Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 11 CAT CK 3047

Santosh Kumar Yadav Vs Union Of India & Ors.

Central Administrative Tribunal · Allahabad · 03 Nov 2026 · Om Prakash VII, J · Manju Pandey, Member (A)

Open full page

Judgment

71 paragraphs · 4,441 words

By Justice Om Prakash VII, Member (J)

The present Original Application has been filed by the applicant under section 19 of the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985 seeking following reliefs:-

“a)

Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Certiorari quashing of impugned Order dated 26.07.2016 passed by Respondent No. 3, (Annexure No. A-9 to Compilation No. 2 of this application).

b)

Issue a writ, order or directions in the nature of mandamus, upon respondents to correct the position of applicant in Seniority list as on 01.01.2014 for the post of Junior Works Manager, published by OFB letter no. DJSL/2014/TECH (Revised)/ PER/GB dated: 18.11.2014.

c)

Issue any other suitable order or direction as this Hon'ble CAT may deem fit and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case.

d)

Award the cost of this application to the applicant”.

2.

The brief facts of the case are as follows:

The applicant was appointed as Junior Works Manager (JWM) on 16.12.2010 after undergoing the prescribed selection process. He submits that the post of JWM is a Group ‘B’ Gazetted post involving managerial duties and is distinct from the supervisory posts in the lower cadres. The applicant contends that, under the relevant recruitment rules and Ministry of Defence communications, the sanctioned strength of JWM (Electrical) was 275 posts. Certain vacancies pertaining to the period from 1998 to 2005 were stated to be unfilled by direct recruitment vacancies and the subsequent recruitment process was initiated to fill the sanctioned vacancies. He alleges that the respondents placed additional JWM (Electrical) officers above him in the seniority list dated 01.01.2014, although the sanctioned strength was limited to 275 posts. He further claims that his seniority should be reckoned from 15.01.2009, the date on which the relevant recruitment process was initiated, instead of 06.03.2009. The applicant submitted representations dated 01.04.2014, 24.07.2015 and 08.02.2016 against the seniority list of JWM (Technical/Electrical), published vide letter dated 18.11.2014, but his grievance was not resolved. He, therefore, filed O.A. No. 330/542/2016 before this Tribunal, which was disposed of on 27.04.2016 with a direction to the respondents to decide his representation dated 08.02.2016 by passing a reasoned and speaking order within two months. In compliance with the said order, the respondents rejected the applicant’s claim vide order dated 26.07.2016, communicated through the covering letter dated 30.07.2016. Aggrieved by the rejection of his claim and the alleged incorrect fixation of his seniority, the applicant has filed the present Original Application seeking appropriate relief.

3.

A counter affidavit has been filed by the respondents, denying the allegations made in the O.A. It has been stated that the applicant, was appointed as Junior Works Manager on 16.12.2010 in the pay scale of Rs.9,300–34,800 with Grade Pay of Rs.4,600. Thereafter, the Ordnance Factory Board, Kolkata, issued the seniority list of Junior Works Managers vide letter dated 18.11.2014. The applicant submitted a representation dated 08.02.2016 seeking a change in his seniority. As no decision was communicated to him, he filed O.A. No. 542/2016 before this Tribunal. The said O.A. was disposed of on 27.04.2016 with a direction to the respondents to decide his representation by passing a speaking order within two months. In compliance with the aforesaid direction, the Ordnance Factory Board, Kolkata, considered and rejected the applicant’s representation vide order dated 26.07.2016. The respondents stated that, as per DoP&T O.M. dated 04.03.2014, the principles for determining inter-se seniority of direct recruits and promotees were applicable with effect from 27.11.2012, and cases of seniority already settled were not to be reopened. Since the seniority of Junior Works Managers (Technical) as on 01.01.2009 had already been settled, the respondents considered that there was no justification for reopening the same. Aggrieved by the order dated 26.07.2016, the applicant has filed the present O.A., which, according to the respondents, is without merit and is liable to be dismissed.

4.

The applicant has also filed a rejoinder affidavit, reiterating the facts stated in the Original Application and denying the averments made in the counter affidavit. No new facts have been brought on record in the rejoinder affidavit.

