Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 10 CAT CK 5070

Shiv Singh Vs Union Of India & Ors.

Central Administrative Tribunal · Allahabad · 29 Oct 2026 · Om Prakash VII, Member (J)

Open full page

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 1,210 words

The present Original Application has been filed by the applicant under section 19 of the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985 seeking following reliefs:-

“a)

This Hon'ble Tribunal may kindly be pleased to quash and set aside the impugned order dated 25.09.2026 in respect of applicant and direct the respondents to post him as General Assistant (General Admin) under Assistant Chief Medical Superintended, Juhi, North Central Railway, Jhansi Division, Jhansi in pursuance of letter of said authority dated 20.04.2026 and 16.09.2026 with all consequential benefits.

b)

Any other relief, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case may be given in favour of the applicant.

c)

Award the costs of the original application in favour of the applicant”.

2.

The brief facts of the case are as follows: The applicant was initially appointed as House Keeping Assistant in the Medical Department of North Central Railway and was posted under the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, Jhansi Division. Subsequently, as the work of cleanliness and malaria control was decided to be carried out through a contractor, the applicant and other House Keeping Assistants were declared surplus. Vide letter dated 20.04.2026, the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, informed the respondent No. 3 about the status of surplus staff and recommended that the applicant be posted at Juhi, considering his knowledge and experience of the work. The applicant also submitted a representation dated 21.05.2026 requesting his posting at the Health Centre, Juhi Railway Colony. Thereafter, the respondents conducted screening on 07.09.2026 and, vide order dated 11.09.2026, allotted the applicant the post of General Assistant (General Administration). Subsequently, the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, again requested the respondents vide letter dated 16.09.2026 to post the applicant at Juhi, as the services of one General Assistant were required there. However, vide impugned order dated 25.09.2026, the respondents posted the applicant as General Assistant (General Administration) under the Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, Jhansi Division. Aggrieved by the said posting, the applicant submitted a representation dated 10.10.2026 requesting reconsideration of his posting. As his grievance was not resolved, he has filed the present Original Application challenging the impugned order.

3.

I have heard Mr. Rakesh Kumar Dixit, learned counsel for the applicant, and Shri Anil Kumar, learned counsel for the respondents, and have perused the record.

4.

Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant was initially working as House Keeping Assistant in the Medical Department of North Central Railway, Juhi, Jhansi Division. As the work of cleanliness and malaria control was decided to be carried out through a contractor, the applicant was declared surplus. Thereafter, he was screened and allotted the post of General Assistant (General Administration) vide order dated 11.09.2026. Learned counsel for the applicant further submitted that the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, vide letter dated 20.04.2026, had recommended that the applicant be retained under his office, considering his experience and the administrative requirements. The applicant also submitted a representation dated 21.05.2026 requesting his posting at the Health Centre, Juhi. Subsequently, vide letter dated 16.09.2026, the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent again requested the respondents to post the applicant at Juhi, as the services of a General Assistant were required there. However, the respondents, vide order dated 25.09.2026, posted the applicant under the Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, Jhansi Division. Learned counsel for the applicant next submitted that the respondents have failed to consider the genuine request for his posting at Juhi, despite the recommendation and administrative requirement expressed by the concerned Medical Officer. It is further submitted that the applicant is visually impaired in one eye and is a person with disability. According to the applicant, the respondents have also failed to consider his family circumstances, as his father has expired, his mother is about 65 years old and is undergoing treatment in Kanpur and he is required to look after her. It is contended that his posting away from Juhi would cause hardship to his family and adversely affect the education of the children. Thus learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the impugned posting order has been passed without properly considering the applicant’s disability, family circumstances and the administrative requirement at Juhi. The applicant seeks appropriate directions to the respondents to consider his representation and accommodate him as General Assistant at the Health Centre, Juhi. Thus, argued to decide the OA at this stage itself.

5.

In rebuttal, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that, after the applicant and other House Keeping Assistants were declared surplus, the prescribed screening process was conducted on 07.09.2026 and the applicant was allotted the post of General Assistant (General Administration) vide order dated 11.09.2026. Thereafter, vide order dated 25.09.2026, he was posted under the Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, Jhansi Division, in accordance with the administrative arrangement. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the letter dated 20.04.2026 from the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, regarding surplus staff and the availability of posts did not specifically recommend the applicant by name for posting at Juhi. It is also contended that no sanctioned post of General Assistant at Level-1 was available under the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi. According to the respondents, a General Assistant had already been posted at the Health Unit, Orai, against an available vacancy. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that, apart from the letter dated 16.09.2026, no earlier communication specifically concerning the applicant’s request for posting at Juhi was received by the concerned section before issuance of the posting order dated 25.09.2026. It is stated that the applicant’s representation dated 10.10.2026 was received after issuance of the said order and is presently under consideration in accordance with the applicable rules and instructions. Thus he submitted that the posting order was issued on administrative grounds and pray that the O.A. be dismissed.

6.

I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for both parties and perused the material available on record.

7.

From the perusal of the record, it is evident that the applicant seeks posting at the Health Centre, Juhi, on the basis of the letters dated 20.04.2026 and 16.09.2026 issued by the Assistant Chief Medical Superintendent, Juhi, indicating the requirement of a General Assistant. The respondents, on the other hand, have contended that no sanctioned post of General Assistant at Level-1 is available under the said authority.

8.

In these circumstances, the applicant’s representation requires proper consideration by the competent authority, taking into account the aforesaid letters, his disability and family circumstances, the availability of a sanctioned post and the administrative requirements of the department. It is, therefore, appropriate to direct the competent authority to take a reasoned decision on the applicant’s representation dated 10.10.2026.

9.

Accordingly, the O.A. is disposed of at the admission stage without entering into the merits of the case with a direction to the competent authority to consider and decide the applicant’s representation dated 10.10.2026 by passing a reasoned and speaking order, in accordance with the applicable rules within two months from the date of this order. The decision so taken shall be communicated to the applicant. Till the aforesaid decision is taken, the effect and operation of the impugned order dated 25.09.2026 shall remain stayed. There shall be no order as to costs. All pending M.As. stand disposed of.