K.K. Sharma Vs State Of Haryana & Ors.
Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · 15 Oct 2026 · Harsimran Singh Sethi, J · Minderjeet Yadav, J
Judgment
HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI, J. (ORAL)
In the present appeal, the challenge is to the order dated 06.07.2011 passed by the learned Single Judge, whereby CWP No. 11491 of 2011, titled ‘K.K. Sharma v. State of Haryana and others,’ preferred by the appellant, has been dismissed.
In the present matter, vide order dated 23.06.2011 passed by the respondents, the services of the appellant were terminated after a period of 33 years of service, which is the maximum period of service for which pension could be earned under the applicable rules. The termination was ordered on the ground that the appellant was guilty of misconduct in the form of insubordination and making false and frivolous complaints against his superior officers. The findings recorded in the departmental proceedings and the consequent order of punishment were upheld by the learned Single Judge vide the impugned judgment.
Certain facts need to be noticed for the proper adjudication of the issue involved.
The appellant was appointed as an Assistant Engineer with the respondent Corporation on 01.06.1978. He was subsequently promoted to the post of Executive Engineer and thereafter to the post of Senior Executive Engineer with Haryana Power Generation Corporation Limited, Panchkula. The service record of the appellant was either good or very good. In the year 2007, the appellant became eligible for his promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer, but was denied the same. This led to certain allegations and representations being made by the appellant.
It may be noticed that, a year prior to 2007, an allegation had been levelled against the appellant regarding misbehaviour with the staff. The respondents, keeping in view their apprehension that the appellant might be suffering from some mental ailment or psychological disorder and might require counselling, referred him to the Medical Board for assessment and for appropriate treatment, if necessary. Keeping in view the aforesaid circumstances, the appellant was not promoted in the year 2007, which further aggravated his temperament.
On the basis of certain allegations levelled against the appellant, a charge-sheet was served upon him on 31.12.2009. The allegations therein were that he had entered the chamber of an officer without permission and misbehaved with him, and had also made allegations against another officer. The allegations contained in the charge-sheet were examined and, in the meantime, another charge-sheet was also served upon the appellant on 23.03.2010 on the allegations that he had failed to report to the Headquarter at Hisar in the office of Chief Engineer. Ultimately, the charges were inquired into and found to be proved, which led to the passing of the order dated 23.06.2011 dismissing the appellant from service. The said order was assailed by the appellant by filing a writ petition.
The learned Single Judge held that, in the exercise of writ jurisdiction, the Court could not reappreciate the evidence recorded in the departmental inquiry and that, since the allegations had been proved in the said inquiry, the order of punishment was liable to be upheld. Accordingly, the punishment was upheld vide judgment dated 06.07.2011, leading to the filing of the present appeal, which has remained pending for a period of 14 years.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has argued that, prior to the issuance of the charge-sheets in the years 2009 and 2010, the respondents themselves had formed an opinion that the appellant might be exhibiting some imbalance in his behaviour and might be suffering from a psychological problem and had, accordingly, directed him to appear before the Medical Board. Such circumstances ought to have been taken into consideration while imposing the punishment, even if the charges of insubordination stood proved.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the punishing authority ought to have considered whether the alleged acts of insubordination were attributable to the appellant's mental condition or were intentional acts committed independently of any such condition. Hence, the punishment imposed after 33 years of service, resulting in the deprivation of all pensionary benefits, is not only disproportionate to the charges alleged and proved but is also shockingly disproportionate, warranting interference by this Court.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that, as per the settled principles of law, the extreme punishment of dismissal from service ought to be imposed only in cases involving misconduct of the highest degree of gravity, such as misappropriation or corruption, and should not ordinarily be imposed where the allegations relate merely to insubordination or the making of false allegations, particularly when the respondents themselves had entertained doubts regarding the appellant's mental stability.
