Dr. Rehana Kounsar & Anr. Vs State Of Jammu And Kashmir & Ors.
Central Administrative Tribunal · Srinagar · 05 Oct 2026 · M.S. Latif, Member (Judl.) · Prasant Kumar, Member (Admn.)
Judgment
Per Hon’ble Mr. M.S. Latif, Member (Judl.)
The Writ Petition was initially filed before the Hon’ble High Court of J&K in the year 2017 bearing SWP No. 1756/2017, and the same was later transferred to this Tribunal and got numbered as T.A./5893/2021.
By way of filing the instant Writ Petition, the applicants seek the following reliefs:
a. To re- designate the petitioners as senior consultants in the respondent department in terms of the proposals made to government and approved by finance department.
b. To accord consideration to the petitioners for the promotion to the next higher ranks in accordance with the Jammu and Kashmir Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted Services, Recruitment Rules-2013) with all consequential service benefits lin retrospectively from the dates they were entitled to it.
The brief facts of the case, as stated in the T.A., are that petitioners were initially appointed as Assistant Surgeons in the respondent department in the year 1997 and have since rendered their services with dedication and diligence. The petitioners subsequently qualified the entrance examination in open merit and were selected for the three-year Post-Graduate course in Maternity, Child Health and Community Medicine (hereinafter called MCH) at Sher-i-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences (hereinafter called SKIMS). The petitioner no. 1 completed the said degree in 1999, whereas petitioner no. 2 completed the same in 1997.
It is averred that upon completion of the Post-Graduate degree, the petitioners became entitled to be promoted as B-Grade Specialists. In the meantime, vide Notification dated 02.01.2002, the SKIMS, discontinued the composite specialist course, Post-Graduate degree offered in MCH. However, the Apex Selection Committee of SKIMS, in its meeting held on 19th and 20th April 2001, examined the cases of the 12 (twelve) candidates who had completed the said degree and resolved that a proposal be submitted to the Government for their adjustment as B-Grade Specialists in District Hospitals.
It is further stated that the Government of India subsequently recognized the said qualification by amending the relevant provisions under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, vide Notification dated 29.04.2004. Consequently, the respondent department placed the petitioners as B-Grade Specialists in the pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,000 vide Government Order No. 132-HME of 2007 dated 07.03.2007, pursuant to which they were posted at different places.
Learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Mohammad Altaf Khan, submits that under Schedule-I of the Jammu and Kashmir Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules, 2006, as amended in 2013, the petitioners became entitled to promotion from B-Grade Specialist to A-Grade Specialist in the year 2012. However, despite their eligibility and completion of the requisite service, their cases have not been considered for promotion in terms of the applicable recruitment rules.
It is stated that only 12 (twelve) candidates had obtained the MCH qualification (PG degree) from SKIMS, Srinagar, during the relevant period from 1992 to 2000 and that, some of the candidates have already been adjusted in different streams due to discontinuation of the course and there are no further promotion avenues of these candidates. The petitioners also seek upgradation so that they can be placed at par with other colleagues in department having same service background. Out of those 12 (twelve) doctors, only 04 (four) B-Grade Specialists, including the petitioners, are presently stated to be serving in the respondent department. The petitioners assert that these posts of Senior Consultant MCH will revert to the post of Medical Officer upon their superannuation, as there are no further candidates available in the discontinued speciality.
As stated, the respondent department had already initiated a proposal for upgradation/redesignation of their posts so as to facilitate their placement at par with other similarly situated specialist doctors. The proposal was examined by the Finance Department, which, vide U.O. dated 20.03.2015, returned the case with some observations. The same are reproduced hereunder for reference:
Returned: the proposal has been examined, the department is advised to decide the issue at its level, since no up-gradation of pay scale is involved in the matter. However, Finance Department conveys no objection to the re-designation of these four doctors as Senior Consultants subject to the following conditions:-
(i)That no financial implications are involved
(ii)Minimum period of service as Consultant is fixed for redesignation as Senior Consultant.
(iii)Orders are issued after obtaining approval of the Competent Authority.
The petitioners contend that despite the aforesaid position and the proposal having been examined at the departmental level, no final decision has been taken. As a result, the petitioners have remained stagnant in the B-Grade Specialist category, while their colleagues possessing Post-Graduate qualifications in other disciplines have been designated as A-Grade Specialists and have progressed to higher posts and service benefits.
