AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Background:-
One Mr.Velanganni Joseph, Professor and Head of the Department of Youth Welfare Studies, Madurai Kamaraj University, has filed WP(MD)No.23417 of 2026, seeking issuance of a writ of quo warranto calling upon Dr.S.Muthiah to show cause under what authority he continues to hold the post of Registrar (in-charge) of Madurai Kamaraj University.
According to the petitioner, Dr.S.Muthiah, who is functioning as Registrar (in-charge) of the University, does not belong to the Professor cadre and as such, not eligible to be appointed to the said post. It was further contended that the very same person is also holding the post of Controller of Examinations (in-charge).
When the writ petition was taken up for hearing on 19.08.2026, Mr.Isaac Mohanlal, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Registrar (in-charge), submitted that the third respondent was functioning as Registrar (in-charge) only as an interim arrangement and that he possessed the requisite qualifications. He further submitted that the appointment was made by the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee, who was competent to make such an appointment in the absence of a Vice-Chancellor. He also brought to the notice of this Court that the process of appointing a regular Registrar had already commenced and that a notification had been issued on 02.06.2026, fixing 08.07.2026 as the last date for receipt of applications. Therefore, he submitted that a regular Registrar would be appointed shortly.
During the course of hearing, it was pointed out by the learned Counsel across the Bar that nearly 14 Universities in the State of Tamil Nadu were functioning without regular Vice-Chancellors. In their absence, the functions of the Vice-Chancellors were being discharged by Convenor Committees, while the day-to-day administration of the Universities was being carried on by Registrars (in-charge). It was submitted that such arrangements had adversely affected the proper administration of the Universities.
Since it was brought to the notice of this Court that the process of appointing a regular Registrar in Madurai Kamaraj University had already commenced pursuant to the notification dated 02.06.2026, this Court expressed its disinclination to entertain the writ petition. However, taking note of the submissions made across the Bar regarding the prolonged vacancies in the posts of Vice-Chancellors, Registrars and other key functionaries in several Universities, this Court, by order dated 19.08.2026, called for a report from the Government explaining the reasons for not filling up the post of Vice-Chancellor and the steps taken by the existing administration to fill up the vacant posts.
The filing of WP(MD)No.23417 of 2026 and the interim order passed by this Court on 19.08.2026 appear to have provided the backdrop for the subsequent writ petitions concerning the affairs of Madurai Kamaraj University.
It appears that 12 members of the Senate of Madurai Kamaraj University submitted a joint representation to the Chancellor of the University / Hon'ble Governor of Tamil Nadu, raising certain concerns regarding the administration of the University and the need to ensure that appointments to key positions, including those of Nodal Officers, are made in accordance with the rules, statutes and regulations of the University. The grievances raised in the representation are as follows:-
(i)The University had been functioning without a regular Vice-Chancellor for nearly two years. In the absence of an academic head, the University was being administered by a Convenor Committee, which did not have any academicians as its members. It was contended that this had adversely affected the academic standards and reputation of the institution.
(ii)The Convenor / Commissioner of Collegiate Education had appointed Dr.S.Muthiah as Registrar (in-charge), contrary to the rules and statutes of the University. It was contended that he did not belong to the Professor cadre and was not eligible to be appointed to the said post. It was further pointed out that the very same person was also functioning as Controller of Examinations (in-charge), contrary to the rules of the University.
(iii)In the absence of a regular Vice-Chancellor, important positions such as Registrar and Controller of Examinations were being occupied by persons from clerical cadre, instead of academicians, through in-charge arrangements. It was contended that such arrangements had resulted in delays in decision-making and affected the University's ability to take important academic decisions and improve its standards.
The representation appears to have been submitted on 21.08.2026, two days after the interim order passed by this Court on 19.08.2026. The complaints raised therein were forwarded by the Chancellor to the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee on 28.08.2026 for appropriate action. It further appears that the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee, by proceedings dated 02.09.2026, directed that show cause notices be issued to the Senate members who had submitted the representation, with the following endorsement:-
“Matter is in court. Explanation may be called through a show cause for wrong information.”
Pursuant to the above direction, the Registrar (in-charge) of Madurai Kamaraj University, Dr.S.Muthiah, issued show cause notices to the Senate members who had submitted the joint representation. Aggrieved by the issuance of the said notices, five of the Senate members have approached this Court by filing WP(MD)Nos.27234 to 27238 of 2026.
Apart from the above writ petitions, three Senate members have filed WP(MD)No.28453 of 2026, seeking issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the University authorities to consider the above mentioned joint representation dated 21.08.2026, in accordance with the rules, statutes and regulations of the University.
