Results
High Courts(2026) 11 BOM CK 1903

Vikram Gattani Vs State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Bombay High Court · Nagpur Bench · 03 Nov 2026 · Rajnish R. Vyas, J · Anil S. Kilor, J

Open full page

Judgment

18 paragraphs · 1,230 words

(Per : Rajnish R. Vyas, J.)

Heard.

2.

Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. The petition is heard with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties.

3.

The petitioner, who claims to be the owner of Field Survey No.331/3/1, situated at Umarkhed, District Yavatmal, has approached this Court praying for issuance of declaration that the action of re-reservation of the land by respondent No.1-State of Maharashtra and respondent No.2-Municipal Council, Umarkhed, is bad-in-law with a further request to withdraw the proposed re-reservation in the pending second revised development plan and other consequential reliefs are also prayed for.

4.

The aforesaid land of the petitioner was shown as reserved for the purpose of ‘Playground’ vide Reservation No.27 and part of the land for ‘Garden’ vide Reservation No.18 in the revised development plan of City of Umarkhed, which was sanctioned by the Government and came into force vide Notification published in official Gazette on 15/04/1999. As the land of the petitioner was not acquired, he issued a notice under section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (MRTP Act) and thereafter also, since no steps of acquisition were taken, Writ Petition No.5026 of 2022 was preferred before this Court, which came to be allowed on 17/03/2023.

5.

The Court declared that reservation of the aforesaid land for playground and garden has lapsed, in view of the provisions of section 127 of the MRTP Act, the Notification to that effect was also issued. The petitioner thereafter preferred an application under section 44 of the MRTP Act for sanctioning of the layout on 14/10/2024. Respondent No.2-Municipal Council then sought guidance from respondent No.3-Assistant Director of Town Planning and vide communication dated 24/03/2025, it was informed by respondent No.3 that the second draft of revised development plan is already submitted under section 30(1) of the MRTP Act for sanction to respondent No.1, which is pending under section 31 of the MRTP Act and it is only after receipt of the sanction, the permission can be granted according to the proposal in the development plan.

6.

The learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that re-reservation is not at all permissible. The learned counsel for the petitioner then submitted that on the basis of communication dated 24/03/2025, respondent No.2 informed the petitioner that an application for development shall be taken after sanctioning of second revised development plan under section 31 the MRTP Act.

7.

Per contra, the learned counsel for respondent No.2, on the strength of submissions filed, has contended that the land in question is already proposed for Re-reservation No.6, i.e. Community Park and twelve meters development plan road and therefore, it would not be appropriate to grant development permission for sanctioning the layout on the land in question till the sanction under section 31 of the MRTP Act to the second revised development plan is granted.

8.

With the help of respective counsel, we have gone through the record of the case. It is not in dispute that the same land was earlier shown reserved in the revised development plan of City of Umarkhed, which came into force on 15/04/1999 for playground and garden. It is also not disputed that since the Authorities could not take any action, a purchase notice came to be served and thereafter also no steps of acquisition were taken. This compelled the petitioner to invoke writ jurisdiction of this Court by preferring Writ Petition No.5026 of 2022, which came to be decided on 17/03/2023 and it was declared that the reservation stated above has lapsed under section 127 of the MRTP Act. The re-reservation and forwarding of proposal thereafter in our opinion could not be a ground for rejecting the permission sought by the petitioner for development of the land in question.

9.

The learned counsel for the petitioner has rightly relied upon the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited v. State of Maharashtra and others, reported in (2015) 11 SCC 554, more particularly paragraph-20, which is reproduced as under :

20.

In view of the abovesaid statement of law declared by this Court in the cases referred to supra, after adverting to the judgment of majority view in Girnar Traders (2) case2 is accepted in Shrirampur Municipal Council3, wherein it is held that Girnar Traders (2) case4 is not conflicting with Hakimwadi Tenants' Assn. case5, the statement of law laid down in the abovereferred cases is aptly applicable to the fact situation. Therefore, we have to hold that the impugned notification is bad in law and liable to be quashed. The High Court has not examined the impugned notification from the viewpoint of Section 127 of the MRTP Act and interpretation of the abovesaid provision made in Girnar Traders (2)4, therefore, giving liberty to the appellant by the High Court to file objections to the proposed notification is a futile exercise on the part of the appellant for the reason that the State Government, once the purpose the land was reserved for has not been utilised for that purpose and a valid statutory right is acquired by the landowner/interested person after expiry of 10 years from the date of reservation made in the development plan and 6 months' notice period has also expired, the State Government has not commenced the proceedings to acquire the land by following the procedure as provided under Sections 4 and 6 of the repealed Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Therefore, the land which was reserved for the above purpose is lapsed and it enures to the benefit of the appellant herein. Therefore, it is not open for the State Government to issue the impugned notification proposing to modify the development plan from deleting for the purpose of the Railways and adding to the development plan for the formation of development plan of road after lapse of 10 years and expiry of 6 months' notice served upon the State Government.”

10.

Perusal of the observations of Hon’ble Apex Court would clearly reveal that the reservation of the land, which was reserved earlier for the purpose, is lapsed and consequently ensures the benefit for the person interested/owner of the property, therefore, it would not be open for the State Government to issue Notification proposing to notify the development plan from deleting the earlier purpose and adding to the development plan for effecting new development after lapse of substantial period. As this Court has already declared that the reservation has lapsed and therefore, the rejection of the application for development on the ground of sanction under section 31 of the MRTP Act is yet not received, would be contrary to the law. Hence, the following order is passed.

ORDER

(I)

The writ petition is allowed.

(II)

It is declared that the action of re-reservation of the land owned by the petitioner bearing Field Survey No.331/3/1 of Mouza Umarkhed, District Yavatmal, by respondent No.1-State of Maharashtra and respondent No.2-Municipal Council Umarkhed is bad-in-law.

(III)

The impugned communication dated 24/03/2025 issued by respondent No.3-Assistant Director, Town Planning, Yavatmal, as well communication dated 08/04/2025, issued by respondent No.2-Municipal Council Umarkhed are hereby quashed and set aside.

(IV)

Application dated 14/10/2024 submitted by the petitioner at Annexure-B be decided within four weeks from the production of this order, in accordance with law.

11.

Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms. No order as to costs.