Abhinav Kumar Singh Vs Union Of India & Anr.
Central Administrative Tribunal · Allahabad · 13 Nov 2026 · Rajnish Kumar Rai, Member (J)
Judgment
Facts of OA 427 of 2026
The applicant has approached this Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking quashing and setting aside of the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 and a direction to the respondents/competent authority not to interfere with his peaceful functioning at the present place of posting until completion of his minimum tenure of two years, in terms of the Railway Board Circular dated 31.08.2015. The reliefs sought by the applicant are as follows:-
“i.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature quashing and setting aside the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 (Annexure No. A-1 to this OA with compilation no. I).
ii.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the respondents/competent authority not to interfere in the peaceful functioning of the applicant at the present place of posting or till completion of his minimum tenure of 2 years in view of the Railway Board Circular dated 31.08.2015.
iii.To issue any other order or direction, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
iv.To award the cost of the application to the applicant.”
The brief facts of the case are that the applicant, Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh, has filed the present Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, challenging the transfer order dated 13.04.2026, whereby he was transferred from the post of Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, Varanasi Division, North Eastern Railway, to the post of Deputy Chief Personnel Officer (Gazetted), Gorakhpur Headquarters, on the same pay and allowances. The applicant was selected through the UPSC Civil Services Examination and allotted the Indian Railway Personnel Service (IRPS). He joined as Assistant Personnel Officer at Varanasi Division on 07.06.2021, was promoted as Divisional Personnel Officer on 21.02.2023 and posted at Izzatnagar Division, and was thereafter transferred to Varanasi on 04.03.2025. He subsequently assumed charge as Sr. DPO, Varanasi, on 26.08.2025. The applicant contends that the impugned transfer was ordered before completion of his normal tenure of two years and during the middle of the academic session. He has also referred to his wife’s research work at Banaras Hindu University and the admission of his daughter, Nitya Singh, to Nursery at My Nurture School, Mehmorganj, Varanasi, for the academic session 2026–27. He submitted a representation dated 14.04.2026 seeking reconsideration of the transfer order.
Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was premature, as the applicant had assumed charge as Sr. DPO, Varanasi, only on 26.08.2025 and had not completed the normal tenure of two years prescribed under the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy dated 31.08.2015. It was contended that the transfer order did not disclose any specific administrative exigency warranting the applicant’s premature transfer and that the relevant procedure concerning the Transfer Placement Committee had not been followed in accordance with the applicable instructions. Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant’s wife was pursuing research work at Banaras Hindu University and his daughter was attending school at Varanasi, and that the transfer during the academic session would cause avoidable hardship to the family. It was argued that the transfer order was liable to be quashed for non-compliance with the applicable transfer policy and the relevant instructions. Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the impugned transfer order be set aside and that the respondents be directed not to disturb the applicant’s posting at Varanasi before completion of his normal tenure.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the Original Application and submitted that the impugned transfer order had been issued by the competent authority in the administrative interest of the department. It was contended that the applicant had misinterpreted the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy dated 31.08.2015, which provides that the minimum tenure of two years is not applicable to Junior Scale/Senior Scale officers of Group ‘A’, although relaxation may be granted by the cadre-controlling officer in administrative exigencies. Learned counsel further submitted that the transfer had been made on the basis of administrative requirements and the recommendation of the Transfer Placement Committee, and that the relevant records concerning the transfer decision would establish the administrative necessity for the same. It was argued that transfer is an incident of service and that the applicant had no vested right to continue at a particular place of posting. The respondents, therefore, opposed the prayer for interim protection and sought dismissal of the Original Application.
In the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents, the allegations and grounds raised in the Original Application have been denied, except those specifically admitted or borne out by the record. The respondents have stated that the applicant was transferred in accordance with the applicable rules and administrative requirements. They have disputed the applicant’s contention that the transfer was contrary to the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy and maintained that the transfer was necessitated by administrative exigencies, including the requirement to fill the post of Deputy Chief Personnel Officer (Gazetted) at Gorakhpur Headquarters. The respondents have further contended that the applicant’s interpretation of the tenure provisions was incorrect and that the transfer order did not suffer from any illegality warranting interference by this Tribunal.
