Case at a Glance
Bengaluru police registered a cheating case under Section 318(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, against a father and son for riding a motorcycle without a number plate; a charge sheet was filed and a non-bailable warrant issued. The State argued the plate had been removed to dodge further helmet fines. Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde held that the charge sheet for cheating was “not tenable” and quashed the proceedings, but, noting the repeated helmet violations, directed the first petitioner to pay a fine of Rs. 1,500 under Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
On 23.02.2026, Kamakshipalya Police Station, Bengaluru, registered Crime No. 90/2026 for an offence under Section 318(2) BNS (cheating) on the allegation that the petitioners were riding a motorcycle without a number plate. A charge sheet was filed on 05.03.2026, cognizance was taken in C.C. No. 20285/2026 on 24.03.2026, and a non-bailable warrant was issued.
The first petitioner had earlier been fined twice for riding without a helmet, which the petitioners did not dispute. The petitioners argued that even if the entire charge sheet were accepted, no offence of cheating was made out, and at most an offence under Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, punishable with a fine of Rs. 500 for a first offence and Rs. 1,500 for a subsequent one, was disclosed. The State contended that the plate had been deliberately removed so that the first petitioner could ride without a helmet and evade further fines.
The Key Question Before the Court
Does riding a motorcycle without a number plate, even allegedly to avoid traffic fines, amount to the offence of cheating under Section 318(2) of the BNS?
A Traffic Violation Does Not Become Cheating
Examining the charge sheet against the ingredients of Section 318 BNS, the Court held that the prosecution for the offence under Section 318(2) was “not tenable”. Removing or not displaying a number plate, even with the motive alleged by the State, did not satisfy the requirements of the cheating provision, and the criminal case could not continue.
The Court did not, however, let the conduct go unpunished. It observed that the first petitioner “appears to have committed offences” under the Motor Vehicles Act and the Karnataka Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, for not wearing a helmet, and since he had already been fined twice, treated it as a repeated offence. Exercising its inherent powers, it directed him to pay a fine of Rs. 1,500 under Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act and to produce the receipt in the Registry within two weeks.
What the Court Actually Held
- Riding a motorcycle without a number plate, on the facts alleged, does not make out the offence of cheating under Section 318(2) BNS.
- The proceedings in Crime No. 90/2026 of Kamakshipalya Police Station were quashed.
- Treating the helmet violations as a repeated offence, the first petitioner was directed to pay a fine of Rs. 1,500 under Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
- The receipt for the fine must be filed in the Registry within two weeks; the petition was allowed in part.
Why This Judgment Matters
- It stops the use of a serious penal provision like cheating for what is essentially a traffic violation.
- It reminds police that the Motor Vehicles Act already provides the penalty for such conduct.
- It shows the High Court balancing relief from prosecution with accountability for repeated violations.
What Should Advocates Take Away From the Judgment?
For Two-Wheeler Riders
- Riding without a number plate or helmet is still an offence under the Motor Vehicles Act and will attract fines.
- But a missing number plate, by itself, should not lead to a cheating case under the BNS.
- If you face a criminal case for a pure traffic violation, a petition under Section 528 BNSS may be available.
For Counsel
- Test the charge sheet against each ingredient of Section 318 BNS; motive to evade fines is not deception of a person.
- Point to the specific penalty provision in the Motor Vehicles Act as the proper route.
- Expect the court to impose the statutory fine while quashing the penal case.
Key Takeaways
- A missing number plate is a Motor Vehicles Act violation, not cheating under Section 318(2) BNS.
- The BNS case, charge sheet and cognizance in this matter were quashed.
- The rider still had to pay Rs. 1,500 under Section 177 of the MV Act for repeated violations.
- Courts will not let a traffic offence be inflated into a penal one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is riding without a number plate cheating?
In this case the Karnataka High Court held that the charge sheet for cheating under Section 318(2) BNS was not tenable and quashed the case.
Did the rider escape without any penalty?
No. The Court directed the first petitioner to pay a fine of Rs. 1,500 under Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act and file the receipt within two weeks.
Why did the police say he removed the plate?
The State argued that he had already been fined twice for not wearing a helmet and removed the plate to avoid further fines. The Court treated the helmet violations as a repeated MV Act offence, not as cheating.
Conclusion
The Karnataka High Court has drawn a sensible line between a traffic violation and a crime of deception. Riding without a number plate can be penalised under the Motor Vehicles Act, but it does not turn the rider into a cheat under the BNS.
Practical takeaway: Traffic violations carry their own statutory penalties; when police invoke cheating or other penal provisions for them, the case can be challenged before the High Court.
For more judgments, legal opinions and case analysis, visit courtkutchehry.com