Nirmala Suresh Baikar Vs The State Of Maharashtra
Bombay High Court · 27 Oct 2026 · Sarang V. Kotwal, J · Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, J
Judgment
[PER SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.]
1. The Appellant has challenged the judgment and order dated 16.10.2019 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Raigad at Alibag in Sessions Case No.27/2016. There were two accused in the said case. The original accused No.2 was the Appellant’s son. He was acquitted of all the charges. However, the Appellant was convicted for commission of the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and was sentenced to suffer life imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- and in default of payment of fine to suffer S.I. for three months. The Appellant was given set off under Section 428 of Cr.P.C.
2. Heard Mr. Pawan Mali, the learned counsel for the Appellant and Ms. Supriya Kak, the learned APP for the Respondent-State.
3. The prosecution case, in brief, is that the deceased Priyanka was married to the Appellant’s son (original accused No.2). It was a love marriage. The Appellant was opposed to that marriage. Initially the couple resided elsewhere; but a few days prior to the incident dated 5.12.2015, the deceased and the accused No.2 came to reside near the house of the Appellant. On 5.12.2015, at around 2.00 p.m., the accused No.2 had gone out. It is the prosecution case that the Appellant entered the room of the deceased, poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. The husband of the deceased Priyanka came after 10 to 15 minutes and he doused the fire. He took her to the nearest police station and from there she was taken to the hospital. Police Naik Juili Mhatre recorded her statement and treated it as an FIR. It was lodged at around 5.25 p.m.. A Special Executive Magistrate [SEM] also recorded her statement. Thus, there were two written dying declarations wherein she had narrated the same story alleging that the Appellant had set her on fire. She was shifted to KEM hospital, Mumbai and she died on 12.12.2015. She had suffered 80% burn injuries. It is the prosecution case that one day before her death she expressed her desire to give more details about the incident to her mother, sister and brother. Her brother videographed her statement. On this occasion, Priyanka changed her story and stated that the accused No.2 together with the present Appellant had poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. They left the place by bolting the door from outside. After some time, the accused No.2 came back and took her to the hospital. This was a completely different story. During investigation, the spot panchnama was conducted. After Priyanka’s death the postmortem was conducted. The clothes of the deceased and the Appellant were seized. The articles were sent for chemical analysis. At the conclusion of the investigation, the charge-sheet was filed. The case was committed to the Court of Session.
4. During trial, the prosecution examined seventeen witnesses, including the police officers and the SEM who had recorded the dying declarations, mother, brother and sister of the deceased, the panchas, the medical officers and the investigating officer. The learned Judge disbelieved the evidence of the videographed dying declaration made to the mother, brother and sister of the deceased. On that reasoning, he acquitted the accused No.2. The defence of the Appellant was that of total denial. She did not take any specific defence. However, the learned Judge believed the two dying declarations recorded by the police and the SEM; and on that basis convicted and sentenced the Appellant.
5. The FIR was lodged by PW-1 Juili Mhatre, who had recorded the first dying declaration. She deposed that she was attached to Wadkhal police station. On 5.12.2015, she was on duty as police station officer in charge. At about 2.30 p.m., a lady having suffered burns came to the police station with her husband. PW-1 and other officers took her to the Rural Hospital, Pen for treatment. PW-1 got her admitted. PW-1 took endorsement from the doctor regarding her fitness to give statement. She called two members of Mahila Suraksha Samiti. They were Vaishali Mhatre and Kalyani Patil. The Dy.S.P was also present. Priyanka’s statement was recorded. PW-1 herself recorded the statement. The statement is produced on record at Exhibit-22. It had the signature of the Dy.S.P and the signatures of the two aforementioned members of Mahila Suraksha Samiti. It also had the thumb impression of Priyanka as well as the endorsement of the doctor. Priyanka told her that the marriage was a love marriage. Her mother-in-law i.e. the present Appellant did not approve of that marriage. She came to reside near the Appellant’s house about twenty days prior to the incident. The Appellant used to abuse her. The Appellant told Priyanka that she would kill her one day. On 5.12.2015, at around 2.00 p.m., Priyanka’s husband had gone out. She was alone in the house. The Appellant poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. PW-1 recorded the statement and brought it to the police station. She registered C.R. No.60/2015 at Wadkhal police station under Sections 307, 498-A read with 34 of IPC. The FIR proforma is produced on record at Exhibit-23. PW-1 identified the clothes of the deceased.