This Court heard the submissions made by the learned Counsel appearing for the respective parties and also perused the materials placed on record.
Allegations and Counter-allegations:-
The petitioners in WP(MD)Nos.27234 to 27238 of 2026 contend that they have been penalised by issuing show cause notice, for having raised the issues regarding administration and academic quality of the University to the Chancellor. They have raised the following allegations against Dr.S.Muthiah, Registrar (in-charge):-
Dr.S.Muthiah was appointed as a Clerk in the University on compassionate grounds in the year 1993 and was thereafter promoted from time to time. He was appointed as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) on 20.12.2024 and subsequently as Registrar (in-charge) on 02.03.2026. According to the petitioners, he does not belong to the cadre of Professors and is not eligible to hold the post of Registrar. They further contend that he is holding the posts of Registrar and Controller of Examinations simultaneously, contrary to the principle that one person should not hold more than one post.
The petitioners rely upon the Syndicate resolutions dated 29.01.2020 and 04.08.2021, by which it was resolved that one person should not hold more than one post. They also refer to the Syndicate resolution dated 18.08.2023, which contemplated that faculty members belonging to the cadre of Professors should be appointed as Nodal Officers in future. According to them, the appointment of persons outside the Professor cadre to such important positions is contrary to the resolutions of the Syndicate and affects the proper administration of the University.
It is further alleged that one Tmt.Dhanalakshmi, Superintendent, Public Relations Office of the University, had lodged a complaint of sexual harassment against Dr.S.Muthiah before the Internal Complaints Committee and that the complaint is pending consideration.
The petitioners have also questioned the qualifications possessed by Dr.S.Muthiah at the time of his initial appointment in the University. According to them, he possessed only a Bachelor's degree when he entered service and acquired his Master's degree and Ph.D. only thereafter.
In response to the above allegations, Dr.S.Muthiah has raised counter-allegations against some of the Senate members and other University officials. He has relied upon the following complaints and proceedings:-
One Dr.Sivasubramanian, a former research scholar, submitted a complaint dated 07.04.2025 against Dr.Velanganni Joseph, alleging that he had subjected him to humiliation on caste grounds, denied him a research seat, demanded money for approval of research-related work and misused the RGNF portal by submitting forged documents. It is further pointed out that a charge memo was issued to Dr.Velanganni Joseph on 30.07.2026 in connection with the allegations.
A complaint was submitted by the SC/ST Faculty and Non-Teaching Staff Association against Dr.P.Raj Kumar, alleging caste-based discrimination and harassment. He has also referred to the enquiry initiated in respect of the said complaint.
A Ph.D. scholar submitted a complaint dated 30.01.2025 alleging sexual harassment against Dr.R.Asokan, Professor and Head of the School of Mathematics. The Internal Complaints Committee, by its report dated 17.03.2025, reportedly found the allegations proved. The Syndicate thereafter resolved, on 03.07.2026, to place Dr.R.Asokan under suspension, and the matter is stated to be pending approval of the Chancellor.
Dr.S.Muthiah has also referred to complaints and allegations exchanged between Dr.G.Kumaresan and Dr.M.Murugan, Associate Professor and Head of the Department of Microbial Technology. The allegations include aggressive behaviour, coercion for obtaining a No Objection Certificate, favouritism on caste and community considerations, and irregularities in the utilisation of research funds. An enquiry committee was constituted on 17.02.2025 to look into the complaints.
Earlier Instances Reflecting Administrative Irregularities:-
Apart from the allegations and counter-allegations referred to above, this Court has also dealt with certain other issues concerning the administration of Madurai Kamaraj University. In WP(MD)No.8025 of 2020, a Division Bench of this Court took note of the pending vigilance enquiry into serious irregularities in the University, including malpractices in the conduct of examinations, collection of fees, missing answer sheets and issuance of fake certificates. By order dated 22.03.2021, the Division Bench directed the Director of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption to constitute a Special Team to investigate the irregularities in the conduct of examinations and issuance of false certificates, including false PSTM certificates, by the University. The said order was challenged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP(Civil)Nos.3364 to 3367 of 2022, which came to be dismissed on 31.07.2023.
