Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 11 CAT CK 3820

H.C. Subhash Chand Vs Govt. of NCTD & Ors.

Central Administrative Tribunal · New Delhi · 03 Nov 2026 · R. N. Singh, Member (J) · Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)

Open full page

Judgment

45 paragraphs · 3,702 words

Hon’ble Mr. R. N. Singh, Member (J):

By way of the present O.A. filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant has sought the following reliefs:-

“8.1

To quash and set aside the impugned order dated 11.09.2013 passed by Disciplinary Authority at A-2, order dated 14.08.14 whereby the statutory appeal of the applicant has been rejected and to further direct the respondent that forfeited years of service be restored as it was never forfeited with all consequential benefits including seniority & promotion and pay & allowances.

8.2

To quash and set aside the findings of the Enquiry Officer.

8.3

To set aside the order of initiation of D.E. dated 22.03.2011.

Or/and

Any other relief which this Hon’ble court deems it and proper may also be awarded to the applicant.”

2.

We have heard learned counsels for the parties and with their assistance, we have also perused the pleadings available on record. We have also perused the original Disciplinary Enquiry records produced by the respondents.

3.

Undisputed facts of the case are that a complaint from Mr. Vinod Kumar Khanna, R/o 14/7, Mile Stone, Delhi Mathura Road, Faridabad, Haryana having office at Delhi was received by the Commissioner of Police on 25.07.2007 to the effect that on 16.06.2007 at about 11 A.M. six police personnel, including the applicant, who had been working as Head Constable at that time visited the office of said Mr. Vinod Kumar Khanna and informed him that a non-bailable warrant has been issued against him by Delhi Court and he is under arrest. One of them also showed him a weapon and threatened to kill him. When they were taking him away, Rajan Khanna, younger brother of Mr. Vinod Kumar Khanna requested them not to take his brother. Then one of the policemen took him aside and asked for Rs. 4 lacs for his release. They did not disclose their identity and informed that they are from Special Cell and arresting him under the directions of Commissioner of Police. They also threatened him to involve him in a heinous crime case, if he did not pay the amount to them. They released him after one and a half hour when they succeeded in extorting Rs. 50,000/- and obtaining an assurance that additional amount of Rs. 1 lakh would be paid within a week. After a few days one of the policemen collected Rs. 30,000/-from his brother in his absence. He left his mobile no. 9871315817 and told his name as Jai Singh.

4.

On receipt of such complaint, the Commissioner of Police ordered for strict disciplinary action and initiation of disciplinary action after suspension and legal action and for legal action to be taken against such concerned police personnel.

5.

It is also apparent from the records that it was also ordered that if deemed fit, Joint Commissioner of Police (Crime) could examine to see whether the case can be registered and the matter can be taken to its logical conclusion. In view of such order, the matter was entrusted to one Mr. M. R. Mehami for conducting preliminary enquiry into the matter, while, he was posted in vigilance/PHQ as ACP Vigilance and he submitted that said Mr. M. R. Mehami after conducting the preliminary enquiry submitted his report on 03.07.2007. On the basis of such report, vide impugned order dated 22.03.2011 (Annexure-A/1), the Deputy Commissioner of Police, 1st Battalion ordered for initiation of Departmental Enquiry against the applicant and other police personnel. Pursuant to such order, the Inquiry Officer was appointed, who in turn conducted the enquiry and has submitted the impugned enquiry report dated 05.06.2013 (Annexure-A/4) returning his findings on the charges levelled against the applicant which read as under:-