In the cross-examination, she stated that Priyanka came to the police station with her husband at 2.30 p.m. to 2.45 p.m.. The said fact was not entered in the station diary. PW-1 herself was in-charge of the said station diary on that day. She did not make station diary entry when she left the police station to go to the hospital. PW-1 was unable to tell the name of the doctor who had put his endorsement on the dying declaration. It took 15 minutes to record her dying declaration. PW-1 obtained the signatures. It was around 3.30 p.m.. She came to the police station at about 4.30 p.m.. She deposed that Priyanka was residing in a separate room which was adjoining to the Appellant’s house. PW-1 herself did not visit the spot of incident and she did not arrest the Appellant. She stated that when Priyanka came to the police station she was in a critical condition.
6. The dying declaration at Exhibit-22 bears the endorsement of the doctor as – “patient conscious. Can give its verbal statement”. The dying declaration gives many details. It gives the details of her address. It also gives the details about the age of her husband and details about her son Preet. The dying declaration mentions the full name of the Appellant. It is further mentioned in the dying declaration at Exhibit-22 that the Appellant was opposed to Priyanka’s marriage with the Appellant’s son; but inspite of that they got married three years ago. After the marriage, they were residing in separate room. They were blessed with a son. About one month prior to the incident, her husband constructed a room at Dharamtar. The Appellant used to abuse Priyanka and used to threaten her that she would kill Priyanka. On 5.12.2015, since morning the Appellant was abusing her. After lunch, her husband left the house to go to the creek. She herself and her son Preet were in the house. At about 2.00 p.m., the Appellant came to her room. She had brought a kerosene can. She poured kerosene on Priyanka and set her ablaze with a match-stick and she left the house. At that time nobody was in the vicinity. Nobody came to douse her fire. About after 15 to 20 minutes her husband Dinesh came back. He poured water from a water-tank. He put a bed-sheet on her. He then took her to Wadhkal police station. The police then took her to the Government Hospital at Pen. She further stated that she was fully conscious. After narrating this, the dying declaration records the gist of the entire incident and significantly the concluding paragraph mentions that her statement was recorded in the presence of two members of Mahila Suraksha Samiti Vaishali Mhatre and Kalyani Patil.
7. PW-14 Kiran Patil was the Special Executive Magistrate. He visited the Rural Hospital, Pen as per the directions given by the Tahsildar for recording Priyanka’s statement. He deposed that he met Dr. Tandale who took him to Priyanka. PW-14 asked Dr.Tandale to examine Priyanka as to whether she was ready to give statement or not. He further stated that Dr. Tandale examined the said lady and asked certain questions to her and thereafter informed PW-14 that she was in a position to give statement. At that time, the said Medical Officer and Priyanka were the only persons present in the room. After that, PW-14 asked her about the incident. He recorded the statement as stated by Priyanka. She informed him that she was married about three years prior to the incident. She was residing separately from her in-laws. Her mother-in-law i.e. the Appellant used to abuse her and threaten to kill her. Her husband had gone out for work. At about 2.00 p.m., the Appellant came there. She had brought kerosene. The Appellant poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. Priyanka shouted for help and after 10 to 15 minutes, her husband came back. He extinguished the fire by pouring water and he took her to the police station on the motorcycle. This was the statement given by her. The statement is produced on record at Exhibit-57. It bears the endorsement of Dr.Tandale in the margin as “patient can give its verbal statement”
In the cross-examination, he accepted that he did not record the questions asked by the Medical Officer to Priyanka. He did not record the questions put by him to Priyanka. He did not record the exact timing of starting and ending of recording of the said statement. The endorsement of the Medical Officer did not mention the timing and date. The averments in the dying declaration at Exhibit-57 are similar to the description given by PW-14. She added that when she was set ablaze, she started shouting but nobody came to help her. After 15 to 20 minutes, her husband came back. He poured water on her and then took her to Wadkhal police station.
