Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 08 ITAT CK 6923

SIDH Management Corporate Services Ltd. Vs ITO, Ward 23 (3), Delhi

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · New Delhi · 05 Aug 2026 · S. Rifaur Rahman, Accountant Member · Vimal Kumar, Judicial Member

Open full page

Judgment

93 paragraphs · 2,743 words

PER S.RIFAURRAHMAN,AM:

1.

This appeal filed by the assessee is directed against the order of ld. Addl./JCIT (Appeals), Mysore [for short ‘ld. CIT (A)] dated 17.11.2025 for the Assessment Year 2012-13 raising following grounds of appeal :-

“1.

That on the facts and circumstances of the appellant's case, the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in law in upholding the addition of Rs,2,62,860/- on account of disallowance of depreciation as per Income Tax Act. 1961, which is completely technical in nature as error has not been generated while generating xml file for uploading the return of income, by rejecting the detailed submission of the appellant and without considering the fact that option to revise the return of income has been lapsed and appellant had filed rectification under section 154 of the Income Tax Act. 1961.

2.

That the impugned appeal order is arbitrary, illegal, bad in law and in violation of rudimentary principles of contemporary jurisprudence.”

2.

At the time of hearing, ld. AR of the assessee brought to our notice relevant facts and submitted his submissions as under. Brief facts of the case are, the assessee is a company incorporated under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 having its registered office at E - 253, Saraswati Kunj Apartments 25, I.P. Extension, Patparganj, Delhi – 110 092 has e-filed its return of income for the Assessment Year 2012-13 on 14.10.2023 declaring total income of Rs.1,93,510/- under the head ‘Profits and gains from business or profession’ which has been processed on 15.11.2023 in which total income has been assessed at Rs.4,56,370/- against the returned income of Rs.1,93,510/-, thereby making addition of Rs.2,62,860/- on account of disallowance of depreciation as per Companies Act, 1956 and accordingly, demand has been raised amounting to Rs.1,12,200/-. Ld. AR submitted that it is pertinent to note that the assessee filed rectification applications under Section 154 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on the following dates:

20.01.2014 (Rectification Ref. No. 865255521200114)

15.01.2019 (Rectification Ref. No. 409005641150119)

28.10.2020 (Rectification Ref. No. 681384561281020)

3.

He submitted that all of the above rectification applications were rejected by CPC, Bengaluru, and no relief in respect of depreciation was granted. He further submitted that assessee had filed physical application with the jurisdictional assessing officer on 05.12.2019 whose copy of the letter has been placed on record, however, the Assessing Officer did not bother to consider the rectification application till date.

4.

He submitted that while filing the original return of income for Assessment Year 2012-13, Schedule DPM (Depreciation on Plant and Machinery) was inadvertently omitted. However, Schedule BP (Details of Business Income) was properly filled, specifically Row No. 12(ii) of Point A, which clearly reflected the depreciation allowable under Section 32(1)(i) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘the Act’). He submitted a relevant screenshot of this entry which is reproduced below for reference :-

Schedule BP Computation of income from business or profession

AFrom business or profession other than speculative business and specified business
1Profit before tax as per profit and loss account (item 43 of Part A-P&L )108245
2aNet profit/loss from speculative business incl in 1(enter -ve sign in case of loss)2a0
2bNet profit or Loss from Specified Business u/s 35AD included in 1(enter -ve sign in case of loss)2b0
3Income/ receipts credited to profit and loss account considered under other heads of income30
4Profit or loss included in 1, which is referred to in section 44AD/44AF/44AF/44B/44BR/44BRA/44BRB/ 44D/44DA Chapter-XII-G/ First Schedule of Income-tax Act40
5Income credited to Profit and Loss account (included in 1) which is exempt
aShare of income from firm(s)5a0
bShare of income from AOP/ BOI5b0
cAny other exempt income5c0
dTotal exempt income5d0
6Balance (1- 2a - 2b - 3 - 4 - 5d)6 108245
7Expenses debited to profit and loss account considered under other heads of income70
8Expenses debited to profit and loss account which relate to exempt income80
9Total (7 + 8)90
10Adjusted profit or loss (6+9)10 108245
11Depreciation debited to profit and loss account included in 911 348126
12Depreciation allowable under Income-tax Act
iDepreciation allowable under section 32(1)(ii) (column 6 of Schedule-DEP)12i0
iiDepreciation allowable under section 32(1)(i)(Make your own computation and enter, refer Appendix-IA of IT Rules)12ii262862
iiiTotal (12i + 12ii)12iii 262862
13Profit or loss after adjustment for depreciation (10 +11 - 12iii)13 191500
14Amounts debited to the profit and loss account, to the extent disallowable under section 36 (6p of Part-OI)140
15Amounts debited to the profit and loss account, to the extent disallowable under section 37 (7h of Part-OI)150
5.