Learned counsel for the appellant further contends that, as per the appellant's Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs), approximately 97% of the entries were either good or very good. In these circumstances, dismissal from service on the ground of insubordination, including entering the chamber of a superior officer without permission, was not warranted. Rather, some other punishment commensurated with the charges alleged and proved could have been imposed.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents submits that, although the authorities had, in the year 2006, prior to the issuance of the charge-sheets, entertained an apprehension regarding the mental stability of the appellant and had directed him to appear before the Medical Board, such apprehension could not justify his misconduct in offending superior officers or creating an atmosphere of fear by making false and frivolous allegations against them. Learned counsel further submits that the punishing authority, after conducting the disciplinary proceedings, imposed the punishment in accordance with law, which has rightly been upheld by the learned Single Judge. It is, therefore, prayed that the present appeal be dismissed.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the record with their able assistance.
It is a settled principle of law that the Court will not re-appreciate the evidence or reassess the merits of the charges so as to record its own finding regarding the guilt or otherwise of the delinquent employee. The scope of judicial review is primarily confined to examining whether the procedure prescribed for conducting the disciplinary proceedings has been followed or not. However, with regard to the quantum of punishment, the Court has limited jurisdiction to examine whether the punishment imposed is commensurated with the charges alleged and proved, keeping in view the relevant circumstances, including the length of service rendered by the employee and his previous service record.
In the present case, the allegations do not relate to corruption or embezzlement resulting in any financial loss to the respondent Corporation. The allegations are primarily of insubordination by entering the chamber of a superior officer and creating a scene. There is also an allegation of making baseless complaints against officials with a view to creating an atmosphere of fear.
Even if such allegations have been proved, the punishment is required to be determined after taking into consideration the mental condition of the employee at the time of the alleged misconduct. As noticed hereinbefore, even before the initiation of the disciplinary proceedings, the respondents themselves had apprehended that the appellant might be suffering from some mental imbalance and had directed him to appear before the Medical Board for assessment and appropriate medical advice.
Under these circumstances, this Court is required to examine whether the punishment of dismissal from service could justifiably have been imposed upon an employee who was suspected by the respondents themselves to be suffering from mental instability and whose alleged misconduct consisted of insubordination by entering the chamber of a superior officer and creating a scene, along with making false allegations against higher officials of the respondent Corporation.
The object of the respondent department was to prevent the appellant from indulging in such conduct in the future. The said object could have been achieved by imposing a lesser punishment, such as compulsory retirement, rather than dismissing him from service and thereby depriving him of the pensionary benefits attached to 33 years of service, during which his service record had been assessed as good or very good. An isolated incident, particularly when the employee's mental condition was itself a matter of concern to the respondents, did not warrant the imposition of the harshest punishment possible. The punishment imposed is, therefore, not merely disproportionate but shockingly disproportionate, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, and warrants interference by this Court.
Further, as per the settled principles of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Surekha Domaji Bele v. Executive Engineer, Testing Division, MSEDCL, SLP (C) Diary No. 11294 of 2025, decided on 11.06.2026, the surrounding circumstances and the nature and gravity of the misconduct must be taken into consideration while determining the appropriate punishment. Where the misconduct does not involve corruption or embezzlement, the punishment of dismissal from service must be examined in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case, and the punishment imposed must remain commensurate with the misconduct established.
It may be noticed that the principle of proportionality in the imposition of punishment has also been considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Surekha Domaji Bele’s case (supra). The relevant paragraphs of the said judgment are reproduced as under:
90.The Appellant has urged that the punishment of dismissal is grossly disproportionate to the charges proved.
91.The Appellant has submitted that several allegations, even if accepted, would fall within the category of minor lapses under Regulation 86(2) read with Schedule A of the MSEDCL Employees Service Regulations, 2005. She has relied upon entries such as late attendance, irregular attendance, absence without prior permission, minor negligence, lack of courtesy towards colleagues and lack of respect towards superiors not amounting to insubordination.