8. In that context, the evidence of PW-4 Indubai Baikar is important. She was a neighbour. She deposed that her house was adjacent to the house of the accused. The accused No.2 and the deceased were staying together. The Appellant was residing in a room adjacent to the house of the deceased. The incident occurred in the afternoon of 5.12.2015. PW-4 heard the shouts. She saw that Priyanka’s clothes had caught fire. PW-4 wrapped Priyanka with a cloth. She specifically told that the accused No.2 i.e. Priyanka’s husband was present with Priyanka. She did not know as to how Priyanka had sustained burn injuries as she was inside the house. After that the accused No.2 took Priyanka to the hospital on a vehicle.
In the cross-examination, the portion marked ‘A’ from her statement was put to her. She accepted that it was stated by her. In that portion mark which is exhibited at Exhibit-83 it was mentioned that at 2.00 p.m. on 5.12.2015, the accused No.2 Dinesh brought Priyanka outside their house. She had suffered burn injuries. PW-14 went there and put a blanket on Priyanka. There is no mention of presence of the Appellant.
9. PW-3 Anusaya Patil was the mother of the deceased, PW-6 Jayesh Patil was the brother of the deceased, PW-11 Ranjana Patil was the sister of the deceased and PW-12 Harshad Patil was a cousin of the deceased. All of them have stated about the oral dying declaration made to them by the deceased blaming only the Appellant. All of them, in short, deposed about a video recording of the dying declaration of the deceased wherein she had narrated a different story ascribing roles to the Appellant as well as to the accused No.2. To that extent, their evidence is similar.
10. PW-3 Anusaya Patil, the mother of the deceased, deposed that on 5.12.2015, she received a telephonic message from her son that the Appellant had set Priyanka on fire. On 5.12.2015, PW-3 & PW-6 hired a vehicle and went to Pen. They came to know that Priyanka was shifted to KEM Hospital,Mumbai. They went there. That time Priyanka was unable to speak with PW-3. Treatment was going on. Priyanka was shifted to the ICU. She further deposed that Priyanka was in a fit state of mind and was fully conscious. PW-3 enquired with Priyanka, who stated that she was set on fire by the Appellant. The Appellant had poured kerosene on her and then had lit a matchstick and had thrown it on Priyanka. Priyanka further told PW-3 that the Appellant bolted the door from outside. After sometime, the accused No.2 came there. He opened the door, extinguished the fire by pouring water and brought her to the police station at Wadkhal. She was taken to the hospital at Pen. On 11.12.2015, Priyanka told her that she had realized that she was about to die. She narrated another story. She told that the accused No.2 i.e. the Appellant’s son had beaten her. The accused No.2 poured kerosene on her person. When she narrated this, PW-3’s son Jayesh (PW-6) and her nephew Harshad (PW-12) were present. They videographed that statement. Priyanka died on 12.12.2015.
In the cross-examination, she deposed that during Priyanka’s admission to KEM Hospital, the accused No.2 was taking care of Priyanka. He used to bring medicines. He did not leave Priyanka alone. The police had recorded two to three statements of Priyanka. She further stated that when she saw Priyanka, she found her in critical and serious condition. At that time, medical treatment was going on.
11. The evidence of PW-6 Jayesh Patil is on the same lines. He also deposed about Priyanka narrating him the first story wherein she had ascribed a role only to the Appellant. He then deposed about the videographed dying declaration. At that time, Priyanka told them that both the accused had poured kerosene and set her on fire. He produced the certificate issued by him which was treated as a certificate under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act. It is marked at Exhibit-33. The video recording was made on his mobile phone. He identified the video clips.
In the cross-examination, he admitted that on 11.12.2015 he did not disclose to any police officer that he had recorded the conversation of the deceased in his mobile phone. He had stayed in KEM Hospital for seven days. During that period, the Medical Officers used to visit and examine Priyanka. At the time of the video recording, the medical officers and nurses were present nearby. He corrected himself and added that at that time the Medical Officers and the nurses were not present. He showed the video clips to the police on 13.12.2015. He had accompanied Priyanka from Alibag Hospital to KEM Hospital, Mumbai. From the date of the incident, Priyanka’s son was with PW-6. He added that he did not show the video clips recorded by him for three days after its recording to anybody.
