Results
High Courts(2026) 10 BOM CK 5935

Mr. Chetan Laxman Chavan Vs The State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Bombay High Court · 30 Oct 2026 · Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, J · Sarang V. Kotwal, J

Open full page

Judgment

34 paragraphs · 3,067 words

(PER RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, J) :-

1)

By the present petition, the Petitioner seeks to quash and set aside the impugned Detention Order dated 7th January 2026, passed by the Respondent No. 2, i.e. Commissioner of Police, Pune as also the committal Order of the even date, whereby the Petitioner was detained in the Buldhana District Prison, Buldhana.

2)

Heard Mr. Ramji Kotali, learned counsel for the Petitioner, and Mr. S. V. Gavand, learned APP for the Respondent-State.

3)

Mr. Ramji Kotal, learned Advocate appearing for the Petitioner, on instructions submitted that, though the Petitioner has raised various grounds in the petition, he is restricting his arguments to only one ground i.e., in the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority has relied upon past offences and preventive actions to conclude that the Petitioner is a dangerous person under section 2(b-1) of the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities Act (MPDA Act) and at the same time stated that he is relying only on certain offences mentioned in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the Grounds of Detention, to arrive at the required subjective satisfaction to conclude that the Petitioner is a dangerous person under the MPDA Act. That, has created confusion in the mind of the Petitioner and thereby adversely affected the Petitioner’s right to make an effective representation.

4)

Per contra, Mr. S. V. Gavand, learned APP, supported the Order of Detention and submitted that, the Detaining Authority has only relied upon the grounds mentioned in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the Grounds of Detention. That, the reference in the Detention Order , to the past offences and preventive actions taken in the past is only to put in perspective the history of the Petitioner and the Petitioner’s propensity towards crime and criminal activities. Mr Gavand, would submit that, perusal of the Grounds of Detention makes it clear that, the subjective satisfaction of the Detaining Authority is based only on the C.R. mentioned in paragraph 5, i.e. C.R. No. 130 of 2025, and the two in-camera statements of witnesses A and B.

5)

We have considered the submissions of the respective advocates appearing for the parties. We have perused the entire record and particularly the Grounds of Detention. In paragraph 2 of the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority has specifically referred to the Petitioner as a weapon-wielding dangerous recidivist of violent nature, indulging in criminal activities that foster terror in society. It is specifically recorded that, the Petitioner has become a perpetual danger to the lives and properties of the people residing in and around the jurisdiction of Bundgarden and Uttamnagar Police Stations, in Pune. It is recorded that, the Petitioner along with his accomplices, moved around the area with deadly weapons such as firearms, swords, koytas and knives and does not hesitate to use the same while committing offences such as attempt to murder, causing hurt, rioting, etc. The Detaining Authority, further proceeds to record that, the Petitioner has made himself a virtual terror on account of the criminal activities mentioned in paragraph 3 and habitually commits offences under Chapters XVI and XVII of the Indian Penal Code, as well as Chapters VI and XVII of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and Chapter V of the Arms Act. Therefore, the Detaining Authority has termed the Petitioner as a “Dangerous Person” as defined under Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act.

6)

We have noted that, in paragraph 2 of the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority has specifically mentioned that the Petitioner was a weapon-wielding, dangerous recidivist of violent nature, indulging in criminal activities that foster terror in society. It has been specifically stated that the Petitioner moves around with deadly weapons and, on account of his criminal activities, has created virtual terror in the said area. The Detaining Authority, after narrating the aforesaid facts has in paragraph 2, specifically concluded that:

“2.

..Thus, you have made yourself a virtual terror on account of your below mentioned criminal activities. You have been habitually committing offences under chapters XVI and XVII of the Indian Penal Code, under chapters VI and XVII of Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita well as under Chapter V of the Arms Act and you are thus a “Dangerous Person” as defined under Section 2(b-1) of the said Act. Further, your criminal activities are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order.”

7)

Paragraph 3 of the Grounds of Detention lists the past offences and preventive actions taken against the Petitioner. There are five past offences against the Petitioner registered with Uttamnagar Police Station and Bundgarden Police Station. The offences are during the period from April 2019 to October 2023. The record indicates that, the Petitioner had been arrested in all of the offences. Perusal of the tabulated chart reproduced in paragraph 3.1 would indicate that, the offences pertain to Sections 326, 427, 506 and 34 of the IPC, read with Section 4(25) of the Arms Act, and under Sections 37(1)(3)/135 of the Maharashtra Police Act, read with Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act.

8)

We have noted that, the Grounds of Detention proceed to reproduce the preventive actions taken against the Petitioner in paragraph 3.2. There are seven preventive actions taken against the Petitioner. It is specifically recorded that, in spite of the preventive actions being taken i.e the Petitioner being externed from the jurisdiction of the Pune City and Pimpri Chinchwad Police Commissionerates for a period of two years; being detained in the Nagpur Central Prison, etc the same have had no deterrent effect on the Petitioner. The said conduct of the Petitioner adversely affected the maintenance of public order in the jurisdiction of Bundgarden and Uttamnagar Police Stations, Pune.