“I, Inspr. Jagjeet Singh, EO, DE Cell, Police Bhawan, Delhi charge all of you (i) HC Subhash Chand No. 315/DRP, now 67/DAP (PIS No. 28801096), (ii) Ct. Bhupender Singh No. 319/DRP, 10297/DAP, 375/DRP, now 1407/DAP (PIS No. 28912253), (iii) Ct. Ram Karan No. 281/Crime, now 1408/DAP (PIS No. 28932557) and (iv) Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD, 399/Crime, now 1406/DAP (PIS No. 28931144) that while you HC Subhash Chand, 315/DRP now 67/DAP, Ct. Bhupender Singh No. 319/DRP, 10297/DAP, 375/DRP, now 1407/DAP Ct. Ram Karan Meena No. 281/Crime now 1408/DAP were posted in Crime & Rlys and Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD, 399/Crime now 1406/DAP posted in PS Sangam Vihar, South Distt., New Delhi, complainant namely Sh. Vinod Kumar Khanna s/o Late Sh. V.P. Khanna r/o H.No. 631/21C, Faridabad, Haryana had submitted a complaint against all of you to commissioner of Police, Delhi on 26.06.2007 alleging therein that on 16.06.07 at about 11 AM, six police personnel including one Inspector came to the office of said Sh. Vinod Kumar Khanna at 14/7, Mile Stone Delhi Mathura Road, Faridabad, Haryana and informed that a Non-Bailable Warrant has been issued against said complainant by Delhi Court and he is under arrest. One of them also shown him a weapon and threatened to kill him. When these personnel were taking him (complainant) away, one Rajan Khanna, younger brother of complainant requested you not to take his brother. Then one of the policemen took his brother aside and asked for Rs. 4 Lacs for his release. These Police Personnel did not disclose their identity and informed that they are from Special Cell and arresting the said complainant under the directions of commissioner of police. They threatened him (complainant) to involve him in a heinous crime, if he did not pay the hefty amount to you. These police personnel released him (complainant) after one & half hour when you were succeeded in extorting Rs. 50.000/- and obtaining an assurance that additional amount of Rs. 1 Lakh would be paid within a week. After a few days, one of the policemen collected Rs. 30,000/- again from the brother of complainant in his absence. The said policemen left his mobile No. 9871315817 and told his name as Jai Singh.

It is pertinent to point out here that a Civil case No. 9843/01/04 U/S 138 Negotiable Instruments Act was pending between the complainant and Sh. Sidhartha Sapra s/o Late Sh. H.L. Sapra r/o H. No. Sant Nagar, East of Kailash, New Delhi in the court of Sh. Vikas Dhull MM Patiala House Courts, regarding non payment of two cheques worth Rs. 10 Lakhs and 13 Lakhs. During trial Mr. Sapra obtained NBW against Sh. Viond Kumar Khanna addressed to SHO/Lajpat Nagar Dasti from the court of Sh Vikas Dull, MM Patiala House Courts.

During the course of enquiry, you Ct. Ramesh Kumar, No. 672/SD now 1406/DAP was found holder of phone No. 9871315817. While you Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD now 1406/DAP was on duty, Sidhartha Sapra informed you that he had obtained a NBW against Vinod Khanna and the same is to be executed and also asked for any officer of Crime Branch. You Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD now 1406/DAP suggested Sidhartha Sapra to speak to HC Subhash Chand posted in crime Branch. On 16.06.07 all of you i.e. HC Subhash Chand, Ct Ramesh Kumar, R. K. Meena and HC Bhupinder along with a private person driver of a Maruti Van reached in the office of Sh. Vinod Kumar Khanna in Faridabad (HR) to execute NBW, while you HC Subhash Chand were carrying a 9 MM Pistol and a pair of handcuffs with you at that time. After negotiation you were settled the amount at Rs. 1.5 Lacs for his release and you HC Subhash Chand demanded Rs. 80,000/- on the spot for his release. Later, Complainant Vinod Khanna came to know that Rs. 50,000/- were taken by you HC Subhash Chand and others. You HC Subhash Chand gave Rs. 5000/- each to police personnel who were accompanying you. A scrutiny of call details of Sh. Sidhartha Sapra's mobile No. 9818840003 and the phone of you Ct. Ramesh chand indicates that you were in constant touch with Mr. Sidhartha Batra and had spoken on many occasions with each other on 16.6.07.

You, HC Subhash Chand posed yourself as an Inspector and kept the NBW with yourself. You returned the NBW through your son Manmeet Singh on 29.06.07 to Ct Ramesh Chand who later on handed it over to Sidhartha Sapra on that day. You HC Subhash Chand made your departure for outstation to Nagpur on 13.06.07 and made your arrival back on 18.6.07. It shows your dubious conduct and ill intention. Similarly you Ct. Ram Karan Meena made a departure for outstation to Haryana on 15.06.07 and did not come back till 26.06.07 and on that day you also made a departure for medical rest.

It has transpired that Sh Sidhartha Sapra had obtained dasti NBW against Sh Vinod Kumar Khanna on 16.01.07 in the name of SHO/Lajpat Nagar. He however did not deliver NBW at PS Lajpat Nagar and had connived with you HC Subhash Chand No. 315/DRP (now 67/DAP), with the help of you Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD, 399/Crime (now 1406/DAP). Subsequently you HC Subhash Chand then roped in HC Bhupinder Singh No. 319/DRP, 10247/DAP, 376/DRP (now Ct No. 1407/DAP) and Ct. Ram Karan No. 281/Crime (now 1408/DAP). All of you went to Faridabad Sh. Vinod Kumar Khanna where all of you extorted money from Sh. Vinod Kumar Khanna.