5.

We have heard Shri Shiv Chand Yadav, learned counsel for the applicant, and Shri M.K Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents, and have perused the record.

6.

Submission of learned counsel for the applicant is that the applicant is aggrieved by the revised seniority list of Junior Works Managers (Technical/Electrical) as on 01.01.2014, issued vide letter dated 18.11.2014. It is contended that, as per the Ministry of Defence letter dated 08.06.2009, the sanctioned strength of Junior Works Managers (Electrical) was 275 as on 06.03.2009. However, several officers have been placed above the applicant in the seniority list, adversely affecting his seniority and promotional prospects. Learned counsel for the applicant further submitted that the applicant’s seniority ought to have been counted from 15.01.2009, being the date of initiation of the relevant recruitment process, instead of 06.03.2009. It is argued that the vacancies in question related to earlier unfilled direct recruitment vacancies and the respondents have wrongly determined the applicant’s seniority. Learned counsel for the applicant contended that, following the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission, the posts of Assistant Foreman and Junior Works Manager were merged without making the necessary amendments to the applicable Recruitment Rules. According to learned counsel for the applicant, the merger of a non-gazetted post with a Group ‘B’ gazetted post and the placement of Assistant Foremen above the applicant in the seniority list are contrary to the Recruitment Rules and the applicable instructions. It is further submitted that an administrative order could not retrospectively alter the service conditions or seniority of the applicant without following the prescribed procedure. Learned counsel for the applicant next submitted that the applicant had submitted representations dated 01.04.2014, 24.07.2015 and 08.02.2016 seeking correction of his seniority, but his grievance was not properly addressed. Thereafter, in compliance with the order dated 27.04.2016 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 542/2016, the respondents rejected his representation vide order dated 26.07.2016, communicated on 30.07.2016, without properly considering the relevant facts and applicable rules. Thus, he contended that the impugned seniority list and the order rejecting the applicant’s representation are arbitrary, discriminatory and contrary to Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Learned counsel for the applicant prays that the impugned order be set aside and the respondents be directed to reconsider and correct the applicant’s seniority in accordance with the applicable rules.

7.

Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, submitted that there is no illegality or infirmity in the seniority list of Junior Works Managers (Technical/Electrical) issued vide letter dated 18.11.2014. It is contended that the applicant was appointed as Junior Works Manager on 16.12.2010 and his seniority has been determined in accordance with the applicable rules and instructions. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the sanctioned strength of 275 posts, as mentioned in the Ministry of Defence letter dated 08.06.2009, cannot by itself confer any right upon the applicant to claim seniority from 15.01.2009. The date of initiation of the recruitment process does not create any right to claim seniority from that date. It is further submitted that the determination of seniority is governed by the applicable recruitment rules and DoP&T instructions and not merely by the date of occurrence or availability of vacancies. Learned counsel for the respondents next submitted that the seniority of Junior Works Managers (Technical) as on 01.01.2009 had already been finalised. Therefore, the applicant cannot seek reopening of an already settled seniority position merely on the basis of his subsequent representations. It is contended that, as per DoP&T O.M. dated 04.03.2014, the revised principles for determining inter-se seniority of direct recruits and promotees were made applicable with effect from 27.11.2012. The said instructions did not provide for reopening of seniority cases which had already been settled before the aforesaid date. Thus, the respondents rightly declined to disturb the settled seniority position. It is also submitted that the applicant has failed to establish that the placement of other officers above him in the seniority list is contrary to any specific provision of the applicable Recruitment Rules. The applicant's contention regarding the merger of the posts of Assistant Foreman and Junior Works Manager, pursuant to the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission, does not establish that the seniority list is illegal. The merger and the determination of seniority are matters to be examined in accordance with the relevant Government decisions and applicable service rules. The applicant cannot claim a particular position in the seniority list merely on the ground that the posts earlier belonged to different cadres or had different designations. It is further submitted that in compliance with the order dated 27.04.2016 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 542/2016, the respondents examined his representation and passed a reasoned order dated 26.07.2016, communicating the decision to the applicant vide letter dated 30.07.2016. Thus, the respondents have duly complied with the directions issued by this Tribunal. The applicant has also failed to establish that any officer junior to him under the applicable rules has been wrongly placed above him. His claim is mainly based on the sanctioned strength of the posts and the date of initiation of the recruitment process, which, by themselves, are not sufficient to establish his right to claim seniority from 15.01.2009. Therefore, the applicant is not entitled to any relief and the Original Application is liable to be dismissed. In support of his claim, learned counsel for the respondents has relied upon the decision of Jabalpur Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 399/2014 (Deepak Pandey and others Vs. Union of India and others) decided on 07.08.2025.

