M/s. K.C. Construction Company & Ors. Vs Mrs. Arlinda Dos Anjos Dias Torres E Fernandes & Ors.
Bombay High Court · Goa Bench · 03 Nov 2026 · S. G. Chapalgaonkar, J
Judgment
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. With consent of parties, matter is heard finally at admission stage.
The petitioners impugns order dated 27.02.2024 passed by Commercial Court in Commercial Suit No.20/2021/B, whereby respondents’ written statement were permitted to be taken on record by condoning delay caused beyond 120 days from date of service of summons/appearance of parties in Commercial Suit.
The petitioners are original plaintiffs. They instituted suit bearing SCS No.3/2016/A in Court of Civil Judge Senior Division, Panaji at Goa for specific performance, damages against respondent nos.1 to 4. The respondents instead of filing written statement, submitted application under Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, which came to be rejected.
On 13.05.2017, suit came to be transferred to Commercial Court i.e. District Judge-I at Panaji. On 23.11.2017, Commercial Court issued notices to parties and made it returnable on 02.01.2018. On 02.01.2018, Advocates instructed by defendants/respondents caused their appearance and matter was adjourned for reply of respondents. On 16.08.2018, respondent nos.1 to 3 filed application to accept written statement by condoning delay, which was allowed by Commercial Court vide order dated 27.06.2019. On 27.06.2019, respondent no.4 filed application for accepting written statement by condoning delay. The Commercial Court allowed said application vide order dated 25.09.2019 and accepted written statement of respondent no.4 by condoning delay.
The petitioners had assailed aforesaid orders by filing Writ Petition No.897/2019 precisely contending that Commercial Court lacks jurisdiction to accept written statement filed beyond 120 days from date of service of summons, particularly in light of law laid down by Supreme Court in case of M/s. SCG Contracts India Private Limited Vs. K. S. Chamankar Infrastructure Limited and Ors.1. The respondents supported impugned orders of Commercial Court relying upon observations of Supreme Court in case of Raj Process Equipments and Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Vs. Honest Derivatives Pvt. Ltd2.
In wake of aforesaid submissions, this Court had observed that aforesaid point was not raised before Commercial Court nor it was considered while passing impugned order. Eventually, passed order directing Commercial Court to hear and decide applications made by respondents for taking on record written statement afresh in accordance with law and until such applications are decided, directed to retain written statements subject to further orders to be passed by Commercial Court after hearing parties. On 27.02.2024, Commercial Court took fresh decision and again accepted written statement of respondents by condoning delay. Hence, this Writ Petition.
Mr. Sudin Usgaonkar, learned Senior Advocate appearing for petitioners would submit that present suit is governed by provisions of Commercial Courts Act, particularly by special amendments to provisions of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 made applicable to commercial disputes in terms of Section 16 of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The respondent nos.1 to 3 were issued notices by Commercial Court on 23.11.2017 and they caused their appearance on 02.01.2018. Therefore, it was obligatory on their part to file written statement within 120 days. The Commercial Court had no jurisdiction to condone delay or grant extension beyond aforesaid period. The Supreme Court has settled aforesaid aspect in case of M/s. SCG Contracts India Private Limited (supra). However, Commercial Court mechanically applied ratio in case of Raj Process Equipments and Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (supra) to hold that since suit was originally not filed to Commercial Court, strict provision of Commercial Courts Act would not apply to suit. According to Mr. Usgaonkar, after transfer of suit to Commercial Court, respondents were given fresh notices for appearance before Commercial Court. In response to such notice, they caused appearance through their Advocates. However, failed to file written statement within prescribed period of 120 days from date of their first appearance before Commercial Court. Therefore, even by ignoring their failure to file written statement during pendency of suit before Civil Court, their default from date of appearance before Commercial Court to file written statement within stipulated period of 120 days cannot be condoned by misinterpreting observations of Supreme Court in case of Raj Process Equipments and Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (supra).
Per contra, Mr. J. A. Lobo, learned Advocate appearing for respondents would submit that Supreme Court considered judgment in case of M/s. SCG Contracts India Private Limited (supra) in subsequent case of Raj Process Equipments and Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (supra), wherein it has been observed that rigours of sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order V of Code of Civil Procedure or Proviso to Rule 1 of Order VIII would not apply to suits which have been filed before normal Civil Court and then transferred to Commercial Court and, therefore, present suit would be governed by interpretation given to Order VIII Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure in case of Salem Advocate Bar Association Vs. Union of India3.