The Special Team thereafter collected details of candidates who had secured appointments to Group-I services under the PSTM quota on the strength of fake PSTM certificates issued by the University. The Special Team addressed communications to the University seeking relevant records relating to the degree and PSTM certificates of those candidates. However, the University delayed furnishing the required documents and took the stand that certain records were unavailable. In view of the non-furnishing of the records, the petitioner in WP(MD)No.8025 of 2020 initiated contempt proceedings in Cont.P.(MD)No.918 of 2021, alleging non-compliance with the directions issued by the Division Bench. The University was subsequently impleaded as a party to the contempt proceedings. It was only after the Division Bench issued directions requiring the University to extend full cooperation to the investigating agency that the necessary records were furnished.
The Division Bench, in its order dated 05.06.2026, recorded the manner in which the officials of the University, including the Registrar, had delayed the investigation into the issue of bogus PSTM certificates in the distance education courses conducted by the University. The relevant observations are extracted below:
“9.... Even though the order to conclude the investigation into the issue of fake degree certificates was issued as early as on 22.03.2021, the Vigilance Department expressed difficulty to conclude the investigation on account of non-cooperation from the university authorities. The universities which are statutory authorities meant to uphold the standards of higher education have dragged their feet in providing the documents required for the investigation being undertaken by the Vigilance Department.
10.The Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance and Anti Corruption Department has filed a status report dated 25.08.2022 stating that the enquiry on the issuance of fake degree certificates was pending due to non-availability of the required documents from the Madurai Kamaraj University. ...
11.Therefore, this Court by order dated 25.08.2022, impleaded the Registrar, Madurai Kamaraj University, Madurai, as a party to this contempt petition. Thereafter, things moved a little further. However, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption has filed another status report on 09.02.2023 stating that documents such as the registers, foil cards, answer sheets, applications and provisional certificates of various candidates were not provided by the Madurai Kamaraj University to the Vigilance Department.
12.Strangely, the Madurai Kamaraj University has taken a stand during the course of the contempt proceedings that the above documents such as the foil cards of the candidates which are required to be maintained permanently and are necessary for the vigilance investigation are missing from the university records. ...
13.The blatant non-cooperation on the part of the Madurai Kamaraj University and its officials despite repeated requests from the Vigilance Department has prompted this Court to expand the scope of the investigation by way of order dated 23.06.2023 to examine the manner in which this University and its officials are functioning. Only after the stern orders of this Court, the Madurai Kamaraj University has extended its cooperation and finally, the investigation agency has found that fake PSTM certificates have indeed been issued to four candidates, by which, they have also got appointment to posts in Group-I service. The investigation has revealed that all these candidates claim to have enrolled in various courses at Madurai Kamaraj University through various study centres at the fag end of the academic year. It has also revealed irregularities in the registration process, discrepancies in the payment of their tuition and registration fees and that all the candidates have taken up all the papers during the final year and cleared the courses in a single go. Some of the candidates have also changed their stream and joined the courses against the prospectus of the University.”
Though the investigation into these irregularities commenced in the year 2021, the process of verifying the records relating to the candidates from the University itself took nearly three years. On verification of the records, the Vigilance Department found that certain Group-I officers had obtained bogus degree certificates without following the prescribed admission procedure or paying the requisite registration fees. In this regard, a regular case in Crime No.12 of 2024 was registered on 03.10.2024 against the Government servants concerned and certain officials of the University for the offences under Sections 120-B, 420, 465, 467, 468, 167 and 471 read with Section 109 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The allegation was that the officials concerned had aided and abetted the candidates in obtaining bogus PSTM certificates.
This Court has also come across another instance reflecting the consequences of prolonged administrative inaction on the part of the University. The Secretary of Devanga Arts College (Autonomous), Aruppukottai, affiliated to Madurai Kamaraj University, lodged a complaint dated 16.04.2018 before the Aruppukottai Town Police Station, referring to complaints made by certain girl students of the College. The complaint alleged that one Nirmala Devi, Assistant Professor (Mathematics) of the said College, had demanded sexual favours from the students for officers of the Madurai Kamaraj University and other higher-ups, promising them better academic prospects, careers and employment opportunities. Based on the complaint, an FIR in Crime No.170 of 2018 was registered against Nirmala Devi on 16.04.2018. Subsequently, the investigation was transferred to the CB-CID, South Police Station, Virudhunagar, and an FIR in Crime No.1 of 2018 was registered on 18.04.2018. During the course of the investigation, one V.Murugan, Assistant Professor, Department of Management Studies, Madurai Kamaraj University, and one Karuppusamy, a Ph.D. Scholar, were also arrayed as accused on the allegation that they were involved in demanding sexual favours from the girl students through Nirmala Devi. Thereafter, the University issued a charge memo dated 03.02.2023 framing seven charges against V.Murugan. However, the University took more than two years to conclude the enquiry, and the enquiry report, holding all the charges proved, was submitted only on 14.11.2025.