92.Regulation 86 classifies offences as follows:
“86.CLASSIFICATION OF OFFENCES (1) Offences are classified in two categories as shown below-
(a)Minor lapses, and
(b)Acts of misconduct
(2)Minor lapses are those mentioned in Schedule ‘A’ (with any modification that may be effected by the Company) which may result in a punishment upto the limit prescribed in (1) of the Statement below Regulation 91.
(3)Acts of misconduct are those which have been listed in Schedule ‘B’ (with such modifications as may be specified by the Company from time to time) for which maximum penalty is as prescribed in (2) of the Statement below Service Regulation 91 according to the gravity of the misconduct.
(4)Any minor lapse may be treated as an act of misconduct if repeated for a third time within the period of one year and may be dealt with accordingly.
Note: Schedules A and B appended to the Service Regulations are only indicative of what could be deemed as a minor lapse or act of misconduct. The list is neither complete nor exhaustive. Such of the irregularities or offences committed by an employee not included in the list but commonly or generally known or understood to be against the cannon of good behavior and discipline, may be deemed to have been included in either of the two schedules according to the nature and gravity of the offence committed, at the discretion of the authority competent to order departmental proceedings.”
93.Schedule A, on which the Appellant relies, enumerates minor lapses. The relevant entries charged against Appellant are extracted hereunder:
“SCHEDULE ‘A’ MINOR LAPSES
[See Service Regulation 86(2)]
1.Late attendance on more than 3 occasions in a month.
2.Irregular attendance.
4.Absence without prior permission.
6.Instances of carelessness of minor nature.
7.Minor negligence in the discharge of duties assigned
8.Instances of lack of normal courtesy towards colleagues and subordinates.
14.Lacking in sense of respect towards superiors (not amounting to disrespect or insubordination).
Note: Any of the above instances of misbehavior may, at the discretion of the Competent Authority, be treated as an act of misconduct according to the circumstances and gravity of the misbehavior.”
94.Schedule B deals with acts of misconduct. The entries relevant to the present case are as follows:
“SCHEDULE ‘B’ ACTS OF MISCONDUCT
[See Service Regulation 86(3)]
9.Indiscipline.
12.Insubordination, insolence, impertinence, rude and uncivil behavior or commission of any act subversive of good behavior.
13.Disobedience of any order of the superior officer or a senior officer.
14.Theft, embezzlement, fraud, falsification of account, tampering with official documents, breach of trust, misappropriation or dishonesty in connection with the affairs or property of the Company.
22.Breach of any Rules, Regulation, Circulars, Orders or Instructions.
23.Negligence or neglect of work.”
95.Regulation 91 prescribes the punishments for minor lapses and acts of misconduct. The material portion reads as follows:
“91. PUNISHMENTS FOR MINOR LAPSES AND ACTS OF MISCONDUCT
The following punishments are prescribed for minor lapses and acts of misconduct.
1.Minor lapses
(a)Warning
(b)Reprimand
(c)Fine up to 1/3rd of the gross salary of the employee.
(d)Recovery from gross salary / or an encashment of leave at the time of retirement to make up wholly or partly the pecuniary loss caused to the Company due to negligence or breach of orders (amounts less than Rs.50,000/-).
(e)Withholding of increment without cumulative effect.
2.Acts of misconduct
(a)As in (d) above but for loss in excess of Rs.50,000/- according to the gravity of the offence and the loss incurred by the Company.
(b)Withholding of increment with cumulative effect.
(c)Stoppage of promotion.
(d)Suspension.
(e)Reversion to a lower post.
(f)Removal from service.
(g)Dismissal.”
96.Note 4 below Regulation 91 is also relevant. It reads:
“Note 4: The act of grave misconduct like theft of energy / abetment in theft of energy, obtaining or attempting to obtain illegal gratification, misappropriation of Company’s property or money or stores, theft, fraud, falsification of account, tampering with official document, gross irregularity or negligence in discharging of official duties with a dishonest motive, act of disloyalty, sabotage etc. (The list is illustrative and not exhaustive and is intended to serve as guide) shall necessarily merit action of imposing one of the major penalties as prescribed for the acts of misconduct and the Competent Authority shall not have any discretion to convert the act of misconduct into minor lapses and impose the punishment prescribed for the minor lapses.”
