Results
High Courts(2026) 11 KAR CK 2351

Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Sri. Khanasidd Mayappa Nagarale & Anr.

Karnataka High Court · Dharwad Bench · 12 Nov 2026 · Usharani, J

Open full page

Judgment

50 paragraphs · 1,432 words
1.

MFA No.102404/2026 is filed by the claimant for enhancement of compensation and MFA No.102803/2026 is filed by Insurer for reduction of compensation awarded in the judgment and award dated 07.04.2026 in MVC No.45/2024 by Principal Senior Civil Judge and Member, Additional MACT, Chikodi (for short, ‘Tribunal’).

2.

The claim petition has been filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as ‘MV Act’, for short). There is no dispute with regard to the occurrence of accident and the liability fixed on the insurance company of the truck bearing registration No.KA-01/AJ-7945.

3.

The Tribunal, after considering the evidence of PWs.1 and 2 and Exhibit P1 to 13, assessed disability of the claimant at 9% and awarded compensation as follows by fastening liability on the insurance company of the truck bearing registration No.KA-01/AJ-7945:

Pecuniary damages
HeadsAmount in Rs.
Loss of future earning3,54,705/-
Medical and hospitalization expenses2,83,303/-
(present and future)
Transportation /conveyance, nourishing, food and miscellaneous expenditure30,000/-
Loss of earnings during the period of treatment41,400/-
Non-pecuniary damages
Damages for pain, suffering and trauma as a consequence of the injuries50,000/-
Loss of amenities /marriage prospects20,000/-
Total7,79,408/-
4.

The learned counsel for the claimant contends that, the Tribunal by considering the age of claimant as 27 years, applied multiplier ‘17’ and computed future prospects at 40%, but has not considered the medical documents and the evidence of the doctor who assessed disability at 80%. Further, Tribunal has also erred in fixing the income of the claimant at Rs.13,800/- instead of Rs.15,500/- per month.

5.

The learned counsel for the Insurance Company argued that PW2 is a non-treating doctor and hence, his evidence cannot be considered. Since clavicle bone is an ornamental bone, fracture of the same will not adversely affect his ability to carry out day-to-day work. Further, learned counsel contends that addition of 40% e prospects is improper and Tribunal has rightly held the assessed the disability suffered by the claimant at 9%. Moreover, as the claimant is working, even 9% of disability cannot be considered. In support of his argument, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Anoop Maheshwari Vs. Shiv Kumar Singh and Ors.1

6.

Heard the arguments of learned counsels for the parties and also given anxious consideration to the available documents on record.

7.

At the outset, it is important to refer the judgment in Anoop Maheshwari (supra), wherein claimant was a businessman and income tax payee, who had suffered amputation and a prosthetic leg was fixed. Hence, the Hon'ble Apex Court considered that there is no difficulty in continuing the business. Since claimant had also been fitted with a prosthetic leg, it ensures his mobility and continuance of the business. However, the facts involved in the above case and the case on hand are distinguishable on facts and above judgment is not applicable to the present case for the reason that claimant herein was an agriculturist and as per the wound certificates (Ex. P4) and discharge summary (Ex. P7), he had suffered following grievous injuries/fractures:

i.

Fracture shaft of right femur.

ii.

Fracture both bone of right leg.

iii.

Right clavicle fracture.

iv.

5th MC base fracture right.

v.

CLW sutured wound over right eye.

vi.

Sutured CLW over left thigh 3x3cm.

8.

I do not propose to venture into the various complications that may be faced by a person who suffers fractures, as it depends upon how the fractured bones heal. Sometimes bone can heal in a crooked or shortened position or fail to grow back together completely. Moreover, doctor has explained in his evidence in detail about the difficulties faced by the patient/claimant and has accordingly assessed functional disability. However, learned counsel for the Insurance Company contended that disability certificate (Ex. P8) issued by the doctor - PW2, cannot be relied upon, as he is not the treated doctor and that he is a stock witness. But in the case of Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar and Another2, at paragraph 17 and 19 of the said judgment, it is held that, if a doctor, who has issued disability certificate, gives evidence with regard to the assessment of disability, then the same can be considered.

9.

At this juncture, it is important to verify as to whether percentage of disability assessed by the doctor is a functional disability with reference to the whole body or whether it is only with reference to a limb.

