Results
High Courts(2026) 11 BOM CK 1944

Nilesh @ Golu @ Ajit Vs State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court · Nagpur Bench · 02 Nov 2026 · Rohit W. Joshi, J · Shivkumar Dige, J

Open full page

Judgment

24 paragraphs · 2,638 words

(Rohit W. Joshi, J.)

1.

Vide judgment and order dated 22.09.2020 passed in Sessions Case No.42 of 2019, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli has convicted the present appellant/original accused for offence punishable under Sections 302, 364 read with Section 149 and Section 148 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”). The said judgment and order is subject matter of challenge in the present appeal.

2.

It is the case of the prosecution that on 23.04.2016 at around 04:00 a.m., 50 to 60 naxalites came to village Huryaldand, Tah. Kurkheda, Dist. Gadchiroli, abducted two villagers, namely Gangsu Budu Kumoti and Matkursha Sanku Holi and murdered them on 25.04.2016 by firing bullets.

3.

The FIR was registered on the basis of complaint made by PW-1/Dhondu Kumoti, uncle of deceased Gangsu. However, he is not witness to the abduction or killing. His evidence is relevant only to the extent of lodging of FIR. The accused did not even cross-examine this witness.

4.

Prosecution has examined wife of deceased Indira Gangsu Kumoti as PW-2. She has deposed that one boy and two girls had come to her house at 12:00 midnight and they abducted her husband from the house. She has stated that she tried to follow them, however, she was warned not to accompany them. She has deposed that on 25.04.2016, deceased was found to have been killed at Khamtala – Malewada Road. During the course of her deposition, she identified the accused as one of the persons who had come to her house with the two girls and had taken away her husband. During the course of her cross-examination, an omission was elicited to effect that she had not stated before the police while her statement was recorded, that one boy and two girls had come to her house. She admitted that around 50 to 60 naxalites had gathered around her house. She denied the suggestion that face of the persons who abducted her husband were covered with cloth. She also denied the suggestion that there was no electricity supply to her house and that it was dark when three naxalites took away her husband. She admitted that her husband was taken away by around 20 to 30 naxalites. She also denied that the police had showed her photograph of the accused on the basis of which she deposed against the accused.

5.

Deposition of wife of another deceased, Mirabai Matkursha Holi, is recorded as PW-3. She has also deposed that her husband was abducted at around 12:00 midnight. She has stated that five naxalites had come to her house and forcibly abducted her husband. She has deposed that she, her mother-in-law, father-in-law accompanied her husband while he was being taken away by naxalites. However, from midway, the naxalites asked them to return and upon her insistence to accompany her husband, she was beaten up and two naxalites dropped her back to her house. She has stated that on the third day, she learnt that naxalites had killed her husband by firing gunshots at village Khamtala. She identified the accused over video conferencing unit as one of the persons who had come to her house for abducting her husband. During her cross-examination, omission with respect to the statement that five naxalites had entered the house and she along with her parents-in-law had accompanied her husband for some distance but were forced to return and further that she was beaten by naxalites, does not appear in her statement recorded by the police. She admitted the suggestion that around 50 to 60 naxalites had surrounded her house and that around 20 of them were in the age group of 25 to 30 years. She admitted the suggestion that normally faces of naxalites are covered with cloth or painted black stripes. She admitted that on the date of cross-examination, she could not identify the naxalites, since their faces were painted with black stripes.

6.

Manguram Madavi as PW-8 has stated that he knew the two persons who were killed by naxalites in the year 2016. He has stated that 8 to 10 days prior to the incident, naxalites had come to his house at nighttime and took him to field where they inquired about his work and told him not to do any religious work. He identified the accused on video conferencing unit as one of the two naxalites who had come to his house. In cross-examination, he stated that names of two naxalites who visited his house were Dinkar and Vikas. However, he further denied the suggestion that accused was not the person who had visited his house.

7.

