Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 10 CAT CK 3388

Union Of India & Anr. Vs Sh. Mandip Singh

Central Administrative Tribunal · New Delhi · 22 Oct 2026 · Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J) · Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A)

Open full page

Judgment

7 paragraphs · 1,002 words

Hon'ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A):

By means of the present Review Application filed under Section 22(3)(f) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 read with Rule 17 of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1987 and Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the Review Applicants (original respondents in O.A. No. 891/2016) seek review and recall of the judgment and final order dated 19.01.2026 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 891/2016, along with an accompanying application for condonation of delay of 212 days in instituting the Review Application.

2.

The brief factual background of the dispute is that the original applicant, Sh. Mandip Singh, was appointed as a Ticket Collector in Northern Railway on 29.06.1996 under the Sports Quota. During his service, he achieved various distinctions in athletics, securing a Bronze Medal in 1997, a Silver Medal in 1998, and a Gold Medal in the 400m hurdles event in 1999 at the All India Open Athletic Championships. Over the course of time, after engaging in prior rounds of litigation to secure out-of-turn promotion, the original applicant instituted O.A. No. 891/2016 in the year 2016 seeking directions for payment of additional sports incentive increments for his national level sports achievements in terms of the Railway Board Circular dated 20.06.2006, along with arrears and consequential benefits.

3.

The original respondents opposed the O.A. by contending inter alia that the application was heavily barred by limitation, delay, and laches as it sought benefits for achievements dating back to 1997–1999 after an unexplained lapse of 16 to 18 years. It was further pleaded by the respondents that the grant of sports incentive increments for Bronze and Silver medal performances was not automatic but was subject to the advice/recommendation of the Railway Sports Promotion Board (RSPB), which was never made in the applicant’s case. Additionally, the respondents asserted that under the revised Railway Board policy dated 31.12.2010, a ceiling of a maximum of five sports incentive increments during an entire service career had been imposed, whereas the applicant had already been granted as many as eleven sports/advance incentive increments during his service tenure.

4.

This Tribunal, vide judgment and order dated 19.01.2026, allowed O.A. No. 891/2016, principally drawing parity with the case of one Sh. Tejinder Pal Singh (a cricketer who had been granted out-of-turn promotion with four additional increments in 2002), and directed Respondent No. 1 to consider paying the admissible incentive increments along with consequential benefits. The Review Applicants initially challenged the said judgment dated 19.01.2026 before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi by way of W.P.(C) No. 11607/2026, which was permitted to be withdrawn vide order dated 13.08.2026 with liberty to file a review application before this Tribunal.

5.

Having carefully perused the Review Application, the grounds set forth therein, and the material available on record, we have given our thoughtful consideration to the matter. It is a well-settled principle of law governing review jurisdiction under Section 22(3)(f) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985—which is analogous to Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code—that a review of a judgment is permissible only on limited grounds, namely, discovery of new and important matter or evidence which was not within the knowledge of the applicant or could not be produced at the time when the order was passed, or on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason. It is equally well established through a long line of authoritative judicial precedents of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, including Parsion Devi vs. Sumitri Devi [(1997) 8 SCC 715], Lily Thomas vs. Union of India [(2000) 6 SCC 224], State of West Bengal vs. Kamal Sengupta [(2008) 8 SCC 612], and Union of India vs. Tarit Baran Dey [(1998) 8 SCC 481], that the scope of review is extremely restricted and cannot be treated as an appeal in disguise. A review application cannot be entertained merely to rehear arguments on merits, re-examine pleadings, or substitute one plausible view with another. An error apparent on the face of the record must be a patent defect or an error which is self-evident and does not require an elaborate process of reasoning or long drawn out arguments to establish.

6.

In the present Review Application, the Review Applicants have extensively argued that the Tribunal overlooked their preliminary objections regarding limitation and delay, omitted to discuss the lack of RSPB recommendation, failed to evaluate the policy ceiling of five increments under the 2010 circular, and incorrectly applied the principle of parity with Sh. Tejinder Pal Singh. However, a close inspection of the record reveals that all these contentions, affidavits, policies, and factual distinctions were already pleaded, submitted, and fully available before the Tribunal at the time of final hearing of the O.A. The Coordinate Bench, after calling for an additional affidavit specifically on the comparative facts of Sh. Tejinder Pal Singh and examining the entire service and administrative records, consciously evaluated the comparative merits and arrived at a considered judicial conclusion on grounds of equity, parity, and non-discrimination under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Whether the Tribunal's decision in granting relief on grounds of parity was correct on merits or whether a different interpretation of the administrative rules/circulars ought to have been taken are matters strictly within the domain of an appellate forum and cannot be re-agitated or re-adjudicated under the garb of a Review Application. If the Review Applicants are aggrieved by the findings or conclusions recorded in the judgment dated 19.01.2026, the appropriate remedy lies in challenging the order before the higher judicial forum in accordance with law rather than seeking a full re-hearing of the original matter before this Tribunal. Consequently, we find no error apparent on the face of the record, nor any fresh material, which would justify invoking our review jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Review Application, along with the pending M.A. for condonation of delay, lacks merit and is hereby dismissed, with no order as to costs