In the meantime, the trial Court, by judgment dated 29.04.2024 in SC.No.145 of 2018, convicted Nirmala Devi and acquitted V.Murugan and Karuppusamy. Relying upon his acquittal in the criminal case, V.Murugan approached the Tamil Nadu State Commission for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, alleging that the University was refusing to reinstate him despite his acquittal and that such refusal was on account of caste discrimination. The Secretary of the Tamil Nadu State Commission for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, by order dated 12.12.2025, stayed the enquiry proceedings against V.Murugan. Aggrieved by the said order, the University filed WP(MD)No.36857 of 2025, which is pending before this Court.
Thus, despite the charge memo having been issued in February 2023, the disciplinary enquiry was concluded only in November 2025. Even thereafter, the disciplinary proceedings could not reach their logical conclusion in view of the subsequent order passed by the State Commission, which has been challenged by the University. Consequently, V.Murugan, who has been under suspension since 2018, continues to receive subsistence allowance without attending to any work, while the disciplinary proceedings remain unresolved. Such prolonged pendency of proceedings involving grave allegations against a University faculty member cannot but affect the credibility and reputation of the institution.
The above instances appear to be only the tip of the iceberg and indicate that all is not well with the administration of Madurai Kamaraj University. The University was established with the object of imparting education, promoting research and advancing and disseminating knowledge in diverse branches of learning. It was also intended to promote postgraduate education, extend educational opportunities and facilitate the overall development of higher learning and research. Sadly, instead of working towards these objectives, the University appears to be spending a considerable part of its time and resources in dealing with litigations arising out of maladministration and other improper practices within the institution.
Vacancies and Prolonged In-charge Arrangements in Statutory Posts:-
This Court is also concerned about the manner in which several full-time positions and other statutory offices in the University have remained vacant for a prolonged period, with their functions being discharged through in-charge or temporary arrangements. Arrangements intended to be purely temporary or to serve as stop-gap measures have virtually become permanent. This Court has taken note of the following:-
The position of Vice-Chancellor, which is intended to be a full-time position, has remained vacant, with the Commissioner of Collegiate Education functioning as the Convenor and exercising the powers and duties of the Vice-Chancellor for more than two years;
The duties of the Controller of Examinations have been discharged by persons holding the post on an in-charge basis for more than six years, even though neither the MKU Act nor the Laws of the University provide for such an in-charge arrangement for this post; and
The post of Registrar has remained vacant since 2019, with its duties being continuously discharged by persons appointed on an in-charge basis.
Controller of Examinations:-
Chapter XI, Section 12 of the Laws of the University provides for the post of Controller of Examinations. The Controller of Examinations is responsible for the conduct of examinations in the University, custody of examination records, issuance of notices convening meetings of the Boards of Question Paper Setters and Board of Examiners and other committees connected with examinations. The Controller is also required to route all papers having a bearing on the administration of the University or decisions of any of its bodies through the Registrar. As per the said provision, the post is a full-time post with a term of three years. It is pertinent to note that neither the MKU Act nor the Laws of the University provide for any temporary or in-charge appointment to this post. However, the University has been functioning with an in-charge Controller of Examinations for more than six years.
It appears that one Dr.T.Dharmaraj, Professor and Head of the Department of Folklore and Culture Studies, served as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) for a period of four years, from 02.11.2020 to 20.12.2024. Thereafter, Dr.S.Muthiah, who was then serving as Senior Deputy Registrar of the University, was appointed as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) on 20.12.2024 by the then Registrar (in-charge), pursuant to the directions of the Convenor, Syndicate Committee. The said appointment was ratified by the Syndicate on 07.11.2025.
Registrar:-
The Registrar of the University is recognised as an Officer of the University under Section 8 of the MKU Act. Section 13 of the Act provides that the Registrar shall be a whole-time paid officer of the University, appointed by the Syndicate. Chapter VI, Section 2 of the Laws of the University prescribes a term of three years for the post of Registrar. The duties attached to this post are vital in nature. The Registrar is the custodian of the records and common seal of the University, the Secretary to the Syndicate, is responsible for signing contracts and agreements on behalf of the University and is also responsible for the transfer of non-teaching staff. However, Chapter VI, Section 8(i) of the Laws of the University provides for an interim arrangement when the office of Registrar is vacant or when the Registrar is unable to perform his duties. In such circumstances, the duties of the Registrar may be performed by a person appointed by the Vice-Chancellor with the approval of the Syndicate. The provision reads as follows:
“8(i) When the office of the Registrar is vacant or when the Registrar is, by reason of illness, absence or any other cause, unable to perform the duties of his office, the duties of the office of the Registrar shall be performed by such person as the Vice-Chancellor may appoint for the purpose with the approval of the Syndicate (as per Governor's office letter dated 09.11.2010).”