Mr. Lobo would further place his reliance on observations of this Court in case of Colonial Life Insurance Company (Trinidad) Ltd. and Another Vs. Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd.4, wherein while deciding issue as to “whether mandatory timeline of 120 days for filing written statement in Commercial Suit is applicable to suit, which were filed prior to enactment of Commercial Courts Act or have subsequently being transferred as Commercial Suits to be heard by Commercial Division” observed that Proviso to sub-rule (1) of Order V of Code of Civil Procedure shall not apply to transferred suits and Courts may, in its discretion prescribe a new time period within which written statement shall be filed. The Court has discretion to prescribe new timeline, which excludes applicability of 120 days timeline stipulated in Order V Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure. Section 15(4) of Commercial Courts Act would come into play only if Writ summons is issued under Order V Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure.
Having considered submissions advanced by learned Advocates appearing for respective parties question that arises for consideration before this Court is as to whether in Civil Suit transferred to Commercial Court, defendants are under obligation to follow timeline of 120 days prescribed for filing written statement from date of service of notice by Commercial Court or their appearance before Commercial Court or whether transferred suit would continue to be governed by provisions of Rule 1 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure applicable in normal suit in terms of law laid down by Supreme Court in case of Salem Advocate Bar Association (supra).
Section 15 of Commercial Courts Act prescribes that all suits and application relating to commercial disputes of specified value pending before any Civil Court shall be transferred to Commercial Court. Sub-section (4) of Section 15 prescribes that Commercial Court may hold case management hearing in respect of such transferred suit in order to prescribe new timeline and issue further direction as may be necessary for speedy and efficacious disposal of suits or applications in accordance with Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Proviso to Rule 4 of Section 15 prescribes that proviso to sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order V of Code of Civil Procedure shall not apply to such transferred suits or application and Court may, in its discretion, prescribe new time period within which written statement shall be filed. Section 16 of Commercial Courts Act prescribes amendment to Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for its application to any suit in respect of commercial dispute of specified value and Commercial Courts are put under obligation to follow amended provisions in trial of suit in respect of commercial disputes. Sub-clause (3) of Section 16 prescribes that provision of Code of Civil Procedure as amended by this Act shall prevail in case of conflict with any provision of Code of Civil Procedure as applicable to jurisdictional Court. The relevant amended provision of Code of Civil Procedure as regards to timeline for filing written statement reads thus:
“The proviso of Order VIII Rule 1 read as under:
“Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing and on payment of such costs as the Court deems fit, but which shall not be later than one hundred twenty days from the date of service of summons and on expiry of one hundred twenty days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record.”
The proviso to Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure read as under:
“Provided further that no Court shall make an order to extend the time provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of the written statement.”
On interpretation of aforesaid provisions Supreme Court in case of M/s. SCG Contracts India Private Limited (supra) observed in paragraph nos.8 and 11 as under:
“A perusal of these provisions would show that ordinarily a written statement is to be filed within a period of 30 days. However, grace period of a further 90 days is granted which the Court may employ for reasons to be recorded in writing and payment of such costs as it deems fit to allow such written statement to come on record. What is of great importance is the fact that beyond 120 days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record. This is further buttressed by the proviso in Order VIII Rule 10 also adding that the Court has no further power to extend the time beyond this period of 120 days.”
We are of the view that the view taken by the Delhi High Court in these judgments is correct in view of the fact that the consequence of forfeiting a right to file the written statement; non-extension of any further time; and the fact that the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record all points to the fact that the earlier law on Order 8 Rule 1 on the filing of written statement under Order 8 Rule 1 has now been set at naught.”
In case of Raj Process Equipments and Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (supra) on 11.08.2018 suit pending before Civil Judge Senior Division was transferred to Commercial Court in pursuance to its designation in terms of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Prior to that on 03.07.2018 ‘No Written Statement’ order was passed by Civil Court against defendants. On appearance before Commercial Court, defendants sought for recalling of order of ‘No Written Statement’ order dated 03.07.2018 passed against them by Civil Court. The Commercial Court rejected said application citing Proviso to Rule 1 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure. This Court confirmed said order. In aforesaid backdrop, Supreme Court took note that ‘No Written Statement’ order was passed on 03.07.2018 while suit was before normal Civil Court. Thereafter, suit was transferred to Commercial Court. The period of 120 days was already expired on 18.06.2018 while suit was pending before Civil Court. In wake of aforesaid backdrop, Supreme Court observed that proceeding in suit would continue to be governed by law laid down in case of Salem Advocate Bar Association (supra), wherein Proviso to Rule 1 of Order VIII has been interpreted and held same to be directory and not mandatory and excluded same from application of timeline of 120 days prescribed for suits instituted before Civil Court and transferred to Commercial Court.