Further, he submitted that subsequently, in the rectification applications filed under Section 154, the appellant duly filled Schedule DPM with all requisite details and annexures, thereby correcting the inadvertent omission. However, despite submitting complete and accurate data during rectification, the CPC passed orders dated 24.07.2020 and 02.11.2020, rejecting the rectification applications on the ground that rectification could not be carried out. For the sake of brevity, Schedule DPM and Schedule DEP is reproduced below :-

Schedule DPM Depreciation on Plant and Machinery

Schedule DPMDescription on Plant and MachineryPlant and machinery
15 (i)30 (ii)40 (iii)50 (iv)60 (v)80 (vi)100 (vii)
1Block of assets
2Rate (%)
3Written down value on the first day of previous year23733296708
4Additions for a period of 180 days or more in the previous year56310108925
5Consideration or other realization during the previous year out of 3 or 400
6Amount on which depreciation at fullrate to be allowed (3 + 4 -5)293642205633
7Additions for a period of less than 180 days in the previous year00
8Consideration or other realizations during the year out of 700
9Amount on which depreciation at halfrate to be allowed (7-8)00
10Depreciation on 6 at full rate44046123380
11Depreciation on 9 at half rate00
12Additional depreciation, if any, on 400
13Additional depreciation, if any, on 700
14Total depreciation (10+11+12+13)44046123380
15Expenditure incurred in connection with transfer of asset/ assets00
16Capital gains/ loss under section 50 (5 + 8 -3-4 -7 -15) (enter negative only if block ceases to exist)00
17Written down value on the last day of previous year* (6+ 9 -14)24959682253
6.

Further he submitted that however, even after filing the complete details in the relevant schedule, rectification order has been passed wherein rectification application has been rejected vide order dated 24.07.2020 and 02.11.2020 by stating that rectification cannot be made and hence application is rejected. Rectification order extract is attached below for perusal: -

7.

Ld. AR further submitted that the CBDT Circular No. 14 (XL-35) of 1955, dated 11-4-1955, reinforces this obligation in unequivocal terms, stating that the department must not take advantage of ignorance of any assessee as to his rights and it is one of the duties of the department to assist a taxpayer in every reasonable way, particularly in the matter of claiming and securing reliefs, by taking initiative in guiding the taxpayer where the proceedings are before them that some relief is due to the taxpayer.

8.

He submitted that when one reads Explanation5 to section 32(1) and the above circular issued by the CBDT in the context of Article365 of the Constitution of India, one finds it difficult to uphold the action of the authorities below in depriving the assessee of the claim for deduction of depreciation.

The omission of Schedule DPM was a genuine, inadvertent, and human error during return filing, which was subsequently rectified in the rectification applications.

 The depreciation claimed under Section 32 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was clearly disclosed in Schedule BP and forms an integral part of the return.

The mere procedural lapse of not originally populating Schedule DPM should not result in denial of a legitimate claim under law, especially when the depreciation was already accounted for and supported by calculations in Schedule BP.

Depreciation under Section 32 is a statutory allowance, and once the conditions under that section are satisfied and adequate details are furnished (as done subsequently), disallowance solely due to non-filing of a supporting schedule cannot be justified. The relevant provisions of the Act read as follows:

"Depreciation.

32.

(1) In respect of depreciation of--

(i)

buildings, machinery, plant or furniture, being tangible assets;

(ii)

know-how, patents, copyrights, trademarks, licences, franchises or any otherbusinessor commercial rights of similar nature, being intangible assets acquired onor after the 1st day of April, 1998, owned, wholly or partly, by the assessee and used for the purposes of the business or profession, the following deductions shall beallowed--

(i)

....

(ii)

in the case of any block of assets, such percentage on the written down valuethereof as may be prescribed:

Provided that

Explanation 5.--For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that the provisions ofthis sub-section shall apply whether or not the assessee has claimed the deduction inrespect of depreciation in computing his total income; (iia) in the case of any newmachinery or plant (other than ships and aircraft), which has been acquired andinstalled after the 31st day of March, 2005, by an assessee engaged in the business ofmanufacture or production of any article or thing or in the business of generation orgeneration and distribution of power, a further sum equal to twenty per cent of theactual cost of such machinery or plant shall be allowed as deduction under clause (ii)

: ............"

 The Courts have consistently held that procedural technicalities should not override substantive rights, and that rectification under Section 154 is permissible when there is a mistake apparent from the record, as in this case.

 Denial of depreciation, despite all details being subsequently submitted, results in unjust enrichment of the revenue and causes undue hardship to the appellant.

9.

Ld. AR of the assessee placed reliance on the following case laws:-

Vedanta Limited (Successor To Cairn ... vs PrincipalCommissioner Of Income ... on 19 March, 2018 [ High Court of Delhi at New Delhi]

“6.

This court is of opinion that the plain text of the explanation leaves no room for admitting theinterpretive gloss that the assessee wishes to place over it. There can be a multitude ofcircumstances where, but for the provision, the incentive, available to all those for whom the benefitof additional depreciation was intended, could have been deprived of it. Undoubtedly, the amount of the assessee's claim for Section 80IB deduction increased, when it sought to withdraw the additionaldepreciation claim. However, that single circumstance should not influence this court to ignore theplain intendment of the statute, since Parliament clearly stated that the provisions of "thissub-section" would apply, "whether or not the assessee has claimed the deduction in respect ofdepreciation in computing his total income".This court cannot re-write the statute, as is sought to beurged. For thesereasons, the Court is of the opinion that no question of law arises on this aspect.”