It is further stated that the continued failure of the respondents to take a decision on the proposal has resulted in stagnation and discriminatory treatment, particularly when the petitioners' posts are required only to be upgraded/redesignated. The delay in matter by the respondents is violating the rights of the petitioners guaranteed to them under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
The petitioners further state that they had earlier approached the Hon'ble High Court through SWP No. 792/2016, but the said writ petition was subsequently withdrawn after the petitioners became aware of the changed circumstances arising from the Finance Department's consideration of the matter and its communication conveying no objection to the proposed redesignation.
Being aggrieved by the respondents' failure to take a final decision regarding their upgradation/redesignation despite their eligibility under the applicable service rules and the Finance Department having conveyed no objection to the proposed redesignation, the petitioners had approached the Hon’ble High Court, whereafter the case was transferred to this Tribunal seeking appropriate directions.
The matter initially came up for consideration before the Hon’ble High Court of J&K on 31.08.2017, whereby a direction was issued upon the respondent no. 1 to take a decision in the case of the petitioners for their re-designation as Senior Consultants in tune with the ‘No Objection’ furnished by the Finance Department. The consideration was ordered to be made within the notice period. Thereafter, on 18.12.2017, a direction to file compliance report with regard to order dated 31.08.2017, was also ordered to be filed. Thereafter, vide order dated 16.04.2021, the present Writ Petition was transferred to Jammu Bench of this Tribunal and later transferred to this Bench.
Perusal of various orders passed by this Court reveals that umpteen opportunities were granted to the respondents to file reply since 2022. Subsequently, the order dated 27.01.2025 passed by this Court recorded that pleadings are complete in the matter, and the case was ordered to be listed before the Division Bench of this Tribunal. On 25.11.2025, when the matter came up for consideration, learned counsel for the petitioners was directed to file his written arguments along with case law to substantiate his arguments. In the meantime, the respondents were directed to file their compliance report as regards order of the Hon’ble High Court dated 31.08.2017.
Objections stand filed in the matter by the respondents way back in the year 2024. The same is supported by a duly sworn affidavit signed by one Mushtaq Ahmad Khan, Under Secretary to Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K.
A bare perusal of the objections reveals that the Finance Department on 28.12.2004 and the Planning and Development Department on 16.03.2004, conveyed their agreement to the upgradation of 12 (twelve) posts of Assistant Surgeons and re-designated as B-Grade Specialists MCH subject to various conditions. Pursuant to the agreement received, the Health & Medical Education Department, issued a Government Order No. 335-HME of 2005 dated 03.06.2006, whereby 12 (twelve) posts of the Assistant Surgeons were upgraded and bifurcated equally between Jammu and Kashmir Provinces, with six posts earmarked for each Province and intended for rural areas in Sub-District Hospitals with the condition that the incumbents appointed against such posts were required to serve in the said areas for a minimum period of seven years.
The respondents have further stated that, upon examination of the matter, it was decided that, since the Medical Council of India had discontinued the MCH course and the said qualification could not be incorporated in the Recruitment Rules, only 12 (twelve) doctors, whose posts have been upgraded, were to be placed as B-Grade Specialists, in accordance with their inter seniority against the B-Grade posts. It is stated that, at the relevant time, only 06 (six) such doctors are available in Kashmir Division for adjustment against the posts of B-Grade Specialists.
It is further averred that the Government accordingly considered the adjustment of the 06 (six) doctors who had obtained the M.D. qualification in MCH from SKIMS, Srinagar, pursuant to Government Order No. 335-HME of 2005 dated 03.06.2005. Consequently, vide Government Order No. 132-HME of 2007 dated 07.03.2007, 06 (six) Assistant Surgeons who had obtained Post-Graduation in MCH from SKIMS during the period 1992-2000 were placed as B-Grade Specialists in the pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,200. The said order also provided for their posting at different places in the Kashmir Division, whereby the petitioner no. 1 posted from RIHFW Dobiwan to SDH Kangan, and the petitioner no. 2 from SDH Gurez to SDH Gurez.
The respondents have further drawn attention to the fact that, subsequently, the Health & Medical Education Department, vide communication No. HME/HRM/80/2013 dated 21.02.2018, had inadvertently referred 03 (three) posts of Consultant, Maternity and Child Welfare, to the Jammu & Kashmir Public Service Commission (hereinafter called JKPSC) for making selections. Pursuant thereto, the JKPSC, vide communication No. PSC/DR/Consultant MCH/2018 dated 29.01.2019, forwarded the selection list for the post of Consultant, Maternity and Child Welfare, against the Open Merit category, recommending Dr. Anam Ul Haq, while one post each under the RBA and the SC categories remained unfilled due to non-availability of candidates.