PW-9 and PW-10 have deposed that after the aforesaid two individuals were killed by naxalites, they had called a meeting of villagers. Both these witnesses have stated that the accused was present in the said meeting arranged by the naxalites. PW-9 has stated that the accused was present with the naxalites. In his cross-examination, PW-9 has stated that the meeting was held after a period of three days from the date of murder. He has stated that there were around 25 to 30 naxalites. He has admitted that the naxalites had covered their faces by black cloth, and therefore, he could not identify them. However, he denied the suggestion that accused was not present in the said meeting. In his cross-examination, PW-10 has stated that he was not aware as to whether all the naxalites had covered their faces. He too denied the suggestion that accused was not present in the said meeting.

8.

PW-13 was working as A.P.I. in Naxal Cell in the office of Superintendent of Police, Gadchiroli. He has stated that his job was to prepare Dalam Profile, to keep watch on naxal movements and to interrogate naxalites. ‘Dalam’ is a word commonly used for unit of naxalites. He has stated that name of the accused was recorded as a naxalite in their records. He identified the accused on video conferencing unit. In his cross-examination, he admitted that naxal profiles are prepared as per information provided by surrendered naxals and that he had not seen the accused prior to his arrest. He has also admitted that the name of accused was learnt from surrendered naxalites.

9.

The Investigating Officer is examined as PW-17. He has deposed about lodging of FIR and other steps taken during the course of investigation. In his cross-examination, omissions in the statements of PW-2 and PW-3 are extracted. The omission of PW-2 is that she did not state that at the time of incident, one boy and two girls had been to her house at 12:00 midnight. The omissions of PW-3 are that she did not state that five naxalites had entered her house, her husband accompanied them, she and parents-in-law accompanied the husband and they were told to return from midway and further that when she insisted to accompany the husband, she was beaten by naxalites and two of them dropped her at her house. This witness admitted that since offences of kidnapping occur in nighttime, identification parade is necessary. The evidence of other witnesses is not discussed since the same is not relevant for deciding the present appeal.

10.

At the outset, it must be stated that no person has witnessed the appellant/accused committing the murder of the aforesaid two persons. There is no direct evidence against him to link him to the offence of murder under Section 302 of the IPC. The evidence regarding his presence in the alleged meeting of villagers called by naxalites after the murder is also not of much relevance, particularly when nobody has deposed that the naxalites present in the alleged meeting were the same persons who had surrounded the house of the deceased persons when they were abducted from their houses. PW-9 and PW-10 have been examined as witnesses to establish that meeting was held by naxalites after murder of the two persons and that accused was present at the said meeting. PW-9 has stated that the meeting was held three days after the murder. As against this, PW-10 has deposed that the meeting was held 15 days after the murder. PW-9 has specifically admitted that all persons who were present had covered their faces with cloth and therefore, he could not identify the naxalites attending the meeting. Despite this admission, he denied the suggestion that accused was not present at the meeting. Apart from PW-9 and PW-10, the other villagers who were examined have not spoken about the alleged meeting called by naxalites after the murder. It is difficult to accept that whereas all other naxalites, as stated by PW-9, had their faces covered, the accused/appellant did not cover his face. Apart from this, there is no evidence to infer that the naxalites who were present in the meeting were in fact the ones who had committed the murder or were part of group of 50-60 naxalites who had gathered around the houses of the deceased persons on the date of their abduction.

11.

The evidence of PW-8, who has deposed that 8 to 10 days prior to the incident naxalites including the appellant/accused had visited his house, inquired about his profession from him and thereafter asked him not to indulge in religious work, is not of much relevance. The evidence will be relevant only to arrive at inference that appellant/accused was a naxalite or an associate of naxalites.

12.

Evidence of PW-13 is also relevant only to a limited extent that as per information provided by some unknown surrendered naxalites, name of the appellant/accused came to be included in the profile of naxalites maintained by the office of Superintendent of Police.

13.

The evidence of PW-2 and PW-3, wives of the deceased persons, will be relevant. Both have deposed that the accused had entered their house along with other naxalites and abducted their husbands and after a period of two days from the date of abduction, their husbands were murdered. Both of them have identified the accused on the video conferencing unit.

14.