8.

We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for both parties and perused the material available on record.

9.

The main issue for consideration is whether the respondents have correctly determined the seniority of the applicant in the cadre of Junior Works Manager (Technical/Electrical) and whether the order dated 26.07.2016 rejecting his representation suffers from any illegality or infirmity warranting interference by this Tribunal.

10.

Before examining the rival contentions, it would be appropriate to refer to the decision of the Jabalpur Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. No. 200/00399/2014, Deepak Pandey and (supra). The said case also relates to the determination of seniority in the cadre of Junior Works Manager following the merger of the posts of Assistant Foreman and Junior Works Manager pursuant to the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission. In the aforesaid judgment, the Tribunal considered the applicability of DoP&T O.M. dated 13.09.2012 and 04.03.2014 and examined the manner in which the respondents had determined the seniority in the merged cadre. In paragraph 9 of the judgment, the Tribunal took note of the detailed method adopted by the respondents for preparation of the revised seniority list. The aforesaid judgment reads as under:-

“CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, JABALPUR BENCH JABALPUR

Original Application No.200/00399/2014

Gwalior, this Thursday, the 7th day of August, 2025

HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE AKHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, JUDICIAL MEMBER

HON’BLE SMT MALLIKA ARYA, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER

1.

Deepak Pandey, age 38 years, S/o Shri Janki Prasad, Occupation: Junior Works Manager in GCF, Jabalpur, R/o 117, Type – 4, Abhyudaya Nagar-2, GCF Estate, Jabalpur, Pin 482075

2.

Shri K V Dhanamjay Rao, Age 46 years, S/o Shri K Soma Bvahman, Occupation; Junior Works Manager in G.C.F., Jabalpur, R/o 113/1, Type – 4, New Colony G.C.F. Estate Jabalpur Pin 482075

3.

M Siva Kumar, age 38 years, S/o M Shesharao, Occupation: Junior Works Manager, in V.F.J. Jabalpur, R/o Quarter – 486, Type – 4, Sector-II, V.F.J. Estate, Jabalpur M.P. Pin - 482009 –

Applicants

(By Advocate – None)

V e r s u s

1.

The Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Govt. of India, South Block, New Delhi – 110011

2.

Secretary, Department of Defence Production, South Block, New Delhi, Pin – 110001

3.

Director General of Ordnance, Factories and Chairman, 10, S.K. Bose Marg, Kolkata - 700001.

4.

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Through Secretary, Department of Personnel and Training, North Block, New Delhi Pin – 110011

5.

General Manager, Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur, Jabalpur, Pin – 482075

6.

General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory, Jabalpur, Jabalpur, Pin - 482075

- Respondents

(By Advocate – Shri S K Mishra)

ORDER (FINAL)

By Mallika Arya, AM;

Through this O.A., the applicants are seeking reinstatement of their seniority position vide seniority list as on 01.01.2010 (Annexure A/9) published on 27.01.2010 and seeking quashment of the seniority list published on 31.01.2014, as on 01.01.2012 revised seniority list published on 18.11.2014 as on 01.01.2014 (Annexure A/16) and the seniority list published on 19.06.2019 as on 01.01.2016 (Annexure A/17) issued by Respondent no. 3.

2.

Briefly stating, the facts of the case are that the applicants joined in the cadre of JWM, through the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination in the year 2009. However, the other employees who were though junior to the applicants in JWM cadre became senior due to wrong implementation of the DoP&T circular dated 13.09.2012 (Annexure A/2).