The applicant filed a rejoinder affidavit, disputing the contentions raised in the counter reply and reiterating the grounds taken in the Original Application. The applicant contended that the respondents had not placed on record adequate material demonstrating the administrative exigency for his premature transfer or the reasons recorded by the Transfer Placement Committee. He further submitted that, although the applicable policy contemplates consideration of administrative exigencies and recording of reasons, the prescribed procedure had not been shown to have been followed in the present case. The applicant also relied upon the Railway Board’s instructions dated 10.06.2014 concerning the implementation of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.S.R. Subramanian and Others v. Union of India and Others, (2013) 15 SCC 732.
The applicant also filed a supplementary affidavit placing additional documents and subsequent developments on record. In the supplementary affidavit, the applicant referred to the subsequent posting of Shri Arvind Kumar Srivastava against the post of Deputy Chief Personnel Officer (Gazetted), Gorakhpur Headquarters, who, according to the applicant, assumed charge on 15.07.2026. The applicant relied upon this subsequent development in support of his submissions concerning the availability and occupation of the post to which he had been transferred. The supplementary affidavit and the documents annexed thereto have also been taken into consideration along with the original pleadings, counter reply and rejoinder affidavit.
Learned counsel for the applicant, in the written arguments, further submitted that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was contrary to the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy dated 31.08.2015, as the applicant had not completed the normal tenure of two years at the post of Sr. DPO, Varanasi, and the transfer was ordered during the middle of the academic session. It was further submitted that the applicant’s wife was pursuing her Ph.D. at Banaras Hindu University and his daughter had been admitted to school at Varanasi for the academic session 2026– 27, for which the requisite fees had already been deposited. Learned counsel also referred to the subsequent administrative developments, including the order dated 15.05.2026 modifying the arrangement concerning the post of Deputy Chief Personnel Officer (Gazetted), Gorakhpur, and the subsequent transfer and relieving orders concerning Shri Rahul Yadav. It was contended that, in view of these subsequent developments, the post to which the applicant had been transferred under the impugned order was no longer available in the same manner and the transfer order dated 13.04.2026 could not be implemented as originally contemplated. Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the impugned transfer order be quashed and that the respondents be directed not to disturb the applicant’s peaceful functioning at his present place of posting before completion of his normal tenure, in accordance with the applicable Railway Board instructions and the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.S.R. Subramanian and Others v. Union of India and Others, (2013) 15 SCC 732.
Facts of OA 728 of 2026
The applicant has approached this Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking directions restraining the respondents from relieving him pursuant to the Railway Board transfer order dated 05.06.2026 till finalization of O.A. No. 427 of 2026, quashing of the subsequent transfer order dated 09.07.2026, and a declaration that the action of the respondents in treating the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence vide order dated 15.05.2026 is illegal and arbitrary, along with payment of full pay and allowances for the said period by treating it as on duty with all consequential benefits. The reliefs sought by the applicant are as follows:-
“i.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the respondents/competent authority not to relieve the applicant in view of the Railway Board transfer order dated 05.06.2026, till finalization of the court case filed by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh bearing OA no. 427/2026.
i(a) to issue a suitable order or direction in the suitable nature quashing and setting aside the impugned transfer order dated 09.07.2026 issued pursuant to the letter dated 05.06.2026.
ii.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the respondents/competent authority declaring that the action of the respondents in treating the period 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absent vide order dated 15.05.2026 is illegal and arbitrary.
iii.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the respondents/competent authority to pay the full pay and allowances treating the intervening period as on duty from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 with all consequential benefits.
iv.To issue any other order or direction, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
v.To award the cost of the application to the applicant.”