A conjoint reading of Section 13 of the MKU Act and Chapter VI, Section 2 of the Laws of the University makes it clear that the post of Registrar is a regular, whole-time post, carrying a prescribed term of three years. Chapter VI, Section 8(i), on the other hand, provides only for a temporary arrangement to ensure that the functions of the office do not remain unattended during a vacancy or the inability of the Registrar to discharge his duties. Such an arrangement is necessarily intended to operate until a regular appointment is made. However, the arrangement of having an in-charge Registrar has continued since 2019 and has virtually become a regular practice.
The prolonged use of such in-charge arrangements raises serious concerns regarding accountability. It has resulted in a situation where one in-charge officer appoints another in-charge officer, and the practice continues. Further, when appointments are made through such arrangements, the suitability and qualifications of the persons concerned may not undergo the same assessment as in the regular appointment process. This Court is concerned as to whether such arrangements, when continued for long periods, can provide the institutional stability and long-term vision necessary for the proper administration and academic development of the University.
The above concerns are also reflected in the appointment of Dr.S.Muthiah as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) and Registrar (in-charge). Dr.S.Muthiah, who was then serving as Senior Deputy Registrar, was appointed as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) on 20.12.2024. The appointment order was issued in the name of the then Registrar (in-charge). However, the minutes of the Syndicate meeting dated 07.11.2025, by which the appointment was subsequently ratified, reveal that the appointment was made pursuant to the directions of the Convenor, Syndicate Committee. The relevant portion of the minutes is extracted below:
“... 2. As per the orders of the Convenor, Syndicate Committee, dated 20.12.2024, Dr.S.Muthiah, Senior Deputy Registrar was nominated as Controller of Examinations in-charge with effect from 20.12.2024 until further orders in the place of Dr. T. Dharmaraj.” Subsequently, the very same Dr.S.Muthiah was appointed as Registrar (in-charge) on 02.03.2026, again by the Convenor, Syndicate Committee. This appointment was also subsequently ratified by the Syndicate on 03.07.2026.
It is relevant to note that Chapter VI, Section 12(a) of the Laws of the University requires the Senior Deputy Registrar to devote his whole time to the duties of his office. However, Dr.S.Muthiah, while holding that post, was also appointed to two other posts. Further, the Syndicate, in its meeting dated 18.08.2023, had resolved that faculty members belonging to the Professor cadre should be appointed as Nodal Officers in-charge in future. The Syndicate had also adopted the policy of “one man-one post” in its meetings dated 29.01.2020 and 04.08.2021. The relevant resolutions are extracted below:
Meeting of the Syndicate held on 29.01.2020:
“Item No.32 Resolved to adopt one man in one post policy in all the positions of the university.”
Meeting of the Syndicate held on 04.08.2021:
“Item No.5 ... ... ... Resolved further that to adopt one man in one post policy in all the positions of the University.”
However, Dr.S.Muthiah, who does not belong to the Professor cadre, has been appointed as Controller of Examinations (in-charge) as well as Registrar (in-charge). Thus, he is holding three posts simultaneously, namely, Senior Deputy Registrar, Controller of Examinations (in-charge) and Registrar (in-charge). It is reported that steps have been taken to appoint full-time Registrars and Controllers of Examinations by issuing a notification dated 02.06.2026. Nevertheless, the fact remains that the University has been functioning with in-charge Registrars and Controllers of Examinations for nearly six years. These appointments also appear to have been made with the approval of the Convenor, Syndicate Committee, who is the Commissioner of Collegiate Education, an IAS officer.
Writ of Quo Warranto and the Appointment of the Registrar (in- charge):-
A writ of quo warranto is a judicial remedy intended to prevent the unlawful occupation of a public office and to ensure that appointments to such offices are made in accordance with law. Its object is to protect public interest by ensuring that no person occupies a public office without lawful authority. In B.R.Kapur v. State of Tamil Nadu [(2001) 7 SCC 231], the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained the scope of a writ of quo warranto as follows:-
“79.… A writ of quo warranto is a writ which lies against the person, who according to the relator is not entitled to hold an office of public nature and is only a usurper of the office. It is the person, against whom the writ of quo warranto is directed, who is required to show, by what authority that person is entitled to hold the office. The challenge can be made on various grounds, including on the grounds that the possessor of the office does not fulfil the required qualifications or suffers from any disqualification, which debars the person to hold such office. ...”