3 The two posts of Assistant Foreman (6500-10500) and JWM (7450-11500) were merged on 04.02.2012 with retrospective effect. The applicants joined the cadre of JWM before the executive order of merger was issued by the respondents whereas other employees who were junior to the applicants in JWM cadre became senior as per the newly constituted seniority list published in 2014 consequent to the merger. The applicants gave numerous representations but nothing has been done by the respondents. The DOP&T OM NO. 20020/4/2010-Estt. (D) dated 13.09.2012 (Annexure A/2) clarifies as follows:

“2.

III Where recruitment for the posts in different pre-revised pay scale(s) was initiated separately for each posts, prior to acceptance of recommendation of 6th CPC i.e. prior to 29.08.2008 but selected individual joined duty on or after 30.08.2008 in the revised pay scale(s) against the posts which have been granted same Grade pay, such officers will be assigned seniority en bloc below those officers who were in position as on 29.08.2008.”

The applicants have submitted that they have not been awarded correct seniority in light of the aforesaid OM but they have been given seniority of earlier post held by them i.e. Assistant Foreman without relying on the result of LDCE. However, the fact remains that the applicants became senior to many persons because they joined two years before them on the said post of JWM. The seniority list issued on 31.01.2014 merits to be quashed. Further, the persons who failed the examination of JWM LDCE 2008 and were born in JWM cadre after 04.02.2011 have been shown senior to the applicants in the revised seniority list of 18.11.2014. The applicants have relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of R S Raja & Ors vs. State of Gujrat 1997-3-SCC-641 wherein it has been held that the benefit which had accrued under the rules cannot be taken away by an amendment with retrospective effect. Further they have relied on the judgment in the case of Pawan Pratap Singh and Others vs Reevan Singh and others 2011-3-SCC-267 wherein it has been held that the date of entry in a particular service or date of substantive appointment is the safest criteria to decide the issue of seniority. They have also submitted that there is an order of CAT Madras in O.A./278/2011 which has been issued relying on the above judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court.

The main plea of the applicant is that the DOP&T OM 20020/4/2010-Estt. (D) dated 13.09.2012 should be implemented in letter and spirit wherein the employees like applicants who were appointed prior to the merger of posts into one post of JWM should be treated senior to persons who joined the post of JWM after merger that is on 04.02.2011. The applicants are drawing parity with the posts of Section Engineer with the Pay Scale 6500-10,500 which got merged with the posts of Sr. Section Engineer in the Pay Scale of 7450-11,500 in the Indian Railways. The persons who were already working on the post of Sr. Section Engineer, their seniority was protected from the date of merger. However, in the case of applicants, it is their seniority as Assistant Foreman which has been taken into consideration while fixing their seniority in the post of JWM. The applicants gave multiple representations but the said representations have been rejected by the respondents vide order dated 27.01.2014. The applicants have relied upon various case laws in support of above contentions. The applicants by way of an amendment application, have amended the prayer clause and prayed for quashing of the revised seniority list of JWM dated 18.11.2014 w.e.f. 01.01.2014 and the subsequent seniority list dated 19.06.2019 w.e.f 01.01.2016 subsequent to the filing of OA (Annexure A/16 & A/17).

3.

The respondents on the other hand have contended the seniority list of JWM was published on 31.01.2014 as per the DOP&T instructions dated 13.09.2012 which clarified as follows: “the seniority of government servant which existed on 29.08.2008 (date of acceptance of recommendation of 6th CPC) will be maintained, i.e. the holder of post having higher pay scale or post which constituted promotion post for the posts in the feeder grade will rank en bloc senior to those holding post having lower pay scale or the posts in feeder grade.” Consequently, the said seniority list of JWM published on 31.01.2014 w.e.f. 01.01.2012 was revised on 18.11.2014 in terms of DoP&T OM No. 20011/1/2012-Estt (D) dated 04.03.2014 which clarified that