[2024] 158 taxmann.com 12 (Hyderabad - Trib.)/[2024] 205 ITD 217 (Hyderabad -Trib.)[26-12-2023]IN THE ITAT HYDERABAD BENCH 'A'S&P Capital IQ (India) (P.) Ltd.v.Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax

“15.

Explanation 5 to Section 32(1) of the Act clearly lays down that the provisions of such sub-section shallapply whether or not the assessee has claimed the deduction in respect of the depreciation in computing thetotal income. It, therefore, goes without saying that irrespective of the fact of assessee claiming or not, thedepreciation shall be allowed while computing the total income of the assessee. Then it becomes theobligation on the part of the Revenue to allow depreciation on goodwill even if it is not claimed by the assessee. At the same time, the CBDT Circular No. 14 (XL - 35) of 1955, date 11/04/1955, reinforces thisobligation in unequivocal terms, stating that the department must not take advantage of ignorance of any assessee as to his rights and it is one of the duties of the department to assist a taxpayer in every reasonableway, particularly in the matter of claiming and securing reliefs, by taking initiative in guiding the taxpayerwhere the proceedings are before them indicate that some relief is due to the taxpayer. When we readExplanation 5 to Section 32(1) of the Act and the above circular issued by the CBDT in the context of Article365 of the Constitution of India, we find it difficult to uphold the action of the authorities below in depriving the assessee of the claim for deduction of depreciation on goodwill.

16.

For the reasons set forth in the foregoing paragraphs, we are of the considered opinion that disallowanceof the claim for deduction of depreciation on goodwill by the authorities below cannot be sustained and thesame is liable to be deleted. We hold and order so. Grounds of appeal are accordingly allowed.

17.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed.”

CIT v. Mahalaxmi Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. [1986] 160 ITR 920 (SC) "It is well-settled that a claim, if allowable under law, cannot be disallowed merely because a wrong section has been quoted or wrong form has been filed, so long as the necessary facts are on record."

Goetze (India) Ltd. v. CIT [2006] 284 ITR 323 (SC) While the Supreme Court restricted the AO's power to entertain new claims without revised return, it clarified that the appellate authorities are not barred from entertaining such claims if the supporting facts are already on record.

CIT v. Shelly Products [2003] 261 ITR 367 (SC) "Where an assessee’s legal right is denied merely on technical grounds, such denial would be unjustified.

CIT v. Infosys Technologies Ltd. [2012] 341 ITR 293 (Kar.)

The Karnataka High Court held that a statutory deduction cannot be denied solely due to a technical or clerical error in the return if the assessee is otherwise eligible.

DCIT v. Prithvi Insurance Brokers (P.) Ltd. [2016] 160 ITD 400 (Mumbai - Trib.) Held that depreciation under Section 32 cannot be denied merely due to non-filing or defective filing of Schedule DPM, where sufficient supporting evidence is available on record.

Depreciation is a statutory allowance under Section 32 of the Income Tax Act, and once the eligibility conditions are met and details have been provided—even if through rectification—the same cannot be denied merely due to a procedural omission like the non-filing of Schedule DPM.

The rejection of the rectification applications under Section 154 is not sustainable in law, as the mistake was apparent and rectifiable, and the depreciation claim was substantiated through Schedule BP and further rectified by furnishing full details.

10.

In light of the above, it is respectfully requested that the disallowance of depreciation amountof Rs. 2,62,860/- be deleted, the total income be revised accordingly, and the resultant demand of Rs.1,12,200/- be withdrawn. It is further requested that appropriate relief be granted under the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

11.

On the other hand, ld. DR of the Revenue relied on the orders of the authorities below.

12.

Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed from the record that the assessee inadvertently omitted to fill the schedule DPM but filled the schedule BP properly. The claim of the depreciation as per section 32 was claimed in the schedule BP and the above claim is properly matching to the schedule BP submitted by the assessee while filing the rectification application. However, the same was rejected by the tax authorities with the observation that at the time of processing, system do not allowclaim in absence of figures mentioned in schedule DPM. After considering the submissions of both parties, the system may not accept the claim due to absence of figures, but at the time of rectification, the humans are being tasked to rectify the genuine mistake. The officers are not inclined to look at the genuine hardship of the assessee and also it is the duty of the officers to make sure that genuine claims of the assessee should be entertained. In the given case, the claim of the assessee is genuine as per law, the claim of the depreciation is automatic and the same cannot be declined merely transferring the blame to the machine or system. We are aware that the machine is dumb, it carries on its activities as per set coded system. That is the reason, human interface was introduced in the rectification process, even then the officers areintend to work as dumb like the machine. In our considered view, claim of the assessee is genuine as per law, we direct the JAO to allow the claim of depreciation in this case. In the result, grounds raised by the assessee in this regard are allowed.

13.

In the result, appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.