The above act on the part all of you (i) HC Subhash Chand No. 315/DRP, now 67/DAP (PIS No. 28801096), (ii) Ct. Bhupender Singh No. 319/DRP, 10297/DAP, 375/DRP, now 1407/DAP (PIS No. 28912253), (iii) Ct. Ram Karan No. 281/ Crime, now 1408/DAP (PIS No. 28932557) and (iv) Ct. Ramesh Kumar No. 672/SD, 399/Crime, now 1406/DAP (PIS No. 28931144) amounts to gross misconduct, lack of integrity, misuse of official position with the motive to extort money through undesirable means and an act unbecoming of police officer thereby violating the provisions of Rule 3 of CCS (conduct) Rules 1964 which is punishable u/s 21 of Delhi Police Act read with Delhi Police (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980.”

6.

The Enquiry Officer vide the aforesaid impugned report returned the findings that all the alleged misconduct stood proved against the applicant. Pursuant to receipt of the said Inquiry Report, the applicant submitted his written representation and thereafter the disciplinary authority has passed the impugned order dated 11.09.2013 (Annexure-A/2), inflicting punishment of forfeiture of four years of approved service permanently entailing reduction in the pay of the applicant. Statutory appeal of the applicant has been rejected by the Appellate Authority vide impugned appellate order dated 14.08.2014 (Annexure-A/3). Thus, the present O.A.

7.

Mr. Sachin Chauhan, learned counsel for the applicant has argued that in support of his claim, the applicant has pleaded various grounds, however, he, at this stage, presses only one ground that the impugned order dated 22.03.2011 (Annexure-A/1) initiating the departmental proceedings against the applicant and the subsequent impugned report of the IO and also the impugned orders passed by the disciplinary and appellate authorities are not sustainable in law, in view of the same being passed in violation of provisions of Rule 15 of Delhi Police (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980 (in short ‘the Rules of 1980’), however, learned counsel for the applicant submits that other grounds may be kept open.

8.

Learned counsel for the applicant has argued that the provisions contained in Rule 15 (1) & (2) of the Rules of 1980 define specifically the preliminary enquiry and also provide that where specific information is available, a preliminary enquiry is not necessary and a departmental enquiry may be ordered by the disciplinary authority straightaway. Learned counsel further argued that provisions of Rule 15 (2) of the Rules of 1980 provides that whenever a preliminary enquiry discloses the commission of a cognizable offence by a police officer of subordinate rank in their official relations with the public, a departmental enquiry shall only be ordered after obtaining the prior approval of the concerned Additional Commissioner of Police as to whether a criminal case should be registered and investigated and departmental enquiry should be held. Learned counsel explains that in the present case, admittedly, on receipt of complaint from aforesaid Mr. Khanna, the Commissioner of Police has ordered for strict disciplinary action and initiation of disciplinary action after suspension and for legal action to be taken against such concerned police personnel. However, after the preliminary enquiry report, admittedly, the approval for both the departmental enquiry as well as criminal prosecution has not been obtained by the respondents from the competent authority i.e., Additional Commissioner of Police has maintained Rule 15 (2) of the Rules of 1980, thus the impugned order dated 22.03.2011 (Annexure-A/1) for initiation of departmental enquiry by the Deputy Commissioner of Police is vitiated as having not been passed with the approval of the competent authority. Learned counsel has further argued that on receipt of the preliminary enquiry report, prior approval of Additional Commissioner of Police with due application of his mind is mandatory. In support of his argument, learned counsel for the applicant has placed reliance on the Judgment dated 23.02.2007 of Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal number 7212 of 2005 titled Vijay Singh Vs. Union of India and Ors.

8.

On the other hand, Mr. Virender Pratap Singh Charak, learned counsel for the respondents by referring to the assertions made in the counter reply filed by the respondents has vehemently opposed the claim of the applicant. However, he has not disputed that after receipt of the preliminary enquiry report, the approval for initiation of departmental enquiry and/or for prosecution case against the applicant was not obtained from the Additional Commissioner of Police. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Vijay Singh (supra) after reproducing the provisions of Rule 15 (1) & (2) of the Rules of 1980 has held as under:-

“To appreciate the present controversy in proper perspective Rule 15 (1) & (2) of the Rules are reproduced:

"15.

Preliminary enquiries (1) A preliminary enquiry is a fact finding enquiry. Its purpose is (i) to establish the nature of default and identity of defaulter (s), (ii) to collect prosecution evidence, (iii) to judge quantum of default and (iv) to bring relevant documents on record to facilitate a regular departmental enquiry. In cases where specific information covering the above-mentioned points exists a Preliminary Enquiry need not be held and Departmental enquiry may be ordered by the disciplinary authority straightaway. In all other cases, a preliminary enquiry shall normally precede a departmental enquiry.

