Yadav Pandurang Kumre Vs Vidhya Bhushan Bhoyar & Anr.
Bombay High Court · Nagpur Bench · 28 Oct 2026 · Pravin S. Patil, J
Judgment
In the present appeal, the challenge is to the judgment and award passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagpur in Claim Petition No.934/2018, decided on 20.12.2019.
The grievance raised by the present appellant before this court is that without effecting proper service on the appellant, the Claim Tribunal has proceeded to decide the matter under the presumption that notice is served and thereby decided the Claim Petition against the present appellant.
The appellant, to substantiate submission that notice was not duly served, has firstly relied upon the bailiff report dated 12.12.2018 which is filed along with paper book wherein the bailiff has specifically reported to the court that when he approached to the address of the appellant along with notice, he found that the appellant was not residing on the given address. He has made enquiry about his address, but no one has given him information about his address and, therefore, he could not serve the notice on the appellant and sent back the notice to the court.
The appellant further pointed out that though the respondent-claimant has claimed that the notice was served by way of private mode of service, relied upon the track report of the postal department. According to the appellant, as the address of the appellant was at Mouda, the track report clearly states that on 18.04.2019 and 24.04.2019 the attempt was made by the postal department, but the same was not delivered due to insufficient address. Therefore, according to the appellant, this document is not helpful to the respondent-claimant.
In addition to this, the appellant further pointed out that the respondent-claimant being aware that address given in the application was not correct, while filing the execution proceeding before the Claim Tribunal, has given his correct address and on that address, the notice was duly served to the appellant.
In view of this submission, the appellant states that the impugned judgment which is passed by the learned Tribunal without granting any hearing opportunity to the appellant, needs reconsideration by this court and for that purpose the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set aside and the matter needs to be remitted back to the Tribunal for fresh consideration.
The respondent-claimant states that the respondent was aware about the pendency of the proceeding before the Claim Tribunal. He is in a police department and, therefore, he was aware that the Claim Petition is filed by the claimant before the Claim Tribunal. It is their further submission that by private mode the service was effected on the appellant. The respondent has relied upon the track report of the postal department wherein it is recorded on 24.04.2019 the item delivered. Hence, according to the respondent-claimant this was a service effected against the appellant in the matter and, therefore, the appellant did not approach with clean hands before this court.
After considering the submission of both the parties, it is clear that as per the bailiff report, the notice was not served on the given address to the appellant. In respect of track report of postal department, from entry dated 24.02.2019 it is clear that the notice was not delivered to the appellant due to insufficient address. Then the item was received back by Nagpur General Post Office on 24.04.2019 at around 7.37 hours. Then it was out of delivery at around 10.42 hours and further on the same day, it is recorded that at around 16.30 hours, item was delivered. From this track report, it is not clear that item was delivered at the given address at Mouda or not. So also it is unbelieveable that on same day, when item was received to the Nagpur GPO, within a day, the service was effected on the appellant at Mouda. This fact is also not proved by the respondent-claimant by adducing any evidence of authorized person of the postal department.
In the light of above factual position, it is clear from record that appellant could not get the opportunity of hearing while the learned Claim Tribunal has decided the Claim Petition on merits and awarded the compensation against the present appellant.
It is also to be noted that the present respondent-claimants are prosecuting their cause since year 2018 and, therefore, the claimants interest is also required to be considered by this court.
In the present matter, considering the controversy involved, it would be just and proper to pass the following order :
O R D E R
The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and order passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagpur dated 20.12.2019 in Claim Petition No.934/2018 is hereby quashed and set aside.
Claim Petition No.934/2018 shall restored to the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagpur.
The parties are directed to appear before the Claim Tribunal on 19.11.2026.
The Claim Tribunal is directed to decide the Claim Petition afresh, as expeditiously as possible and in any case on or before March-2027.
The amount which is deposited by the appellant shall be transferred to the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagpur and same shall be released subject to final decision of the Claim Petition in favour of the person as per their entitlement.
The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.