It is stated that, aggrieved by non-issuance of formal appointment order, Dr. Anam Ul Haq approached the Hon'ble High Court by way of WP(C) No. 2935/2019. In compliance with the directions dated 15.10.2019 passed in the said writ petition and the subsequent order dated 06.03.2020 passed in CCP(S) No. 108/2020, the claim of Dr. Anam Ul Haq for appointment as Consultant, Maternity and Child Welfare, was reconsidered by the Department. The Department, however, found that the post had inadvertently been referred to the JKPSC and that the recommendation made by the Commission could not, therefore, be acted upon. Consequently, Government Order No. 397-JK(HME) of 2020 dated 24.04.2020 was issued, whereby the claim of Dr. Anam Ul Haq was rejected by way of a detailed speaking order. It is stated that the matter concerning Dr. Anam Ul Haq is presently pending before this Tribunal in T.A. No. 6875/2020.
Coming to the case of the petitioners, the respondents have relied upon the Jammu & Kashmir Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules, 2013, and have contended that the post of Senior Consultant is required to be filled up by promotion from Class III, Category E (Consultant) of the respective speciality, having at least 03 (three) years' substantive service.
The respondents contend that the petitioners, being B-Grade Specialists (Consultants), cannot claim promotion to the post of Senior Consultant, as no post of Senior Consultant in the speciality of MCH is available in the Jammu & Kashmir Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules, 2013. It is, accordingly, submitted that the relief sought by petitioners is not merely a case of redesignation, as the same would involve financial implications. They further submit that there can be no proposal which would be dehors the recruitment rules. On this basis, the respondents, the respondents have prayed for dismissal of the T.A.
Mr. Syed Musaib, learned DAG, has also submitted compliance report with respect to the directions issued by this Tribunal vide order dated 25.11.2025 and 23.03.2026, whereby the respondent no. 1 was directed to take a decision in the case of the petitioners for their re-designation as Senior Consultants in tune with the ‘No Objection’ furnished by the Finance Department. The compliance report mentioned that the Administrative Department has considered the claim of the applicants by issuing a Government Order No. 333-JK(HME) of 2026 dated 10.04.2026. The Government Order reveals that the case of the petitioners having been found to be bereft/devoid of any merit is rejected. The reasons stated in the order are that the applicants are borne on the cadre of B-Grade Specialists (treated as Consultants) and are seeking their elevation as Senior Consultants in the MCH discipline. However, the Recruitment Rules, 2013 makes it clear that no post of Senior Consultant exists or is sanctioned in the MCH specialty, nor is there any provision recognizing MCH as a distinct specialty for the purpose of such promotion. Further, in absence of a sanctioned cadre post under the statutory rules, the claim of the applicants is legally untenable. At last, it is added that if the claim of the applicants is accepted, it would not only be in violation of the Recruitment Rules, 2013, but would also disturb the cadre structure and would open floodgates for similarly situated claims, leading to administrative chaos and inequity in service matters. Therefore, the claim of the petitioners is rejected.
Learned counsel for the applicants has filed his written arguments. It is averred therein that in terms of Schedule-I read with Schedule-II of the Jammu & Kashmir Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted Services) Recruitment Rules, 2006, as amended in 2013, the petitioners became eligible for consideration for promotion from the post of B-Grade Specialist to A-Grade Specialist in the year 2012. Learned counsel has relied upon SRO 325 of 2013 dated 12.07.2013 and submitted that the Consultant (MCH) was to be re-designated as Senior Consultant and the proposed method of recruitment for such post was also 100% by promotion with five years minimum service.
It is contended that, in the case of MCH, the Finance Department itself had no objection to the redesignation of the petitioners as Senior Consultants, subject only to the conditions stipulated therein.
It is further stated therein that promotion to a higher post may not be claimed as an indefeasible fundamental right but the right to be considered for promotion in accordance with the applicable service rules is an enforceable legal and constitutional right. It is contended that the petitioners have been denied even such consideration for a long period while similarly situated doctors in other specialties have been considered and promoted, thereby resulting in discrimination and, violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
It is further contended that the respondents cannot rely upon the discontinuation of the MCH course as a justification for denying the petitioners promotional avenues, as they were placed as B-Grade Specialists by the respondents.
Learned counsel has also sought to distinguish the respondents' contention that the relief sought would involve creation of a new post or alteration of the cadre structure. It is submitted that the petitioners are seeking upgradation and redesignation of their existing posts so as to bring them at par with other specialists.