12. PW-11 Ranjana Patil was the sister of Priyanka. Her evidence is almost similar and her cross-examination was on the same lines. She also deposed about the oral dying declaration ascribing a role only to the Appellant and then deposed about the dying declaration wherein Priyanka had ascribed a role each to the accused No.2 and the Appellant. She admitted that since 6.12.2015, till Priyanka’s death, the family members accompanied Priyanka. The Police Officer Shri Borate attached to Wadkhal police station was regularly visiting KEM Hospital from 6.12.2015 to 11.12.2015 but she did not inform him about the statement given by Priyanka to them. They did not inform the police about the video clip recording of Priyanka’s statement.
13. PW-12 Harshad Patil was Priyanka’s cousin. His evidence is also similar. However, there is one material statement made by him. According to him, in her videographed statement, Priyanka told them that the accused No.2 had poured diesel on her and set her on fire. Her husband had told her to blame the Appellant and threatened her that if she named him then he would kill their son Preet. This witness admitted that all the time the doctors, nurses and ward boys were available in that Ward and generally the outsiders were not allowed to enter the ICU. He also admitted that Priyanka’s condition was critical and she was continuously under medication. At the relevant time, he did not inform the police about the video clip.
14. PW-13 Darshana Patil was another sister of the deceased. She deposed about the oral dying declaration ascribing a role only to the Appellant. She did not speak about the videographed dying declaration.
15. PW-7 Manoj Patil was a pancha in whose presence the S.D. card from the mobile phone of PW-6 was given to the police. The panchnama is produced on record at Exhibit-37. The panchnama was conducted on 16.12.2015.
16. PW-2 Vilas Rathod was a pancha for the spot panchnama which is produced on record at Exhibit-26. The panchnama mentions seizure of kerosene can containing half liter kerosene, matchbox, half burnt blanket etc.. There was water all around inside the room.
17. PW-8 Chandrakant Patil was a Circle Officer who had prepared a map of the spot of incident. In the cross-examination, he stated that the spot was surrounded by other houses. The map shows at least three houses adjacent to the spot of incident.
18. PW-9 Avinash Rane was a pancha, in whose presence clothes of the accused No.2 and his phone were seized. PW-10 Umesh Panchal was a pancha in whose presence clothes of the Appellant and clothes of the deceased were seized under panchnama at Exhibits-45 & 49 respectively.
19. PW-15 Dr.Manoj Parchake had conducted the postmortem examination. According to him, the deceased had suffered 80% burn injuries. The postmortem notes are produced on record at Exhibit-60. The cause of death was mentioned as ‘septicemia due to burns (unnatural)’. The deceased had died on 12.12.2015.
20. PW-16 Dr. Anant Tandale is an important witness. His endorsement appears on both the written dying declarations at Exhibits-22 & 57. He deposed that on 5.12.2015, he was attached to Sub-District Hospital at Pen as Medical Officer. Priyanka was brought to that hospital. Her statement was recorded by the police officer in the hospital. At that time, he had examined her and put his endorsement about the physical condition. According to him, at that time, the patient was conscious and she was able to give her statement. He identified his endorsement on Exhibit-22. He further deposed that on the same day, the Special Executive Magistrate, Pen visited the hospital and recorded the statement of Priyanka in his presence. At that time also, he examined Priyanka and opined that the patient could give her verbal statement. Accordingly, he put his endorsement about the fitness of Priyanka in the margin of the statement. He thereafter put his endorsement at Exhibit-57. He had issued a medical certificate showing that Priyanka had suffered 59% burn injuries. According to him, at the time of recording Priyanka’s statement he found her physically and mentally fit; and accordingly he had given opinion in the form of endorsement.
In the cross-examination, he deposed that after Priyanka’s admission, her statement was recorded by the police within 15 to 20 minutes. He admitted that he had not mentioned the timing of the endorsement given by him on that statement. He also admitted he had not mentioned the timing of his endorsement on Exhibit-57.