9)

After referring to paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Grounds of Detention, in paragraph 4, the Detaining Authority has once again stated that, the involvement of the Petitioner is noticed in offences which are of a serious nature and which are suggestive of the Petitioner's violent tendencies and inclination to perpetuate criminal activities as a “Dangerous Person” as defined under Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act.

10)

In paragraph 5, the Detaining Authority refers to C.R. No. 130 of 2025, registered with the Uttamnagar Police Station on 22nd October 2025 under Sections 115(2), 352 and 3(5) of the BNS, Section 4(25) of the Arms Act, Section 37(1)/135 of the Maharashtra Police Act and Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act. Perusal of the said C.R. would indicate that, the incident pertains to 22nd October 2025. It is stated that, the complainant and his friend were walking to offer prayers at a nearby Masjid at Kondhave Dhawade, Pune. When they were on the public road in front of Bismilla Biryani House, Kondhave-Dhawade, Pune, the Petitioner and Mr. Waghmare, who were known to the complainant, came on a motorcycle. Waghmare asked the complainant's friend, Rehan Qasim Ansari, as to where he would get good biryani. At that time, Waghmare started arguing with the complainant, after which he threatened and abused the complainant. At that time, the Petitioner removed a sharp weapon from his waist, waved it in the air and created terror. Looking at the acts of the Petitioner, the shopkeepers closed their shops and went home. This is one CR which has been relied upon by the Detaining Authority.

11)

Further, in paragraph 6 of the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority has referred to and relied upon two in-camera statements, i.e. of witnesses A and B, which are referred to in paragraphs 6.1 and 6.2 of the Grounds of Detention. As regards the statement of witness A, it pertains to the incident of 17th October 2025. The statement of witness A was recorded on 30th October 2025. The said witness has stated that, after having dinner, he was going to his friend's paan stall near Shinde Pool, where he saw a crowd of children at the paan stall. He saw shopkeepers closing the shutters of their shops in a panic. As the witness was nearby and he saw that people were running, he thought something was wrong and therefore stood behind a shelter to watch the incident from a distance. The witness saw the Petitioner among the crowd of children, holding a long koyta in his hand and talking to a friend who owned the paan stall. It is stated that the Petitioner put his hand in the cash counter to take out some money, and also abused the owner of the paan stall. The Petitioner forcefully took an amount of Rs. 3,500/- from the paan stall.

12)

Perusal of the statement of witness B would indicate that, the same was recorded on 1st November 2025 and pertains to the incident of 13th October 2025. The witness was a vegetable vendor who was selling vegetables on his handcart at around 7.15 p.m. The Petitioner and his accomplice suddenly came in front of his handcart, threatened and abused the vegetable vendor. The vegetable vendor was assaulted by the Petitioner and his accomplice. The people/customers who had come to buy vegetables from the complainant ran away from the spot of the incident. The Petitioner and his accomplice forcefully took an amount of Rs. 1,450/- from the witness's pant pocket and left after threatening the witness.

13)

In paragraph 7 of the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority, after referring to the above-mentioned offences/incident , i.e. C.R. No. 130 of 2025 and two in-camera statements of witnesses A and B, has specifically stated that, he was subjectively satisfied that the Petitioner is a dangerous person as defined under Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act. It is stated that, the Petitioner has unleashed a reign of terror and has become a perpetual danger to society at large in the areas of Bundgarden and Uttamnagar Police Stations, Pune.

14)

In paragraph 8, the Detaining Authority has specifically stated that, it has relied upon the material mentioned in paragraphs 5.1, 6.1 and 6.2 of the Grounds of Detention to arrive at its subjective satisfaction that the Petitioner is a dangerous person as defined under Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act and that the criminal activities of the Petitioner are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order.

15)

Along with the Detention Order, the Grounds of Detention are served upon the Detenue with the purpose and object that the Detenue is made well aware of the exact case which he is required to answer. The Grounds of Detention contain the basis on which the subjective satisfaction of the Detaining Authority has been arrived at and the Detention Order passed. Under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India, the Detenue has a right to make representation to the Authorities. The said representation is made by the detenue, based on and in response to the Grounds of Detention. It is pertinent to note that, the Grounds of Detention assume and are of critical importance because they afford an opportunity to the Detenue to make a representation at the earliest, in consonance with Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India.

16)

In our considered view, the contents of paragraph 2 of the Grounds of Detention clearly indicate that, the Detaining Authority had already concluded, based on the past offences and preventive actions, mentioned in paragraph 2 of the Grounds of Detention, that the Petitioner was a dangerous person and, was indulging in criminal activities prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. The said conclusion/subjective satisfaction is also based on past activities/actions which are mentioned in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Grounds of Detention.

17)

Here it would be useful to refer to the definitions of “dangerous person” and of “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order” as defined under the MPDA Act which read as follows:

Section 2(b-1):

"Dangerous person' means a person, who either by himself or as a member or leader of a gang, habitually commits, or attempts to commit or abets the commission of any of the offences punishable under Chapter XVI or Chapter XVII of the Indian Penal Code or any of the offences punishable under Chapter V of the Arms Act, 1959."