An office created by or under a statute, including the statutory offices of a University, can constitute a public office for the purpose of issuing a writ of quo warranto. In this regard, it is relevant to refer to the decision in Rajendrakumar v. State Government of M.P. [1957 SCC OnLine MP 66], wherein it was held that the offices of the Vice-Chancellor, Registrar and other officers of a University established under a statute are offices of a public nature and that a writ of quo warranto can be issued against persons occupying such offices. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:-
“... As regards the first question there is no doubt that the offices of Chancellor, Vice-Chancellor and other Officers of the University in respect of which the writ is prayed for are important offices of public nature and sought to be held under a Statute. For the issue of a writ of quo-warranto no special kind of interest in the relator is needed nor is it necessary that any of his specific legal right be infringed. It is enough for its issue that the relator is a member of the public and acts bona-fide and is not a mere pawn in the game having been set up by others. If the Court is of the view that it is in the interest of the public that the legal position with respect to the alleged usurpation of an important public office should be judicially cleared, it can issue a writ of quo-warranto at the instance of any member of the public. The authorities on this point are practically unanimous. ... ... ...
As regards the Assistant Registrar, it is said, that there is no such officer provided for in the Act and that therefore no writ can issue in respect of an office which has no legal existence. This contention is not well founded. The Assistant Registrar practically performed the duties of the Registrar. He invited the registered graduates to file their nomination-papers and issued blank nomination forms for the purpose. He evidently purported to take proceedings for the election to the Senate from amongst the Registered Graduates of the University'. In so doing he purported to act as a Registrar under Section 7(iii)(d) and (e). It is held in In re Banwarilal Roy [48 C.W.H. 266.] that a writ of quo-warranto lies where there is in substance a usurpation though the name of the office may not have been assumed by the respondent. The principle of this case applies ...”
In the present case, the post of Registrar is a statutory office recognised under Section 8 of the MKU Act. The provision for making an interim arrangement when the office of Registrar is vacant is contained in Chapter VI, Section 8(i) of the Laws of the University. Dr.S.Muthiah is presently discharging the functions of the Registrar under such an arrangement. Though he has contended that his appointment is only temporary and that he does not occupy a regular post, the fact remains that he has been discharging the functions of the Registrar for a considerable period. Further, the circumstances in which he was appointed, the authority under which the appointment was made, and the subsequent ratification by the Syndicate, raise questions regarding compliance with the statutory provisions governing the appointment. His simultaneous appointment as Controller of Examinations (in-charge), despite the Syndicate's resolutions concerning the one-person-one-post policy, also requires examination. In these circumstances, this Court is of the view that Dr.S.Muthiah, the incumbent Registrar (in-charge), should be called upon to explain under what authority he is holding the said office.
The Office of the Vice-Chancellor and the Role of the Chancellor:-
The MKU Act, 1965, provides that the Vice-Chancellor shall be the academic head and the principal executive officer of the University. He is also the ex-officio member and Chairman of the Syndicate, the Academic Council and the Finance Committee, and exercises general control over the affairs of the University. The importance of the office of Vice-Chancellor has been emphasised by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gambhirdan K. Gadhvi v. State of Gujarat [(2022) 5 SCC 179], wherein it was observed as follows:-
“53.It is to be noted that the post of Vice-Chancellor of the university is a very important post so far as the university is concerned. Being a leader and head of the institution, the Vice-Chancellor of the university has to play very important role. While academic qualifications, administrative experience, research credentials and track record could be considered as basic eligibility requirements, the greater qualities of a Vice-Chancellor would be one who is a true leader and a passionate visionary. A Vice Chancellor needs to be one who understands and handles the affairs of the university as ethical business and maintains a pellucidity in his conduct towards the betterment of the university as well as the students therein. A Vice-Chancellor should be one who can inspire students and guarantee entry of high quality teachers into the university system. A Vice-Chancellor functions as a bridge between the executive and academic wings of a university as he is the head of both a “teacher” and an “administrator”. ... ... ...
56.Thus, universities are autonomous and the Vice-Chancellor is the leader of a higher education institution. As per the norm, he/she should be an eminent academician, excellent administrator and also someone who has a high moral stature. The aforesaid reports of the Radhakrishnan Commission, Kothari Commission, Gnanam Committee and Ramlal Parikh Committee have highlighted the importance of the role of Vice-Chancellor in maintaining the quality and relevance of universities, in addition to its growth and development, keeping in view, the much needed changes from time to time. Further, these committees have also made suggestions and recommendations for identifying the right person for the said position. At this stage, it is correct to say that a Vice-Chancellor is the kingpin of a university's system and a keeper of the university's conscience.”