The brief facts of the case are that the applicant, Shri Rahul Yadav, was selected through the Civil Services Examination conducted by the UPSC in 2014 and allotted the Indian Railway Personnel Service (IRPS). After serving at different places, he was posted at Lucknow as Sr. DPO on 03.03.2023, allegedly on spouse grounds, as his wife is a Judicial Officer posted at Lucknow. Vide transfer order dated 13.04.2026, he was transferred from Lucknow to Varanasi as Sr. DPO. The applicant states that the transfer order was communicated to him through a WhatsApp group on 14.04.2026 and that his leave from 17.04.2026 to 15.05.2026 had been sanctioned by the competent authority. According to him, the officer transferred in his place at Lucknow assumed charge on 16.04.2026, and his leave was subsequently cancelled by communication dated 30.04.2026. The applicant states that, upon reporting at Varanasi on 19.05.2026, he found that the post of Sr. DPO was occupied by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh pursuant to the interim order dated 23.04.2026 passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. He thereafter sought clarification from the competent authority and was directed to join as Sr. DPO (Coordination), Varanasi, where he assumed charge on 05.06.2026. Meanwhile, the Railway Board’s order dated 05.06.2026 provided for his inter-zonal transfer from North Eastern Railway to North Central Railway, followed by Office Order No. 159/2026 dated 09.07.2026 and a consequential relieving order dated 15.07.2026. The applicant has also challenged the order dated 15.05.2026 treating the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence and denying pay and allowances for the said period.
Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the successive transfer orders dated 13.04.2026 and 09.07.2026 were issued without disclosing any specific administrative exigency and before completion of the applicant’s normal tenure at Lucknow. It was contended that the applicant’s posting at Lucknow was on spouse grounds and that the repeated transfer and posting actions within a short period raised questions regarding the bona fides of the decisions. Learned counsel further submitted that the transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was communicated to the applicant through WhatsApp on 14.04.2026, whereas the handing-over and taking-over reports of the officers concerned were dated 13.04.2026. It was argued that the applicant was on sanctioned leave, that his leave was subsequently cancelled, and that he could not join the post of Sr. DPO, Varanasi, because it was occupied by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh pursuant to the interim order passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. The applicant, according to learned counsel, sought clarification through the administrative channel and complied with the subsequent directions by joining as Sr. DPO (Coordination), Varanasi. Learned counsel submitted that the respondents had not produced adequate documentary proof of communication of the impugned orders through e-Office and had not disclosed the contemporaneous administrative reasons for the successive transfer actions. It was further argued that the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 should be treated as duty, as the applicant had acted in good faith and had not deliberately disobeyed any lawful direction. Reliance was placed upon the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy dated 31.08.2015 and the judgment in T.S.R. Subramanian and Others v. Union of India and Others, (2013) 15 SCC 732.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the Original Application and submitted that the transfer orders had been issued by the competent authority in the administrative interest of the department and in accordance with the applicable rules and instructions. It was contended that transfer is an incident of service and that the applicant could not claim an indefeasible right to remain posted at a particular station merely on the basis of his spouse’s posting. The respondents disputed the allegations of mala fides and harassment and maintained that the applicant was required to comply with the transfer orders. They further questioned the maintainability of the Original Application on the grounds stated in their counter reply and contended that the applicant had already been relieved from Varanasi. The respondents also sought vacation of the interim protection granted by this Tribunal.
In the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents, the averments made in the Original Application have been denied, except those specifically admitted or borne out by the record. The respondents have contended that the actions taken by the competent authorities were in accordance with the applicable rules and that the Original Application was not maintainable on the grounds stated in the counter reply. They have further pleaded that the applicant had already been relieved from Varanasi and was required to join at the place of his subsequent posting. The respondents disputed the applicant’s challenge to the transfer orders and his claim for treating the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as duty, maintaining that the consequential service benefits claimed by him were not admissible as asserted. The respondents also filed an affidavit/application seeking vacation of the interim order dated 05.08.2026.
The applicant filed a rejoinder affidavit in response to the counter reply, disputing the respondents’ contentions and reiterating the grounds raised in the Original Application. The applicant disputed the respondents’ contention regarding maintainability and asserted that the reliefs arose from the successive transfer actions and the order treating the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence. He further contended that the respondents had not satisfactorily explained the circumstances in which the subsequent transfer orders were issued and that the period in question was not attributable to any wilful default on his part. The applicant reiterated his prayer for setting aside the impugned transfer order dated 09.07.2026 and for treating the intervening period as duty with admissible consequential benefits.