“2.

Definitions. In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,- (a) "acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order" means-

(i)

…..

2(a) (iv) in the case of a dangerous person, when he is engaged, or is making preparation for engaging, in any of his activities as a dangerous person, which affect adversely, or are likely to affect adversely, the maintenance of public order.”

18)

To term a person as a ‘dangerous person’ it is required that, the ingredients of both Sections 2(b-1) and Section 2(a)(iv) are satisfied. In our opinion, the Detaining Authority, has in fact done and dealt with the same in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the ground of Detention itself. We have noted that, the Detaining Authority, after recording the aforesaid observations has in paragraphs 7 and 8 specifically stated that, it had relied on material mentioned in paragraph 5, 6.1 and 6.2 of the Grounds of Detention to arrive at its subjective satisfaction that Petitioner is a dangerous person under Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA Act and that his criminal activities were prejudicial to the maintenance of the public order. In our considered view, the observations made in paragraphs 2 and 8 of the Grounds of Detention are contradictory, as the Detaining Authority, in paragraph 2, arrives at its conclusion and bases its subjective satisfaction on past offences, activities and preventive actions, while in paragraph 8 of the Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority specifically observes that it has based its subjective satisfaction on C.R. No. 130 of 2025 and two in-camera statements of witnesses A and B. This, in our opinion, clearly creates confusion and thereby directly affects the Petitioner's right to make an effective representation. One of the rights contemplated under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India is to afford the detenue an opportunity of making an effective representation. The said opportunity is of crucial importance to the detenue, as an action under preventive Detention is a summary action involving imprisonment without a trial.

19)

When paragraphs 2 and 8 of the Grounds of Detention are read together, they clearly create a confusion in the mind of a prudent person. The Petitioner while making a representation, would not be able to clearly know whether he has to deal with the past offences and/or preventive actions mentioned in paragraphs 2 and 3, or whether he has to deal only with the material relied upon by the Detaining Authority in paragraphs 5, 6.1 and 6.2, or both. This adversely affects the Petitioner’s right to make an effective representation.

20)

We note that, the references made in paragraph 2 are not a casual or passing reference made to the past offences or preventive actions nor can the contents be termed or referred to as only an interlocutory preamble. The Detaining Authority has clearly concluded that the past offences and actions of the Petitioner made him a “Dangerous Person”.

21)

We have no doubt in our mind that the contents of paragraphs 2 and 3, when read with paragraph 8, would cause a confusion in the mind of any person including the Petitioner and, as a result thereof, the right of the Petitioner to make an effective representation to the competent authority would be adversely affected. In our view, therefore, the Petitioner’s right under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India was violated and adversely affected. A useful reference can be placed on the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Vijay Kumar Dharna v. Union of India, reported in (1990) 1 SCC 60

22)

Perusal of the contents of paragraphs 2 and 8 of the Grounds of Detention, clearly creates a confusion as to the basis and material on which the Detaining Authority has arrived at its subjective satisfaction. Considering the Grounds of Detention in their entirety, we are of the considered view that, the contents of paragraphs 2 and 8 clearly created confusion in the mind of the detenue and it is not clear on which material the Detaining Authority has relied upon to reach its subjective satisfaction. This, confusion and lack of clarity, in our considered view directly affects the right of the detenue to make an effective representation. It appears that, the detaining authority has also relied upon the past instances as well as the instances referred to in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Grounds of Detention, and still proceeded to state that it relies only on the instances mentioned in paragraph 5 and 6 of the Grounds of Detention. In our opinion, this has prejudiced the right of the Petitioner to make an effective representation. One cannot lose sight of the fact that Preventive Detention action is a summary action and the Detention is without trial. One of the safeguards available to the Detenue is his right of making a representation as provided under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India. The said safeguard, should be effectively, completely and meaningfully provided to the Detenue. The right to make a representation includes a right to make a complete, effective and meaningful representation. It is necessary that, the facts and material on which the subjective satisfaction is arrived at should be clear, present and not stale grounds nor based on acts/misconduct which can be effectively and completely addressed by the normal law of the land. In view of the aforestated peculiar facts of this case, we are of the considered view that the Detention Order cannot be sustained and is liable to be quashed and set-aside.

23)

Hence the following Order.

i)

The Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (b) which read as follows :-

“b. This Hon’ble Court may be pleased to issue a proper Writ/order/direction for quashing and setting aside the impugned Detention Order dated 07/01/2026 bearing OW. No. CRIME PCB/ DET/ UTTAMNAGAR/ CHAVAN/ 19/ 2026 passed by the Respondent No. 2 u/s. 3(2 of the M.P.D.A. Act and impugned Committal Order dated 07/01/2026 bearing OW. No. CRIME PCB/DET/UTTAMNAGAR/ CHAVAN/ 20/ 2026 passed by the Respondent No. 2 arising out of impugned order dated 30/12/2025 passed by the Respondent No.1 bearing (Special MPDA No. - 1225/CR-673/Spl-3B and direct the respondents to release the Petitioner forthwith;”

ii) The Petitioner be released from detention forthwith, if not required in any other case.

iii) Petition is disposed of.