State Vs Ved Parkash
Jammu And Kashmir High Court · 12 Nov 2025 · Shahzad Azeem, J · Sindhu Sharma, J
Judgment
Shahzad Azeem, J
The present application has been filed by the applicants/appellants seeking condonation of delay in filing the appeal.
For the reasons stated in the application, the same is allowed.
Accordingly, delay of 42 days in filing the appeal is condoned.
Application stands disposed of.
LPA No. 114/2025
Keeping in view the nature of the controversy involved, the appeal is heard at the motion hearing stage.
Heard.
This Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the order dated 10.02.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge (the Writ Court) in OWP No. 303/2014 titled Ved Parkash Vs. State and ors., whereby the respondents were directed to pay an amount of Rs. 50,400/- to the petitioner therein along with interest @ 6 % per annum.
To be very brief and precise, the respondent herein had filed the writ petition bearing OWP No. 303/2014 seeking compensation on account of damage caused to his crop due to alleged negligence of appellants. According to the respondent, due to short-circuit, harvested wheat crop stacked in his field, caught fire and were entirely destroyed due to electrical sparking from the Three Phase LT Line traversing over his field. It is further stated that the revenue authorities have assessed the loss to his crop to the tune of Rs. 50,400/-, however, the grievance of the respondent is that despite his case for compensation on account of damage caused to his crop was processed but revenue authorities did not pay the same, which led to the filing of the aforesaid petition.
Before the writ Court, the appellants have raised the defence that damage to the wheat crop was caused due to heavy wind storm due to which, short circuit occurred, therefore, there was no negligence on their part.
The writ Court has come to the conclusion that it was the duty of the respondents to maintain Phase III LT Line in such a manner so as to prevent the short circuit because of heavy winds. There is also specific finding returned by the writ Court that the respondents did not substantiate the assertion of the wind storm which resulted into the short circuit. Resultantly, the writ petition was allowed vide impugned order under challenge.
Without going into minute factual details, it is relevant to note that the damage caused to the wheat crop of the respondent by the short circuit in the Phase III LT Line is not denied but defence is raised that same was not due to negligence of the Electricity Department, inasmuch as, the revenue authorities have duly assessed the damage to the crop to the tune of Rs. 50,400/-, therefore, only point for consideration is as to whether the appellants/respondents are liable to pay compensation for the loss suffered by the respondent/petitioner.
By now, it is settled principle of law that anyone who deals in, generating, transmitting, supplying or using electric energy of high voltage, is required under law, to ensure that such energy was not transmitted or discharged, unless requisite measures had been taken to prevent its uncontrolled escape, that may injure, impair or taken away life or property. Any omission in preventing the discharge of high voltage electric energy by anyone engaged in the activity of supplying such energy is, under law of torts, liable to compensated for the damage caused, because of the uncontrolled escape of such energy. The basis of such liability is a foreseeable risk, inherent in the very nature of such activity.
Liability to compensate for the damage caused because of such activity is known as “Strict Liability”. It differs from liability that arises from the negligence or fault in this way i.e. concept of negligence comprehends that the foreseeable harm could be avoided by taking requisite precautions. If the operator of such high voltage electric energy had done all that which could be done to avoid harm, it may not be held liable when the action is based on any negligence attributed; but such consideration may be wholly irrelevant in the case of “Strict Liability” where operator of the activity is held liable irrespective of its having taken precaution to avoid harm. {Gittan Ram and anr Vs. State (AIR 2013 J&K 83)}.
On the point of compensation for damages arising out of negligence in maintaining electric energy, Hon’ble Supreme Court in, M.P Electricity Board Vs. Shail Kumar & Ors, (AIR 2002 SC 551) held as follows:-
7.It is an admitted fact that the responsibility to supply electric energy in the particular locality was statutorily conferred on the Board. If the energy so transmitted causes injury or death of a human, being, who gets unknowingly trapped into if the primary liability to compensate the sufferer is that of the supplier of the electric energy. So long as the voltage of electricity transmitted through the wires is potentially of dangerous dimension the managers of its supply have the added duty to take all safety measures to prevent escape of such energy or to see that the wire snapped would not remain live on the road as users of such road would be under peril. It is no defence on the part of the management of the Board that somebody committed mischief by siphoning such energy of his private property and that the electrocution was from such diverted line. It is the look out the managers of the supply system to prevent such pilferage by installing necessary devices. At any rate, if any live wire got snapped and fell on the public road the electric current thereon should automatically have been disrupted. Authorities manning such dangerous commodities have extra duty to chalk out measures to prevent such mishaps.
8 Even assuming that all such measures have been adopted, a person undertaking an activity involving.8 hazardous or risky exposure to human life, is liable under law of torts to compensate for the injury suffered by any other person, irrespective of any negligence or carelessness on the part of the managers of such undertakings. The basis of such liability is the foreseeable risk inherent in the very nature of such activity. The liability cast on such person is known, in law, as "strict liability". It differs from the liability which arises on account of the negligence or fault in this way i.e. the concept of negligence comprehends that the foreseeable harm could be avoided by taking reasonable precautions. If the defendant did all that which could be done for avoiding the harm he cannot be held liable when the action is based on any negligence attributed. But such consideration is not relevant in cases of strict liability where the defendant is held liable irrespective of whether he could have avoided the particular harm by taking precautions.
In view of the settled proposition of law it emerges that once it is shown that tortfeasor is dealing in hazardous electric energy, supplier whereof is bound to compensate for damages, as it is the duty of Manager of such hazardous commodity to take all safety measures. The basis of such liability is the foreseeable risk inherent in the very nature of such activity.
In view of the settled proposition of law, we do not find any error of law or fact has been committed by the Writ Court while passing the impugned order under challenge. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed along with connected CM(s).