In the written arguments filed on behalf of the applicant, learned counsel reiterated the challenge to the successive transfer actions and submitted that the relevant administrative reasons and contemporaneous record supporting the impugned orders had not been disclosed. Reliance was placed upon T.S.R. Subramanian and Others v. Union of India and Others, (2013) 15 SCC 732, particularly in support of the submissions concerning minimum tenure and the recording of official directions and decisions. The applicant also referred to the Railway Board’s Comprehensive Transfer Policy dated 31.08.2015 and the circumstances surrounding the communication and implementation of the transfer orders, as well as the treatment of the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence. These were the submissions advanced by the applicant in support of the reliefs sought in the present Original Application.
Learned counsel for the respondents relied upon the judgments and orders contained in the compilation filed on their behalf, including Gujarat Electricity Board v. Atmaram Sungomal Poshani, AIR 1989 SC 1433; Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar, AIR 1991 SC 532; Rajendra Roy v. Union of India, (1993) 1 SCC 148; Union of India v. G. Ganayutham, (1997) 7 SCC 463; and S.C. Saxena v. Union of India, (2006) 9 SCC 583. Learned counsel also placed reliance upon the orders passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 1079 of 2026 and O.A. No. 1171 of 2025. On the basis of the aforesaid judgments and orders, the respondents submitted that transfer is ordinarily an incident of service, that an employee has no indefeasible right to remain posted at a particular place, and that judicial interference with a transfer order is warranted only on legally recognised grounds. The respondents also relied upon the relevant departmental transfer and relieving orders in support of their submissions.
By order dated 05.08.2026, this Tribunal stayed the operation of the transfer order dated 09.07.2026 and the consequential relieving order until the next date of listing. The respondents subsequently filed an affidavit/application seeking vacation of the interim order. The said interim order and the subsequent proceedings concerning its vacation form part of the record of the present Original Application.
Facts of OA 1063 of 2026
The applicant has approached this Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking quashing of the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 and a direction to the respondents/competent authority to accommodate him at his previous place of posting as Sr. DPO, Lucknow, on spouse grounds in accordance with the applicable Railway Board Circular, along with payment of regular salary as and when due. The reliefs sought by the applicant are as follows:-
“i.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature quashing and setting aside the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 (Annexure No. A-1 to this OA with compilation no. I).
ii.To issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the respondents/competent authority to accommodate the applicant at the previous place of posting as Sr. DPO Lucknow, on spouse grounds as per Railway Board Circular, and pay the regular salary as and when it becomes due.
iii.To issue any other order or direction, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
iv.To award the cost of the application to the applicant.”
The brief facts of the case are that the applicant, Shri Rahul Yadav, has filed the present Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, challenging the transfer order dated 13.04.2026, whereby he was transferred from the post of Senior Divisional Personnel Officer (Sr. DPO), Lucknow Division, to the post of Sr. DPO, Varanasi Division, on the same pay and allowances. The applicant contends that the impugned transfer order was issued before completion of his normal tenure at Lucknow, where he had been posted on spouse grounds, as his wife is a Judicial Officer posted at Lucknow. He has also challenged the consequential action taken by the respondents, including the treatment of the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence and the denial of salary and allowances for the said period. The applicant has, therefore, sought quashing of the impugned transfer order and a direction to the respondents to accommodate him at his previous place of posting at Lucknow on spouse grounds in accordance with the applicable Railway Board instructions, along with consequential benefits.
Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was issued prematurely, without assigning any justifiable administrative reason and without due consideration of the applicant’s posting at Lucknow on spouse grounds. It was further submitted that the applicant’s leave had been sanctioned by the competent authority, but was subsequently cancelled, and that the applicant acted bona fide throughout. Learned counsel contended that the applicant could not join the originally designated post at Varanasi because the same was already occupied by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh pursuant to the interim order dated 23.04.2026 passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. It was argued that the applicant sought clarification from the competent authority and thereafter complied with the directions issued to him. Therefore, treating the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as unauthorized absence and withholding salary and allowances for the said period was unjustified. Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the reliefs sought in the Original Application be granted.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the Original Application and submitted that the transfer order had been issued in the administrative interest of the department and in accordance with the applicable rules and instructions. It was contended that the applicant had served at Lucknow for a substantial period and that posting on spouse grounds does not confer an indefeasible right to remain at a particular station. Learned counsel further submitted that transfers are an incident of service and that the competent authority is empowered to transfer an officer in the interest of administration. The respondents also disputed the applicant’s allegations of mala fides and contended that the applicant was not entitled to the reliefs claimed in the Original Application.