Mr. Lingayat, learned advocate for the appellant argues that both PW-2 and PW-3 have stated that the accused had been to their house on the same date and same time for abduction of their husbands. He contends that it is inconceivable that the accused has abducted their husbands from two different places at the same time. The learned advocate further contends that the evidence of PW-3 will reveal that she has admitted in her cross-examination that she could not identify the naxalites who had entered her house since their faces were covered with black stripes. He contends that this material admission is not taken into consideration by the learned Sessions Court. He further contends that the incident has occurred in nighttime when the witnesses were sleeping and all of a sudden a group of naxalites allegedly entered their house for abduction of their husbands. He contends that it is difficult to accept that the faces of the persons who had abducted their husbands were properly seen by the witnesses. He further argues that both these witnesses were not knowing the accused, and therefore, it is inconceivable that they could identify the accused as the person who had abducted their husbands and that too after a period of over four years and three months. He contends that the accused was arrested on 27.12.2017, and yet test identification parade of the accused was not conducted.

15.

On the contrary, the learned A.P.P. argues that the wives of both the deceased persons have specifically identified the accused in the witness box. It is contended that identification of accused in the witness box constitutes a substantive piece of evidence, whereas test identification parade does not constitute a substantive piece of evidence. The learned A.P.P. argues that several other persons have also identified the accused as a naxalite. In this regard, attention is drawn to evidence of PW-8, 9, 10 and 13. The learned A.P.P. therefore submits that the appeal is without any substance and the same may be dismissed.

16.

Happening of the incident of abduction followed by murder is not seriously in dispute. Perusal of cross-examination of the witnesses will indicate that the accused did not seriously dispute the contention of prosecution with respect to abduction and murder of the deceased persons. The cross-examination was directed towards bringing on record that prosecution had failed to prove involvement of the accused in the offence. The arguments in the present appeal were also advanced on the same line.

17.

In the light of rival submissions, it must be stated that undisputably the accused was not known to PW-2 and PW-3. The act of abduction has occurred late in the night. PW-2 has specifically admitted in the cross-examination that the village is located in forest. There is no positive statement by any of the prosecution witnesses that electricity supply was available in house at the relevant time. Admittedly, the persons who entered the house of the deceased for abducting them had entered late at night. There is no positive evidence with respect to source of light in which PW-2 and PW-3 could have seen the face of the accused/appellant. Likewise, since the appellant/accused was not known to PW-2 and PW-3, it was incumbent upon prosecution to conduct a proper test identification parade. Here, the accused is identified by PW-2 and PW-3 after a period of over four years and three months from the date of incident. When an accused is not known to a witness who claims to be an eye witness to the accused committing crime, a test identification parade should normally be conducted. That apart, PW-3 has admitted that the faces of the persons who had abducted her husband were painted with black stripes, and therefore, she could not identify those persons. Despite this, she identified the accused as one of the persons who had abducted her husband. The evidence to the extent of identification of accused is therefore difficult to accept. It will also be pertinent to state that statement by PW-2 that three naxalites had entered her house and abducted her husband is by way of omission. Similarly, statement of PW-3 that five naxalites had entered her house and had abducted her husband is also by way of omission. Statement of PW-3 that she and her parents-in-law accompanied the naxalites and the deceased for some distance and were forced to return and further that PW-2 was also beaten and dropped at her residence is also by way of omission. There is no cogent reliable evidence to link the accused to the crime. Prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

18.

In the light of above discussion, it will have to be held that the prosecution has failed to prove its case against the appellant/accused beyond a reasonable doubt. In the result, the appeal deserves to be allowed, and hence, following order is passed :-

i)

Criminal Appeal is allowed.

ii) The impugned judgment and order dated 22.09.2020 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli in Sessions Case No.42 of 2019 convicting and sentencing appellant – Nilesh @ Golu @ Ajit S/o Saoji Potavi for the offence punishable under Sections 302, 364 read with Section 149 and Section 148 of the IPC, is quashed and set aside.

iii) The appellant – Nilesh @ Golu @ Ajit S/o Saoji Potavi, is acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections 302, 364 read with Section 149 and Section 148 of the IPC, for which he was tried in Sessions Case No.42 of 2019 by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli.

iv) The appellant – Nilesh @ Golu @ Ajit S/o Saoji Potavi, be released forthwith, if not required in any other case.

v)

The criminal appeal stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of.