10.

In reference to the argument of the insurance company that clavicle bone is an ornamental bone and its fracture is inconsequential, the following extract is reproduced from National Library of Medicine3 in order to substantiate the significance of the said bone.

“Although small, the clavicle supports optimal upper extremity function and protects the limb by dispersing forces transmitted through direct contact. Clavicular positioning maintains sufficient distance between the upper extremity and thorax, allowing unimpeded shoulder range of motion. Strut-like mechanics allow the scapula to glide smoothly along the posterior thoracic wall, which is critical for full upper extremity motion. The anatomical location also protects the brachial plexus, subclavian artery, and subclavian vein, disruption of which substantially increases morbidity.”

11.

It is relevant to note here that the doctor - PW2 has opined that “the patient has got the total permanent physical disability is at extent of 20% in respect of right upper limb due to fracture right clavicle bone, fracture base of 5th metacarpal bone of the right hand and is 60% In respect of right lower limb fracture, shaft of the right femur bone and fracture of both the (tibia and fibula) bones of right leg…”.

12.

As discussed supra, claimant is an agriculturist, hence, above-mentioned fractures undoubtedly and severely affected his income generating capacity and his ability to carry out agricultural operations. This will certainly have an ever-lasting impact on his work and life. The reason being, farming is a physically demanding occupation, which requires one to rely heavily on mobility, upper body strength and manual dexterity, such fractures will have direct impact on an agricultural worker. Therefore, in order to carry out work which demands considerable physical strength, claimant has to definitely depend upon others.

13.

Considering the above discussed facts, evidence and having regard to Pappu Deo Yadav v. Naresh Kumar and Others4, disability suffered by the claimant is assessed at 25%. The wages of the claimant was fixed by the Tribunal as Rs.13,800/-. Since this accident has occurred on 12.08.2023, as per Notional Income Chart issued by Karnataka State Legal Services Authority, his income is fixed at Rs.15,500/-, to which 40% future prospects is added. Further, as rightly contended by learned counsel for the claimant, while awarding compensation under the head of ‘pain and suffering’, number of fractures suffered by the claimant were not considered by the Tribunal. Therefore, claimant is entitled for modified compensation as under:

Pecuniary damages
HeadsAmount in Rs.
Loss of future earning [Rs.15,500/- + 40% (future prospects)= Rs.21,700/- x 12 x 25% x 17]11,06,700/-
Medical and hospitalization expenses (present and future)2,83,303/-
Pain and suffering95,000/-
Loss of earning during laid up period (Rs.15,500/- x 3 months)46,500/-
Conveyance, food, nourishment & attendant charges30,000/-
Loss of amenities75,000/-
Total16,36,503/-
14.

One more contention raised by the learned counsel for the claimant is that interest at the rate of 9% ought to be fixed. Hence, considering the principles laid down in the cases of Puttama and Others Vs. K.L. Narayana Reddy and Another5 and United India Insurance Company Limited Vs. Sri Malyadri M6, the interest is fixed at the rate of 9% per annum.

15.

For the aforesaid reasons, I proceed to pass the following:

ORDER

a. MFA No.102803/2026 filed by the Insurance Company is dismissed.

b. MFA No.102404/2026 filed by the claimant is partly allowed.

c. The judgment and award dated 07.04.2026 in MVC No.45/2024 passed by Principal Senior Civil Judge and Member Additional MACT, Chikodi, is modified with regard to the compensation awarded.

d. The claimant is entitled to a total compensation of 16,36,503/- with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of petition till realization.

e. The Insurance Company herein shall deposit the compensation, together with accrued interest, before the Tribunal within a period of eight weeks, from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment.

f. The Registry shall transmit amount in deposit, if any, and the Trial Court records to the Tribunal forthwith.

Footnotes

  1. 1.AIR 2025 SC 4099
  2. 2.(2011) 1 SCC 343.
  3. 3.James La Rose, Matthew Charlick; Matthew A. Varacallo, Anatomy, Shoulder and Upper Limb, Clavicle, National Library of Medicine, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK525990/
  4. 4.(2020) 7 SCR 968
  5. 5.(2013) 15 SCC 45
  6. 6.MFA 3895/2018 (Bengaluru bench)