21. PW-17 PI Borate was the investigating officer. He deposed about the investigation carried out by him. He had requested the SEM (PW-14) to record Priyanka’s statement. He got the spot panchnama prepared. He arrested the accused under the arrest panchnama. During investigation, Priyanka’s relatives produced the video clip of her statement. The memory card was seized. Since the name of the accused No.2 was disclosed in that statement, he was also arrested. The articles were sent for chemical analysis. After conclusion of investigation, he filed the charge-sheet against the accused.
22. Besides this oral evidence, the prosecution produced the CA certificate on record at Exhibit-80. Importantly, the test for presence of kerosene on the clothes of the Appellant was negative; that means the clothes of the Appellant did not have traces of kerosene. . This, in short, was the evidence led by the prosecution.
23. The learned counsel for the Appellant made the following submissions :
The prosecution has not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. The case is based on circumstantial evidence. It rests purely on different dying declarations which were contrary to each other. None of the dying declarations was truthful and reliable. Therefore, benefit of doubt must be given to the Appellant.
He submitted that the endorsement on Exhibits-22 & 57 fell short of the requirement to prove that the deceased was in a fit state of mind to give her statement.
PW-4 Indubai Baikar’s evidence falsifies both written dying declarations.
The oral dying declarations made to Priyanka’s relatives and the videographed dying declaration were disbelieved by the learned Judge. There was no appeal against that finding.
PW-1 Juili Mhatre did not make any station diary entry before leaving the police station for recording the dying declaration.
The two social workers and Dy.S.P. who put their signatures on the dying declaration at Exhibit-22 were not examined.
There is contrary evidence about the presence or absence of Priyanka’s son Preet. At some places in the dying declaration it is mentioned that Preet was present in the house but afterwards there is no explanation as to what happened to Preet. There is total silence. The manner in which the incident is described shows that no incident could have taken place at all involving the Appellant.
24. The learned APP, on the other hand, heavily relied on the written dying declaration recorded by PW-14 SEM Kiran Patil. The learned APP submitted that the dying declaration had the endorsement of PW-16 Dr. Tandale and, therefore, there is no reason to disbelieve that particular dying declaration at least.
25. The learned APP also relied on the written dying declaration at Exhibit-22 but she laid emphasis on the dying declaration recorded by PW-14 SEM Kiran Patil. She submitted that both these dying declarations are corroborated by oral dying declarations given by Priyanka to her mother, sister and brother. All of them to that extent corroborate each other and, therefore, the learned Judge has rightly recorded his finding of conviction and has properly sentenced the Appellant.
26. We have considered these submissions. As far as the videographed dying declaration is concerned, the learned Judge himself has rightly disbelieved that particular evidence. In paragraph-24 of the impugned judgment, he had given following reasons for discarding that particular dying declaration as follows:
i.It was recorded at such a time when the deceased was critical and breathing her last and there is no certification of mental and physical fitness.
ii.It is inconsistent with previous dying declaration as regards nature of fuel.
iii.It is before only family members and no independent witness, medical authority and hence there is more possibility of it being tutored one.
iv.There was considerable delay in handing over said videographed declaration to the police
27. We fully agree with the reasons given by the learned Judge in discarding the videographed dying declaration. It is important to note that the oral dying declarations were made to the same witnesses who were the near relatives of Priyanka and who were always with her from 6.12.2015 till she died on 12.12.2015. Thus, the possibility of tutoring cannot be ruled out. Their evidence on major portion of videographed dying declaration is disbelieved and, therefore, it would not be safe to rely on their evidence as far as the oral dying declarations are concerned.
28. The next incriminating piece of evidence which requires serious consideration is Exhibit-22 which is the dying declaration recorded by PW-1 Police Naik Juili Mhatre. As discussed earlier, the said dying declaration is a very detailed dying declaration giving many details. It gives the details of the full names of the deceased, the Appellant, full address, their age etc.. The concluding paragraph mentions that Priyanka herself has stated that her statement was recorded in the presence of Vaishali Mhatre and Kalyani Patil. She had no reason to know either of these committee members and yet, her dying declaration specifically mentions their names and records the fact that the dying declaration was recorded in their presence. Quite clearly, hence, the dying declaration is not in her exact words.