The above observations make it clear that the office of the Vice-Chancellor is central to the academic and administrative functioning of a University. Just as a body cannot function without its head, an educational institution cannot effectively discharge its functions or achieve its academic objectives, without a head to lead and guide its affairs. In the present case, the University has been functioning without a regular Vice-Chancellor for more than two years. In the meantime, the Commissioner of Collegiate Education has been exercising the powers and discharging the duties of the Vice-Chancellor as the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee. In this regard, Chapter V, Section 11(4) of the Laws of the University provides as follows:-
“3.When any temporary vacancy occurs in the office of the Vice-Chancellor, the Syndicate shall, as soon as possible, subject to the approval of the Chancellor, make the requisite arrangements for exercising the powers and performing the duties of the Vice-Chancellor.”
The same provision also contemplates that, when a permanent vacancy occurs or is about to occur in the office of the Vice-Chancellor, the Registrar shall, under the direction of the Syndicate, take immediate steps for constituting a committee to recommend candidates for appointment to the post. Thus, the arrangement contemplated under the provision is intended to ensure the discharge of the Vice-Chancellor's functions during a vacancy, pending the appointment of a regular Vice-Chancellor. However, the University has continued without a regular Vice-Chancellor for more than two years, with the Commissioner of Collegiate Education exercising those powers in the capacity of Convenor. This Court does not want to presume that the Government has deliberately delayed the appointment of a regular Vice-Chancellor merely because the Commissioner is exercising the powers of that office. Nevertheless, the continued absence of a regular Vice-Chancellor for such a long period has given rise to serious concerns regarding the administration and functioning of the University.
It is also relevant to note that Chapter V, Section 12-A of the Laws of the University prescribes clear educational qualifications and experience requirements for the post of Vice-Chancellor. As per this provision, the Vice-Chancellor is required to possess a Ph.D. degree in any discipline, have experience in teaching and research in Universities or postgraduate colleges, at least six years of administrative experience in Universities or postgraduate colleges, and academic and research publications. These requirements make it clear that the post is intended to be occupied by a person with a strong academic and research background. However, the powers and functions of the Vice-Chancellor are presently being exercised by the Commissioner of Collegiate Education, an IAS officer, in the capacity of Convenor, who does not possess the above qualifications and experience. If such an arrangement is allowed to continue for an indefinite period, the academic development of the University would certainly be at risk.
It is also relevant to note that the Hon'ble Governor of Tamil Nadu, by virtue of his position, is the Chancellor of the Madurai Kamaraj University. Section 9 of the MKU Act provides that the Chancellor shall be the Head of the University and the President of its supreme governing body, namely, the Senate, and shall preside over the meetings of the Senate and the convocation of the University. The Chancellor thus has an important role and responsibility in ensuring the proper functioning and academic development of the University. Though the original provision under Section 11 empowered the Chancellor to appoint the Vice-Chancellor from the panel of names recommended by the Search Committee, the said provision was subsequently amended by the Tamil Nadu Universities Laws (Amendment) Act, 2025 (Tamil Nadu Act 16 of 2025), vesting the power of appointment in the State Government. The validity of the said amendment is presently under challenge before the First Bench of this Court. In the meantime, the University has remained without a regular Vice-Chancellor for more than two years. It is unfortunate that the matter has remained unresolved between the Chancellor and the State Government, with neither side being able to bring about a resolution. Ultimately, it is the University and, more particularly, its students and academic community who are bearing the brunt of this prolonged disagreement.
It is the contention of the Registrar (in-charge) that several complaints are pending against the members of the Senate, some of which contain allegations of harassment and caste-based discrimination. However, all these complaints are still under enquiry and no findings have been arrived at. Insofar as Dr.R.Asokan is concerned, the Internal Complaints Committee submitted a report dated 17.03.2025 to the Syndicate, holding that all the charges levelled against him were proved. However, no action was taken on the report for nearly fourteen months. It was only on 03.07.2026 that the Syndicate resolved to place Dr.R.Asokan under suspension, pending further orders. On the other hand, the members of the Senate have alleged that the Registrar (in-charge) himself is facing a sexual harassment complaint before the Internal Complaints Committee. These allegations and counter-allegations, coupled with the other instances narrated supra, strengthens the concerns raised by this Court regarding the manner in which the University is being administered.