“initiation of recruitment process against a vacancy year would be the date of sending of requisition for filling up of vacancies to the recruiting agency in the case of direct recruits.” The applicants did not raise any objection disputing their position in the revised seniority list dated 18.11.2014 before the competent authority nor before the Tribunal. Based on the settled seniority list dated 18.11.2014 certain promotions have taken place. Now, after a lapse of 6 years, the applicants have filed an amendment application disputing the seniority list dated 18.11.2014. Further, the respondents have stated that the seniority list dated 18.11.2014 has been drawn taking into account the following aspects i.e. “the date of submission of requisition to the recruiting Agency in case of JWMs appointed through direct recruitment, date of DPC in case of promotee JWMs, date of issue of notification for conducting LDCE in case of JWMs appointed/promoted through LDCE.” Just because the applicants are disputing the seniority list of 18.11.2014, neither the promotion proceedings can be kept on hold nor any post can be kept vacant for them.

4.

We have considered the matter, heard the counsels for the parties and perused the documents on record.

5.

It is a very old case and it is observed that an interim application was also filed by the applicants for grant of interim relief. However, no decision was taken on that application.

6.

The respondents have submitted that the merger of posts of Assistant Foreman with JWM took place consequent to the implementation of the Recommendations of the 6th Pay commission. Although the decision was published by respondents on 04.02.2011, the merger was given effect from 01.01.2006 that is the date from which the recommendations of the 6th pay commission were to be implemented.

7.

The respondents have also submitted that applicants have presented a concocted picture wherein the date of publication of order of merger (i.e. 04.02.2011) has intentionally been confused with the date of actual merger (i.e. 01.01.2006) of cadre of Assistant Foreman with JWMs. The date of publication of order of merger dated i.e. 04.02.2011 has no relevance/significance in determining the inter se seniority between erstwhile Assistant Foreman and JWM cadres. Moreover, the O.A. suffers from non-joinder of parties since the applicants have not made any of those persons who have been assigned seniority over and above them, as the respondents. Therefore, the O.A. is not maintainable in the eyes of law. The respondents have also submitted that since the seniority list dated 31.01.2014 (w.e.f. 01.01.2012) (Annexure A/5) has been substituted by the revised seniority list 18.11.2014, therefore the O.A. has become infructuous and is not maintainable in the eyes of law.

8.

Multiple M.A.s have been filed by the applicants making amendment in the O.A. as well as in the relief clause, consequent to the developments which have taken place after filing of O.A.. These have allowed by this Tribunal.

9.

However, we take note of the reply given by the respondents that the seniority list of 31.01.2014 w.e.f. 01.01.2012 was drawn in light of the DOP&T OM No. 29929/4/2010-Estt (D) dated 13.09.2012 which clarifies as follows:

“2.

III Where recruitment for the posts in different pre-revised pay scale(s) was initiated separately for each posts, prior to acceptance of recommendation of 6th CPC i.e. prior to 29.08.2008 but selected individual joined duty on or after 30.08.2008 in the revised pay scale(s) against the posts which have been granted same Grade pay, such officers will be assigned seniority enbloc below those officers who were in position as on 29.08.2008.” This seniority list was subsequently revised vide order dated 18.11.2014 (w.e.f. 01.01.2014) taking into account DOP&T OM No. 20011/1/2012- Estt (D) dated 04.03.2014 and DOP&T OM No. 20020/4/2010-Estt.(D), dated 13.09.2012. The said seniority list has been revised/modified in light of the following:

(i)

The Seniority list of JWM (Tech) as on 01.01.2009, circulated vide OFB No. DJSL/2009/A/GB, dated 30.01.2009, and having considered and duly disposed the representations on the same, has been taken as settled with reference to the applicable interpretation of the term availability, as contained in DOP&T O.M., dated 07.02.86/03.07.86, and has not been disturbed.

(ii)

JWMs holding the post as on 29.08.2008 have been ranked en-block senior.

(iii)

Those JWMs promoted after 29.08.2008. but Select panel drawn by the DPC prior to 29.08.2008 are placed below the incumbents covered in (ii) above.