In the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents, the averments made in the Original Application have been denied, except those specifically admitted or borne out by the record. The respondents have stated that the transfer was made in accordance with the applicable rules and administrative requirements. They have further contended that the applicant had already joined at Varanasi pursuant to the transfer order dated 13.04.2026 and was subsequently transferred to North Central Railway by order dated 05.06.2026, followed by the order dated 09.07.2026. The respondents have also disputed the applicant’s claim regarding the period treated as absence and the consequential denial of salary and allowances, maintaining that the action taken by the competent authority was in accordance with the applicable rules. The respondents have, therefore, prayed for dismissal of the Original Application.
Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that he does not wish to file any rejoinder affidavit and requested that the matter be heard finally on the basis of the pleadings and documents already available on record. Accordingly, the case is being heard finally.
Learned counsel for the applicant, in the written arguments, further submitted that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was communicated to the applicant through WhatsApp on 14.04.2026, whereas the handing-over and taking-over reports of the officers concerned were dated 13.04.2026. It was contended that the applicant was on sanctioned leave from 17.04.2026 to 15.05.2026, which was subsequently cancelled, and that, upon reporting for duty at Varanasi, he found the post of Sr. DPO already occupied by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh pursuant to the interim order dated 23.04.2026 passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant sought clarification from the competent authority and, in compliance with the subsequent directions, joined as Sr. DPO (Coordination), Varanasi, on 05.06.2026. It was argued that the subsequent transfer orders dated 05.06.2026 and 09.07.2026, the absence of disclosed administrative exigency, and the treatment of the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence raised questions requiring consideration in the light of the applicable Railway Board transfer guidelines and the circumstances pleaded by the applicant. Learned counsel also drew attention to the fact that the counter reply on behalf of the respondents had been signed by the Deputy CPO/Gazetted, who, according to the applicant, was also one of the officers figuring in the transfer order dated 13.04.2026, and submitted that this circumstance should be considered while examining the matter.
Conclusion in the connected Original Applications.
I have heard Mr. Vinod Kumar, learned counsel for the applicants, and Mr. Anil Kumar, learned counsel for the respondents, in O.A. Nos. 427 of 2026, 728 of 2026 and 1063 of 2026, and Mr. K.P. Singh, learned counsel for the respondents, in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. I have carefully considered the rival submissions advanced on their behalf and have also perused the pleadings and documents available on record.
The record reveals that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 formed part of a composite arrangement for transfer and posting of four JAG officers of the Personnel Department of North Eastern Railway. As reflected in the departmental note-sheet, the proposal was to transfer Shri V.K. Dwivedi from the post of Deputy CPO/HQ to the post of Chairman/RRC/GKP in place of Shri Rajesh Kumar Gupta; Shri Rajesh Kumar Gupta from the post of Chairman/RRC/GKP to the post of Senior DPO, Lucknow, in place of Shri Rahul Yadav; Shri Rahul Yadav from the post of Senior DPO, Lucknow, to the post of Senior DPO, Varanasi (BSB), in place of Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh and Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh from the post of Senior DPO, Varanasi (BSB), to the post of Deputy CPO (Gazetted), by redesignating the post of Deputy CPO/HQ as Deputy CPO (Gazetted), North Eastern Railway. The proposal was placed before the Placement Committee and, after its recommendation and approval of the competent authority, the transfer/posting orders were issued on 13.04.2026.