Single Judge of this Court in case of Colonial Life Insurance Company (Trinidad) Ltd. and Another (supra) had framed following question of law:
“Whether mandatory timeline of 120 days for filing a written statement in a commercial suit is applicable to suits which were filed prior to the enactment of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and have subsequently been ‘transferred’ as Commercial Suits to be heard by a Commercial Division?” and concluded in paragraph no.20 as under:
“20.I therefore hold that the mandatory timeline of 120 days for filing a written statement in a Commercial Suit is not applicable to suits which were filed prior to the enactment of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and subsequently 'transferred' as Commercial Suits to be heard by a Commercial Division of this Court. I further hold that a Commercial Division or Commercial Court, as the case may be, may hold Case Management Hearings in respect of such transferred suits under the newly introduced Order XV-A of the CPC to prescribe new timelines or issue further directions including prescribing a new time period within which a written statement shall be filed. The jurisdiction to exercise such discretion is expressly found in Section 15 (4) of the Commercial Courts Act and the proviso thereto.”
While arriving aforesaid findings, Single Judge of this Court observed that proviso to Section 15 (4) provides that proviso to sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order V of Code of Civil Procedure shall not apply to such transferred suits and court may, in its discretion, prescribe a new time period within which a written statement shall be filed. The important aspect of language of proviso is that it specifically states that Court has “discretion” to prescribe new timelines and that it excludes applicability of 120 timeline stipulated in Order V Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If proviso to Section 15(4) of Commercial Courts Act excludes time period as mentioned in Order V Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure, it for all purposes has excluded applicability of 120 days time period for filing written statements in respect of transferred suits. Had legislature intended for 120 days period to apply to transferred suits (by either referring to proviso to Order V Rule 1 and/or proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 and/or proviso to Order VIII Rule 10) there would have been no requirement of carving out this very exception under Section 15(4). It is further observed in paragraph no.12 that there is nothing in scheme or provisions of Commercial Courts Act to suggest that for transferred suits strict time limit of 120 days will apply where service of Writ of Summons is waived. The difficulty in identifying such a starting point for determining 120 days for filing written statement in transferred suits, especially as there is no such provision made in Section 15 of Commercial Courts Act, is yet another reason to accept and apply plain language of Section 15 (4) and proviso that such a time period was not intended to apply in transferred suits.
The aforesaid exposition of law by this Court would also answer the point for consideration framed in this matter. This Court finds no reason to take different view in facts of case.
It is matter of record that on 03.11.2016 Commercial Courts have been constituted in State of Goa. The suit which was instituted before Civil Court was transferred to Commercial Court on 13.05.2017. On 23.11.2017, fresh notices were issued to parties, returnable on 02.01.2018 and on same day defendants put their appearance through Advocate. In this backdrop, looking to proviso to Sub-clause (4) of Section 15 of Commercial Courts Act, it was obligatory on part of Commercial Court to prescribe new time period within which written statement was to be filed. Perusal of Roznanma do not show prescription of timeline for filing written statement. On the other hand, Court appears to have extended time for filing written statement without prescribing time limit. In aforesaid backdrop, respondent nos.1 to 4 submitted application for condonation of delay and acceptance of written statement, which has been allowed.
It is true that, in case of M/s. SCG Contracts India Private Limited (supra), Supreme Court observed that Court shall not allow written statement to be taken on record beyond 120 days from date of service of summons. However, such observations were made in a suit instituted before Commercial Court, and upon service of suit summons under Commercial Courts Act, defendants had filed their written statement. In present case, suit was instituted before Civil Court and it was transferred to Commercial Court after issuance of Notification dated 03.11.2016. The situation in present case is similar to that has been considered by this Court in case of Colonial Life Insurance Company (Trinidad) Ltd. and Another (supra). In that view of matter, this Court finds no reason to interfere in impugned order.
In result, Writ Petition stands dismissed.
Rule stands discharged.
