M/s. Technology Frontiers (India) Pvt. Ltd. Vs Catalyst Trusteeship Ltd.
National Company Law Appellate Tribunal · CHENNAI Bench · 19 Jul 2023 · Rakesh Kumar Jain, Member (Judicial) · Shreesha Merla, Member (Technical)
Judgment
[Per; Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain (MJ)]
This Appeal is directed against the Order dated 18.04.2023, by which right of the Appellant to file its amended Counter before the Tribunal has been closed because the same has not been filed by it despite the time given.
This Appeal is accompanied with an Application bearing I.A. No.679/2023 filed under Section 61(2) proviso for Condonation of Delay of 11 days. Since, the Application for Condonation of Delay is required to be decided first in order to constitute the Appeal, therefore, we have taken up the Application for Condonation of Delay at the first instance and are disposing of the same.
The Impugned Order was passed on 18.04.2023. Period of 30 days for filing such an Appeal in terms of Section 61 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, (for short `The Code’) had expired on 18.05.2023. The Appeal has been filed on 29.05.2023 and in this process period of 11 days beyond the period of 30 days has expired. The reason given in the Application is that the Appellant is a layman and is not acquainted with the procedure in respect of filing of the Appeal.
We have heard the Applicant/Appellant and perused the record of the Application.
Section 61 of the Code deals with the Appeal and the Appellate Tribunal. Section 61 of the Code is being reproduced as hereunder:
“61. Appeals and Appellate Authority. -
(1)Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained under the Companies Act 2013 (18 of 2013), any person aggrieved by the order of the Adjudicating Authority under this part may prefer an appeal to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal.
(2)Every appeal under sub-section (1) shall be filed within thirty days before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal:
Provided that the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal may allow an appeal to be filed after the expiry of the said period of thirty days if it is satisfied that there was sufficient cause for not filing the appeal but such period shall not exceed fifteen days.
(3)An appeal against an order approving a resolution plan under section 31 may be filed on the following grounds, namely: –
(i)the approved resolution plan is in contravention of the provisions of any law for the time being in force;
(ii)there has been material irregularity in exercise of the powers by the resolution professional during the corporate insolvency resolution period;
(iii)the debts owed to operational creditors of the corporate debtor have not been provided for in the resolution plan in the manner specified by the Board;
(iv)the insolvency resolution process costs have not been provided for repayment in priority to all other debts; or
(v)the resolution plan does not comply with any other criteria specified by the Board.
(4)An appeal against a liquidation order passed under section 33, or sub-section (4) of section 54L, or sub-section (4) of section 54N, may be filed on grounds of material irregularity or fraud committed in relation to such a liquidation order.
(5)An appeal against an order for initiation of corporate insolvency resolution process passed under sub-section (2) of section 54-O, may be filed on grounds of material irregularity or fraud committed in relation to such an order.”
Section 61(1) provides a Statutory Right of an Appeal to any person who is aggrieved by the Order of the Tribunal. Section 61(2) prescribes a period of 30 days for filing such an Appeal as provided under Section 61(1). Section 61(2) proviso further provides a period of 15 days both to the Appellant/Applicant and the Appellate Tribunal for the purpose of entertaining the Application for Condonation of Delay in filing the Appeal beyond a period of 30 days, however, the Appellate Tribunal cannot arbitrarily allow the Application for Condonation of Delay as it is required to be satisfied that there was a sufficient cause for the Applicant/Appellant in not filing the Appeal in time prescribed under Section 61(2).
Since, there is no discretion with the Appellate Tribunal and it has only to look into the fact that the reason given by the Appellant/Applicant for not preferring the Appeal within a period of 30 days and seeking extension of period of Limitation within the window of 15 days has a sufficient cause for the same.
In the present case, the Appellant has been remiss in not filing its amended Counter despite the time given to it and has not even filed the Appeal within the prescribed time, therefore, approach of the Applicant/Appellant is totally causal. The reason given for not filing the Appeal in time is lack of knowledge for which it is well settled that ignorance of law is no excuse, therefore, the reason given by the Appellant for not filing the Appeal in time does not come within the definition of a sufficient cause.
Hence, the present Application is found to be devoid of any merit and the same is hereby dismissed. No Costs.
Comp. App. (AT) (CH) (Ins.) No.206/2023:
Since, we have dismissed the Application for Condonation of Delay by a separate Order of the even date, therefore, the present Appeal is not found to be duly constituted and the same is also hereby dismissed. No Costs.