97.The above scheme shows that Schedule A and Schedule B are not rigid watertight compartments. The Note to Regulation 86 expressly states that the Schedules are indicative and not exhaustive. It further permits irregularities or offences to be treated either as minor lapses or as acts of misconduct depending on their nature and gravity. Schedule A itself provides that even instances mentioned therein may, at the discretion of the competent authority, be treated as acts of misconduct according to the circumstances and gravity of the misbehaviour.
98.In the present case, the charge-sheet did not proceed merely on isolated late attendance or a single absence. The charges were framed under Regulation 86(3) read with Schedule B. The Schedule B heads invoked against the Appellant included indiscipline, insubordination or misbehaviour, disobedience of orders of superior officers, tampering with official documents, negligence and misuse of company property. The Labour Court also recorded that the main proved charges related to indiscipline, misbehaviour, disobedience of superior officers, tampering with official documents and negligent discharge of duty.
99.Therefore, the proved acts cannot be reclassified by this Court as only minor lapses under Schedule A. The finding that misconduct stood proved shall remain undisturbed. However, the Appellant’s submission is relevant while considering the proportionality of punishment. The fact that some components of the charge resemble minor lapses, the absence of financial misappropriation, the long service of the Appellant, and the period to which the allegations substantially relate, are all matters which the competent authority must consider while deciding the appropriate penalty.
100.The Appellant had rendered long service before disciplinary proceedings were initiated. She joined service in 1985, and she was dismissed from service on 12.07.2017. Her case is that there were no allegations of misconduct for about 21 years of service and that the allegations arose substantially during a limited period in 2006. She has also contended that the punishment was a counterblast to the proceedings she instituted regarding her service grievances.
101.The Respondent has maintained that the proved charges were serious and related to discipline and office functioning. While we are not inclined to reopen the finding of misconduct, the question of punishment stands on a different footing. The punishment must bear a reasonable relationship with the gravity of the misconduct, the past service record, the surrounding circumstances and the impact of the misconduct on the establishment as also observed by the Labour Court while referring the finding of the alleged misconduct proved.
In the present case, the aforesaid settled principles of law support the case of the appellant. The punishment of dismissal from service, imposed after 33 years of service, despite the appellant's service record being assessed as good or very good even by the respondents, is disproportionate to the charge of insubordination. The appellant ought not to have been deprived altogether of the pensionary benefits earned through his long years of service, which would provide financial support for his treatment and enable him to lead a dignified life after rendering 33 years of service.
Keeping in view the totality of the circumstances, the order passed by the respondents dismissing the appellant from service is held to be disproportionate to the charges alleged and proved and contrary to the settled principles of law noticed hereinbefore. The said order was passed without adequately considering the relevant circumstances that the punishing authority was required to take into account while determining the appropriate punishment. The impugned order of punishment, therefore, cannot be sustained to the extent indicated hereinbelow.
Accordingly, although, upon finding the punishment to be disproportionate, the matter would be remitted to the competent authority for reconsideration of the quantum of punishment, in the present case, the appellant has already attained the age of superannuation. Having regard to this circumstance and the facts of the case, this Court deems it appropriate to substitute the punishment of dismissal from service with that of compulsory retirement, with effect from the date on which the order of dismissal was passed, i.e., 23.06.2011.
Consequent upon the substitution of the punishment, the appellant shall be entitled to all admissible service and retiral benefits up to the date of compulsory retirement, including pensionary benefits, in accordance with the applicable rules. The respondents are directed to release the pensionary benefits admissible to the appellant, along with the arrears of pension payable from the date of compulsory retirement. The requisite exercise shall be completed within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
The order is dictated in the open Court in the presence of learned counsel for the parties. No other arguments have been raised.
Pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