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid transfer order, Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh approached this Tribunal by filing O.A. No. 427 of 2026, raising, inter alia, his personal and family circumstances and contending that he had not completed the minimum tenure at Varanasi. This Tribunal, vide order dated 23.04.2026, granted interim protection by staying the effect and operation of the impugned transfer order in respect of the applicant, if the same had not already been given effect to. In view of the aforesaid interim order, Shri Rahul Yadav, who had also been transferred from the post of Senior DPO, Lucknow, to the post of Senior DPO, Varanasi, could not join against the said post. Subsequently, the respondents issued departmental Office Order No. 128/2026 dated 04.06.2026, whereby the post of Deputy CPO (Gazetted) at Gorakhpur was shifted to Varanasi Division and redesignated as Senior DPO (Coordination), and Shri Rahul Yadav was directed to work against the said arrangement. Accordingly, he joined as Senior DPO (Coordination), Varanasi, on 05.06.2026. Separately, the Railway Board, vide its order dated 05.06.2026, ordered the inter-zonal transfer of Shri Rahul Yadav, JAG/IRPS, from North Eastern Railway to North Central Railway and the reciprocal transfer of Shri Ashish Sachan, JAG/IRPS, from North Central Railway to North Eastern Railway. Pursuant to the said arrangement, Shri Ashish Sachan joined North Eastern Railway at Gorakhpur, whereas Shri Rahul Yadav was transferred to North Central Railway, Prayagraj. Thereafter, the respondents issued a further transfer order dated 09.07.2026, followed by the consequential relieving order, directing Shri Rahul Yadav to join at North Central Railway, Prayagraj. Challenging the aforesaid transfer and consequential relieving orders, Shri Rahul Yadav filed O.A. No. 728 of 2026. Initially, no interim protection was granted in the said Original Application, however, this Tribunal, vide order dated 05.08.2026, stayed the operation of the transfer order dated 09.07.2026 as well as the consequential relieving order till the next date of listing.
In the meantime, pursuant to the departmental arrangement dated 04.06.2026, Shri Rahul Yadav was permitted to work as Senior DPO (Coordination) at Varanasi, while Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh continued to hold the post of Senior DPO, Varanasi, pursuant to the interim order passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. The resulting arrangement and the issue concerning the deployment of the two officers at Varanasi were also brought to the notice of the Hon’ble High Court in Writ-A No. 14670 of 2026. The order of this Tribunal dated 23.09.2026 records that the Hon’ble High Court, vide order dated 15.09.2026, directed the applicant therein to file his rejoinder before 23.09.2026 and also directed this Tribunal to decide at least the stay-vacation application, keeping in view the fact that two incumbents were stated to be working against the same post.
Subsequently, Shri Rahul Yadav filed another Original Application, being O.A. No. 1063 of 2026, challenging the original transfer order dated 13.04.2026, whereby he had been transferred from Lucknow to Varanasi, and seeking appropriate relief in respect of his posting at Lucknow. In the meantime, Shri Rajesh Kumar Gupta had already assumed charge as Senior DPO, Lucknow, on 16.04.2026. Shri Rahul Yadav had initially been granted leave from 17.04.2026 to 15.05.2026, which was subsequently modified, and he reported at Lucknow on 04.05.2026. Thereafter, he reported at Varanasi on 19.05.2026, but could not join against the post of Senior DPO, Varanasi, in view of the interim order passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. He was subsequently permitted to join as Senior DPO (Coordination), Varanasi, on 05.06.2026, pursuant to the departmental order dated 04.06.2026. The treatment of the intervening period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence and the consequential denial of salary have also been raised by him in O.A. No. 1063 of 2026. It is clarified that no independent interim protection was granted in O.A. No. 1063 of 2026.
From the pleadings and documents available on record, it is evident that Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh has pleaded that his wife, Dr. Jagriti, is engaged in research work at Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, under the guidance of Prof. Shashi Pandey, and that his daughter is studying at My Nurture School, Varanasi. The documents filed by him also indicate that his wife is pursuing research work at Varanasi and his daughter is studying there. He has further pleaded that he was promoted to JAG Grade and posted as Senior DPO, Varanasi, on 26.08.2025, and that the impugned transfer order dated 13.04.2026 was issued before completion of the minimum tenure of two years at the said place of posting. It is also relevant that the departmental note-sheet records that Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh had been working as DPO I/C and Senior DPO since 03.02.2025. These dates relate to different aspects of his posting and service, and his actual tenure at the relevant post requires due consideration by the competent authority. His personal and family circumstances, therefore, deserve consideration along with the relevant service conditions and administrative requirements.