(iv)

Those JWMs appointed / joined to the post through DR / I.DCE mode on or after 30.08.2008, but the recruitment processes initiated (Date of notification, in the case of LDCE & Date of submission of requisition to UPSC. in the case of DR) prior to 29.08.2008 are placed thereafter

(v)

Erstwhile Asstt. Foreman, who were holding the post on or before 29.08.2008 and stand merged with JWM w.e.f. 01.01.2006 as per the recommendation of 6' CPC are assigned seniority below the above JWMs.

(vi)

JWMs appointed / promoted to the post through different modes (Promotion / LDCE / DR ) are assigned seniority thereafter by applying rota-quota principle as per the quota prescribed in the relevant SRO in year to year basis by taking the crucial dates as below:

(a)

Date of DPC, in the case of Promote IWMs.

(b)

Date of issue of Notification for conducting LICE. in the case of JWMs appointed promoted through LDCE.

(c)

Date of submission of requisition to the recruiting agency. i.e. UPSC. in the case of JWMs appointed through DR.

10.

We observe that the respondents have given a comprehensive justification as to how the seniority list of 31.01.2014 drawn in pursuance of the directions contained in the DOP&T OM No. 29929/4/2010-Estt (D) dated 13.09.2012 was subsequently revised on 18.11.2014 in light of DOP&T OM No. 20011/1/2012-Estt (D) dated 04.03.2014.

11.

The applicants have not alleged any malafide against the respondents in allocation of seniority in the revised cadre of JWM and have merely drawn a conclusion that their seniority, merits refixation the DOPT guidelines have not been interpreted properly by the respondents.

12.

We also observe that the respondents have submitted that the applicants are trying to confuse the date of publication of order of merger (i.e. 04.02.2011) with the date of actual merger (i.e. 01.01.2006) of both the cadres i.e. Assistant Foreman with JWMs.

13.

Therefore, in light of aforesaid discussions we do not find any reason to interfere with the seniority list published on 31.01.2014 (as on 01.01.2012) (Annexure A/5) and subsequent seniority list published on 18.11.2014 (as on 01.01.2014) (Annexure A/16) and the seniority list dated 19.06.2019 (as on 01.01.2016) (Annexure A/17) in the cadre of JWM .

14.

In view of the observations made above, we do not find any merit in the case of the applicants and the O.A. is dismissed. No order as to costs”.

11.

In the aforesaid paragraphs, the Tribunal observed that the respondents had given a comprehensive justification for preparing the revised seniority list dated 18.11.2014 in the light of DoP&T O.M. dated 04.03.2014 and the earlier O.M. dated 13.09.2012.

12.

The applicant has also questioned the merger of the posts of Assistant Foreman and Junior Works Manager pursuant to the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission. However, the mere fact that the merger order was issued subsequently does not mean that the merger would take effect only from the date of issuance of that order. The actual effective date of merger has to be seen from the relevant Government decision. In Deepak Pandey (supra), the Jabalpur Bench of this Tribunal specifically considered this aspect and observed that the date of issuance of the merger order and the date from which the merger was given effect were two different matters. Therefore, the applicant's contention that the seniority of the officers from the merged cadre could not be considered in the revised seniority list merely because the merger order was issued subsequently cannot be accepted without examining the effective date and the relevant Government instructions.

13.

As regards the impugned order dated 26.07.2016, we find that the respondents considered the applicant's representation in compliance with the direction issued by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 542/2016. The applicant has not been able to point out any specific provision of law which has been ignored by the respondents or any material error in the reasoning given in the impugned order. Mere disagreement with the decision taken by the competent authority cannot be a ground for setting aside the same.

14.

In view of the above discussion and the principles laid down by the Jabalpur Bench of this Tribunal in Deepak Pandey and Others (supra), we do not find any sufficient ground to interfere with the seniority list of Junior Works Managers (Technical/Electrical) dated 18.11.2014 or the order dated 26.07.2016 rejecting the applicant's representation. The applicant has failed to establish that his seniority has been determined in violation of the applicable rules or that he is entitled to be placed at a higher position in the seniority list. Thus, the Original Application lacks merit and is liable to be dismissed.

15.

In view of the foregoing discussion, the Original Application is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. All associated MAs are disposed of.