The Madurai Kamaraj University, established in the year 1965, was initially headed by Dr.T.P.Meenakshisundaram, a recipient of the Padma Bhushan, as its first Vice-Chancellor. The University also achieved the status of an Institution with Potential for Excellence in 2005, as one among nine Universities recognised with that status during that year. However, its position in the National Institutional Ranking Framework has witnessed a decline. It was ranked 45th among Universities in 2019, 53rd in 2023, 63rd in 2024 and 85th in 2025. The absence of a regular Vice-Chancellor, decline in funding, maladministration and the various controversies surrounding the University could be among the factors contributing to this decline.
WP(MD)Nos.27234 to 27238 of 2026 relate to the show-cause notices issued by the Registrar (in-charge) to certain members of the Senate of the Madurai Kamaraj University. Section 16 of the Madurai Kamaraj University Act, 1965, provides for the constitution of the Senate and recognises it as the Supreme Governing Body of the University. As already noted, twelve members of the Senate, which is the Supreme Governing Body of the University, had submitted a joint representation raising concerns regarding the appointment of the Registrar (in-charge) by the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee and the academic development of the University. In the absence of a regular Vice-Chancellor, the members of the Senate were entitled to bring such concerns to the notice of the Chancellor, who is the Head of the University.
However, instead of addressing the concerns raised by the members of the Senate, show-cause notices came to be issued to them at the instance of the Convenor, Syndicate Committee, against whom certain allegations had been raised in the representation. The typed set of papers filed by the Registrar (in-charge) also brings out the manner in which these show-cause notices came to be issued.
The pendency of litigation cannot be a bar for members of the Senate to raise administrative issues and academic concerns before the Head of the University. Further, this Court has not taken a final decision in WP(MD)No.23417 of 2026 and had only expressed its inclination not to entertain the petition, by way of the interim order dated 19.08.2026. Such an observation cannot prevent the members of the Senate from bringing their concerns to the notice of the Chancellor. It is also relevant that the allegations raised by the members are against the officials of the University and the Convenor of the Syndicate Committee. In these circumstances, the issuance of show-cause notices by referring to the interim order of this Court gives rise to a serious apprehension that the order is being used to intimidate the members of the Senate. Let it be stated in no uncertain terms that the Convenor shall not drag this Court into his dispute with the members of the Senate, who have raised their voice against the manner in which the University is functioning.
The University bears the name of Perunthalaivar Kamaraj, a visionary who placed great importance on education. The institution is expected to have an administration that upholds his ideals. This Court expects the officials concerned not to allow the University's reputation to be tarnished by maladministration and continued failure to address its institutional problems.
In view of the issues discussed above, this Court is of the opinion that the present arrangement in the University requires closer examination. In particular, the authority under which Dr.S.Muthiah continues to hold the post of Registrar (in-charge) for a prolonged period requires an explanation. Therefore, this Court proposes to call upon him to show cause as to why a writ of quo warranto should not be issued questioning his continuance in the said post.
This Court also expects the authorities concerned, viz., the Chancellor, the Pro Chancellor, to address the larger issues, identified by this Court, affecting the administration and academic functioning of the University. For the said purpose, this Court suo-motu impleads the Chancellor and the Pro Chancellor of Madurai Kamaraj University as parties to the writ petition in WP(MD)No.23417 of 2026.
Before issuing the directions, this Court makes it clear that the reference to the Hon'ble Governor in this order is only in his statutory capacity as the Chancellor of the University / Head of the University under the Madurai Kamaraj University Act, 1965, and not in his constitutional capacity as the Hon'ble Governor of the State.
Accordingly, the following directions are issued:-
The Chancellor of the University, in his statutory capacity as the Chancellor under the MKU Act, shall place before this Court his views on the issues highlighted in this order, particularly the prolonged vacancy in the office of Vice-Chancellor and the steps required to safeguard the administration and academic development of the University.
The Pro-Chancellor of the University, viz., the Hon'ble Minister for Higher Education Department, State of Tamil Nadu, shall place before this Court the steps taken by the State Government to address the issues concerning the administration of the University and to ensure that its statutory offices are filled in accordance with law.
The University shall furnish the details of the number of litigations instituted against it during the last ten years, together with the expenditure incurred towards such litigation during the same period.
Dr.S.Muthiah, Registrar (in-charge), is called upon to show cause as to why a writ of quo warranto should not be issued regarding his continuance in the said post.
Post the matter on 07.12.2026.