29. The second last paragraph of the dying declaration gives the gist of her entire narration. Considering her critical condition, this repetition would not have been made by her. There is sufficient force in the submissions of the learned counsel for the Appellant that the said dying declaration is not in the words of the deceased but it is a statement written as per the convenience of the police officer. In this view of the matter, we are not inclined to rely on this particular dying declaration as well.
30. This leaves the only serious evidence against the Appellant in the form of the dying declaration at Exhibit-57 recorded by PW-14 SEM Kiran Patil. In this connection, the evidence of the doctor giving endorsement i.e. PW-16 Dr. Anant Tandale is important. His evidence on the dying declaration is very cryptic, which mentions that ‘patient can give its verbal statement’. It does not speak about the physical fitness or mental fitness or consciousness of the patient. The endorsement also does not indicate at what time exactly the endorsement was given – whether it was given prior to recording of the statement or after recording of the statement. The satisfaction that the patient was in a position to give statement being fully aware of what she was saying; is an important aspect of her dying declaration. PW-14 SEM Kiran Patil also has not recorded his own satisfaction that the patient was in a fit mental state to give her dying declaration. He has entirely relied on the opinion of Dr. Tandale. PW-14 stated that Dr. Tandale examined the patient and asked certain questions to her and thereafter informed him that she was in a position to give the statement. However, Dr. Tandale himself does not refer to any such questions having put to her. He merely stated that after the police recorded Priyanka’s statement, the SEM Kiran Patil visited the hospital and recorded Priyanka’s statement in his presence. At that time, he examined Priyanka and opined that the ‘patient can give her verbal statement.’ This endorsement and his evidence is not sufficient to prove that she was in a mentally fit condition to give her statement. Therefore, it is difficult to rely on the dying declaration at Exhibit-57 as well.
31. Even otherwise, the story narrated in that dying declaration is not believable. According to the contents of that dying declaration, the Appellant came to Priyanka’s room. She poured kerosene on her and then lit a match-stick and threw it on her. Priyanka caught fire. She shouted for help but nobody came to help her. After about 15-20 minutes, the accused No.2 came home and then poured water on her to extinguish the fire. She was then taken to Wadkhal police station. There is absolutely no mention of any struggle or resistance offered by Priyanka. This itself is unbelievable.
32. According to this dying declaration, the Appellant single handedly committed this offence. It is difficult to believe that Priyanka would not have resisted or struggled during this incident. There was no reference that door of the room was bolted from outside by the Appellant. The time gap of about 15-20 minutes is also long in the context of the case. It is not possible to believe that she kept burning in the same state and she just sat there for about 15-20 minutes till the accused No.2 doused the fire. The water tank was very much available and yet Priyanka did not try to extinguish the fire. This aspect is also unbelievable.
33. The narration in this dying declaration is further falsified by the evidence of PW-4 Indubai Baikar. She was an independent witness. She had no reason to give false evidence. She had stated that at the relevant time, she heard shouts. She came out. She saw that Priyanka’s clothes had caught fire. She wrapped a cloth around her. At that time, only the accused No.2 was present near Priyanka. The map shows that there were other houses surrounding the spot and yet, there was no other neighbour who had seen the Appellant anywhere near the spot. The narration in Exhibit-57 is not consistent with the evidence of PW-4, who was an independent witness.
34. Apart from these factors, there is one positive factor in favour of the Appellant. The chemical analysis report shows that no traces of kerosene were found on the clothes of the Appellant. This is a very strong circumstance in her favour. If the incident as described in the dying declarations was true, then it was expected that the clothes of the Appellant would show traces of kerosene. In this case, there were no such traces at all. This is a positive circumstance in favour of the Appellant.
35. Considering all these aspects, we are satisfied that the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt against the Appellant and, therefore, the Appellant deserves to be acquitted. Hence, the following order :
:: O R D E R ::
The Appeal is allowed.
The judgment and order dated 16.10.2019 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Raigad at Alibag in Sessions Case No.27/2016 convicting and sentencing the Appellant, is set aside. The Appellant is acquitted from all the charges.
The Appellant shall be released forthwith if not required in any other case.
Before being released, the Appellant shall execute a P.R. bond in the sum of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand Only) under Section 481 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for her appearance in case an Appeal against acquittal is preferred.
The Appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Connected Interim Application is also disposed of.
