granting admission without ensuring compliance with the prescribed eligibility criteria. Thereafter, the petitioner appeared in the Senior Secondary Examination conducted by the National Institute of Open Schooling (NIOS) and was declared passed, securing 82 marks in Biology, 76 marks in Chemistry and 82 marks in Physics. The petitioner contends that he had disclosed all his educational documents at the time of admission and that the responsibility for verifying his eligibility rested with the concerned institution. Despite successfully completing the diploma course and practical training, he has been denied registration as a Pharmacist, thereby jeopardising his career and future prospects.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner had disclosed all his educational documents, including his Class X and Class XII marksheets, at the time of admission to the D.Pharma course and had neither concealed any material fact nor committed any fraud or misrepresentation. It was contended that the petitioner was declared passed in the Class XII examination by CBSE and was thereafter granted admission to the D.Pharma course by Government Polytechnic College, Lohaghat, after verification of his documents. The petitioner successfully completed the two-year D.Pharma course with First Division and also underwent the mandatory three-month practical training under Regulation 20 of the Education Regulations framed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948. Learned counsel further submitted that the Pharmacy Council itself acknowledged the lapse on the part of the concerned institution in granting admission without properly verifying the petitioner's eligibility. Therefore, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer for the negligence or mistake of the institution. It was also contended that the petitioner subsequently passed his Class XII examination through NIOS, securing 82 marks in Biology, 76 marks in Chemistry and 82 marks in Physics, thereby acquiring the requisite subject qualifications. In such circumstances, denial of registration as a Pharmacist, despite successful completion of the prescribed diploma course and practical training, would cause grave injustice to the petitioner and jeopardise his career for no fault of his own. Accordingly, learned counsel prayed that respondent no. 2 be directed to register the petitioner as a Pharmacist.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the petitioner did not fulfil the mandatory eligibility criteria prescribed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948, for admission to the D.Pharma course, as he had failed to secure the requisite passing marks in Biology in his Class XII examination conducted by CBSE. It was contended that passing the prescribed qualifying subjects, namely Physics, Chemistry and Biology or Mathematics, is an essential requirement for admission to the D.Pharma course and that mere completion of the diploma course and practical training cannot confer eligibility for registration when the statutory requirements have not been fulfilled. It was further submitted that the subsequent qualification obtained by the petitioner through NIOS cannot automatically validate his earlier admission or confer upon him a retrospective right to registration. Accordingly, the petitioner is not entitled to claim registration merely on the basis of having completed the D.Pharma course, and the action of the Pharmacy Council in refusing registration is justified in view of the statutory provisions governing the same.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and upon careful consideration of the material available on record, this Court finds that the controversy involved in the present writ petition primarily relates to the petitioner's entitlement to registration as a Pharmacist despite the objection raised by the Pharmacy Council regarding his eligibility in the Class XII examination.
It is not disputed that the petitioner was declared passed in the Senior Secondary Examination conducted by CBSE and was subsequently granted admission to the two-year D.Pharma course at Government Polytechnic College, Lohaghat. It is also evident from the record that the petitioner submitted all his educational documents, including his Class X and Class XII marksheets, at the time of admission. He thereafter successfully completed the D.Pharma course in 2023 with First Division and also completed the prescribed three-month practical training under Regulation 20 of the Education Regulations framed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948.
This Court further takes note of the fact that there is no allegation against the petitioner that he concealed any educational qualification, submitted forged documents or committed any fraud or misrepresentation at the time of admission. Rather, the Pharmacy Council itself acknowledged the lapse on the part of the concerned institution in granting admission without ensuring compliance with the prescribed eligibility criteria. In such circumstances, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer for an error or negligence committed by the educational institution, particularly when all relevant documents had been disclosed by him at the time of admission.
This Court is conscious of the fact that the eligibility conditions prescribed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948, and the regulations framed thereunder are mandatory in nature and cannot be overlooked merely on equitable considerations. However, the subsequent qualification acquired by the petitioner through NIOS, wherein he secured 82 marks in Biology, 76 marks in Chemistry and 82 marks in Physics, is also a relevant circumstance which deserves consideration while examining his claim for registration. In the instant case also, as stated, the petitioner may not be presumed to know as to what was the minimum marks prescribed by the Pharmacy Council for registering the petitioner as Pharmacist. He had submitted his documents. It is not the case of any of the respondents that the petitioner at any stage, withheld the documents and gave forged documents. The percentage of marks which he filled is aggregate of five best subjects. This is admittedly, the mistake of the respondent no.2-College. The petitioner did not make any misrepresentation, did not play any fraud and did not conceal anything and, in fact, disclosed every documents.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the respondents are required to examine the petitioner's claim in the light of his subsequent qualification, the diploma certificate issued by the competent authority, the completion of the prescribed practical training and the circumstances in which admission was granted to him. The petitioner's claim cannot be rejected merely by attributing the entire responsibility for the admission-related lapse to him, without examining the effect of his subsequent qualification and the applicable statutory provisions.
Accordingly writ petition stands allowed. Respondent-Competent Authority is directed to register the petitioner as Pharmacist based on his course completion certificate given by respondent no.2 and respondent no.4.