It is lastly submitted that the continued stagnation of the petitioners for nearly two decades, despite their having completed the requisite service and possessing the prescribed qualification, has deprived them of status, promotional hierarchy and consequential service benefits, while their similarly situated colleagues have progressed in the service hierarchy. Learned counsel accordingly submits that the action/inaction of the respondents is arbitrary and discriminatory and warrants interference by this Tribunal by directing the respondents to accord the petitioners appropriate re-designation/promotion with consequential benefits.
To fortify his arguments on the above point, learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon various judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. He has relied upon the judgment passed in the case titled as Bihar State Electricity Board And Others V. Dharamdeo Das, (Neutral Citation 2024 INSC 549) wherein their lordships held that once employed, the employees are entitled for being considered for promotion to the next higher post subject to their satisfying the eligibility criteria, as per the applicable rules. Failure to consider an employee for promotion even after satisfying the eligibility criteria would violate her fundamental right. Further, while relying on the judgment passed in O.P. Singla & Anr. vs. Union of India & Ors., (1984) 4 SCC 450, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the judgment settled disputes over seniority between promoted officers and direct recruits in the Delhi Higher Judicial Service (DHJS), clarifying that seniority should generally follow the "rota rule" (quota system) prescribed in the DHJS Rules, meaning direct recruits and promotees are ranked alternately, but allowing for adjustments for backlog, ensuring fairness and adherence to the service rules. The case established that while quotas exist, service rules (like the DHJS Rules, 1970) must be read as a whole, and promotees with longer service couldn't automatically be placed junior to later-appointed direct recruits if the quota system was followed properly. In addition, the petitioners have relied upon the judgments in the cases titled as, Union of India & Anr. vs. Hemraj Singh Chauhan & Ors, (2010) 4 SCC 290, Union of India v. C.R. Madhava Murthy, (2022) 6 SCC 183 as also on E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1974) 4 SCC 3.
Lastly, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that stagnation in service on the same post for quite a long period of time and lack of any promotional avenues kills the desire to serve properly. He has relied upon the judgment passed by the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of J&K in the case titled as Latif Hussain Khan v. State of JK, WP(C) No.1410/2019, where while directing the Government, it was observed “The petitioners have been discharging their duties on the posts of Restorers in the High Court since a long period of time with the legitimate expectation that in due recognition of such services being rendered by them, they will be provided appropriate promotional avenues as is the procedure prevalent with regard to the rest ofthe posts borne on the establishment of the High Court." The Bench further expressed, "Availability of reasonable promotional opportunities in service generates efficiency and fosters the appropriate attitude to grow for achieving excellence in service."
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the 1999 Constitutional Bench Judgment titled as Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab held that Article 16 (1) guarantees a fundamental right to be considered for promotion for all eligible employees and failure to do so is a clear infraction of personal and constitutional rights.
Undoubtedly, the State has an obligation to prevent career stagnation, for which eligible employees have a right of seeking timely consideration for their promotion. It is true that Government employees do not have a guaranteed right of promotion, but they do have a fundamental right to be fairly considered for a promotion, if they meet the eligibility criteria, for which authorities must ensure fair, timely and non-arbitrary evaluation of the eligible candidates, and at times, this right is often violated. It is also apt to mention here that right to be considered for promotion is rooted in Article 14 and 16 (1) of the Constitution which guarantees equality before law and equal opportunity of public employment.
In the instant case, referring to the note as contained in Annexure C Page 14 of the Writ Petition wherein the proposal as regards the petitioners has been examined and the Finance Department has advised to decide the issue at the departmental level as no upgradation of pay scale is involved in the matter and the Finance Department having conveyed its no objection to the redesignation of the petitioner as Senior Consultants subject to some conditions, that no financial implications are involved, minimum period of service as Consultant is fixed for redesignation as Senior Consultant, and Orders to the effect are issued after obtaining approval of the Competent Authority.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the contents of the T.A. along with the reply filed and the case law cited at Bar.
The T.A. is accordingly disposed of by providing that the case of the petitioners shall be considered by the respondents, in the light of the recommendations of the Finance Department vide Ref:- U.O. No. HME/HRM/29/2013 dated 02.01.2015, and accordingly accord consideration to the petitioners for their promotion to the next higher ranks in accordance with J&K Health and Family Welfare (Gazetted Services) Recruitment Rules, 2013, strictly in accordance with the recommendations mentioned above. The consideration shall be accorded within a period of eight weeks by passing a speaking order.
Accordingly, T.A. No. 5893/2021 is disposed of along with all connected M.A.s, if any.
No order as to costs.