So far as Shri Rahul Yadav is concerned, he has raised his grievance regarding his posting at Lucknow on spouse grounds, as his wife is a Judicial Officer posted there. He has also questioned his subsequent transfer to North Central Railway, Prayagraj, pursuant to the Railway Board’s order dated 05.06.2026 and the consequential order dated 09.07.2026. In O.A. No. 1063 of 2026, he has further raised his grievance regarding the treatment of the intervening period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 as absence and the consequential non-payment of salary. These aspects require consideration along with his personal circumstances, the available sanctioned posts and vacancies, and the administrative requirements of the department.
It further appears from the pleadings and documents on record that the dispute also involves the deployment and adjustment of officers in JAG Grade in the Personnel Department of North Eastern Railway, particularly in relation to the posts of Senior DPO/Deputy CPO. The departmental note-sheet relating to the transfer/posting proposal refers to the redesignation of the post of Deputy CPO/HQ as Deputy CPO (Gazetted). The availability of sanctioned posts, vacancies and adjustment of officers in the said grade, therefore, also requires examination by the competent authority in the light of the existing administrative requirements.
After hearing the matter at length, learned counsel for the parties jointly submitted that the respondents’ department was in the process of reconsidering the grievances raised by the applicants in these Original Applications.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, and taking note of the submission made by learned counsel for the respondents, I am of the opinion that the matter deserves to be remitted to the competent authority for fresh consideration of the grievances raised by the applicant in these Original Applications. Accordingly, the matter is remitted to the General Manager, North Eastern Railway, in consultation with the Principal Chief Personnel Officer, North Eastern Railway, to reconsider the grievances of both applicants. The competent authority shall examine whether Shri Rahul Yadav, applicant in O.A. Nos. 1063 of 2026 and 728 of 2026, can be accommodated at an appropriate post in North Eastern Railway, keeping in view his personal circumstances, including the grounds raised by him in relation to his spouse, the sanctioned strength, available vacancies, relevant service requirements and administrative exigencies. While undertaking this exercise, the competent authority shall also take into consideration the subsequent administrative arrangements and postings made during the pendency of these proceedings, as reflected in the supplementary affidavit filed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026. The competent authority shall further consider the grievance raised by Shri Rahul Yadav in O.A. No. 1063 of 2026 concerning the period from 01.05.2026 to 18.05.2026 and his consequential claim for salary, in accordance with the applicable rules. It shall also consider the personal and family circumstances pleaded by Shri Abhinav Kumar Singh, applicant in O.A. No. 427 of 2026, his tenure at Varanasi and the relevant departmental records concerning his posting and promotion. The issue relating to the deployment and adjustment of officers against the posts of Senior DPO/Deputy CPO in JAG Grade shall also be examined having regard to the sanctioned strength, available vacancies and administrative requirements.
In case the competent authority finds that Shri Rahul Yadav can be accommodated at an appropriate post in North Eastern Railway, it shall take an appropriate decision in that regard. It is a settled principle of law that transfer is an incidence of service and an employee has no enforceable right to remain posted at a particular place. Transfer may be ordered in the exigencies of service, subject to the applicable rules and guidelines. In such an eventuality, the Railway Board shall also reconsider its order dated 05.06.2026, to the extent necessary, in the light of the decision taken by the competent authority of North Eastern Railway. The General Manager, North Eastern Railway, in consultation with the Principal Chief Personnel Officer, North Eastern Railway, shall take an appropriate decision under intimation to the applicant. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. Till such time, the interim orders dated 23.04.2026 passed in O.A. No. 427 of 2026 and 05.08.2026 passed in O.A. No. 728 of 2026 are extended.
It is made clear that this Tribunal has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the claims raised by the applicants, and the competent authority shall consider the same independently, in accordance with the applicable rules and the observations and directions contained herein.
In view of the aforesaid observations and directions, O.A. No. 427 of 2026, O.A. No. 728 of 2026 and O.A. No. 1063 of 2026, stand disposed of by this common order. There shall be no order as to costs.
All pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