(2)

In cases in which a preliminary enquiry discloses the commission of a cognizable offence by a police officer of subordinate rank in his official relations with the pubic, departmental enquiry shall be ordered after obtaining prior approval of the Additional Commissioner of Police concerned as to whether a criminal case should be registered and investigated or a departmental enquiry should be held".

A reading of Rule 15(1) & (2) together and the language employed therein clearly discloses that a preliminary enquiry is held only in cases of allegation, which is of weak character and, therefore, a preliminary enquiry is to be held to establish the nature of default and identity of defaulter; to collect the prosecution evidence; to judge quantum of default and to bring relevant documents on record to facilitate a regular departmental enquiry. In cases, where specific information is available, a preliminary enquiry is not necessary and a departmental enquiry may be ordered by the disciplinary authority straightaway. It is because of this reason sub-rule 2 of Rule 15 is couched in such a way as a defence to the delinquent officer. The Additional Commissioner of Police being higher in hierarchy next to DGP, the requirement of his approval is mandatory, so that the delinquent officer is not prejudiced or harassed unnecessarily in a departmental enquiry. Such approval, if any, must also be accorded after due application of mind. It is a case of violation of mandatory provisions of law. Therefore, the appeal must succeed. The appellant was dismissed by an order dated 21.1.1998 preceded by an enquiry. The order of dismissal is set aside. The appellant shall be re-instated forthwith. The orders of the Appellate Authority, the Revisional Authority and the High Court are set aside.”

9.

We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsels for the parties.

10.

It is not in dispute that though for suspension or legal action for disciplinary action and legal action, order was passed by the Commissioner of Police on the complaint received from the aforesaid Mr. Khanna and pursuant to such order, the preliminary enquiry was also got conducted, however, on receipt of preliminary enquiry report, admittedly, no prior approval was sought and/or obtained from the Additional Commissioner of Police for initiation of departmental enquiry against the applicant and/or criminal case against the applicant.

11.

In this regard, we may also note that it is settled law that if something is required to be done in a particular way, the same must be done in that manner only and/or not to be done at all. In this regard, we may place reliance on paragraph No.14 of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Opto Circuit India Limited Vs. Axis Bank & Others, reported in 2021 (6) SCC 707, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court held that if statute provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, then it should be done in that manner only and not in any other manner. Paragraph no. 14 of the said judgment is reproduced herein-below:-

“14.

This Court has time and again emphasised that if a statute provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in that manner alone and in no other manner. Among others, in a matter relating to the presentation of an election petition, as per the procedure prescribed under the Patna High Court Rules, this Court had an occasion to consider the Rules to find out as to what would be a valid presentation of an election petition in Chandra Kishore Jha v. Mahavir Prasad and in the course of consideration observed as hereunder: (SCC p. 273, para 17)

"17.

.. It is a well-settled salutary principle that if a statute provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in that manner and in no other manner."

12.

Similarly, the Hon’ble Apex Court in paragraph nos. 15 to 17 of the judgment in the case of Union of India & Others Vs. Mahendra Singh, reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 909, has held as under:-

“15.

A three Judge Bench of this Court in a judgment reported as Chandra Kishore Jha v. Mahavir Prasad held as under:

"17....It is a well-settled salutary principle that if a statute provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in that manner and in no other manner. (See with advantage: Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor [(1935-36) 63 IA 372: AIR 1936 PC 253 (2)], Rao Shiv Bahadur Singh v. State of V.P [AIR 1954 SC 322: 1954 SCR 1098], State of U.P. v. Singhara Singh [AIR 1964 SC 358: (1964) 1 SCWR 57].) An election petition under the rules could only have been presented in the open court up to 16-5-1995 till 4.15 p.m. (working hours of the Court) in the manner prescribed by Rule 6 (supra) either to the Judge or the Bench as the case may be to save the period of limitation. That, however, was not done

16.

The said principle has been followed by this Court in Cherukuri Mani v. Chief Secretary, Government of Andhra Pradesh wherein this Court held as under:

"14.

Where the law prescribes a thing to be done in a particular manner following a particular procedure, it shall be done in the same manner following the provisions of law, without deviating from the prescribed procedure."

17.

Similarly, this Court in Municipal Corporation of Greater Mambal (MCGM) v. Abhilash Lal and OPTO Circuit India Limited v. Axis Bank has followed the said principle. Since the advertisement contemplated the manner of filling up of the application form and also the attempting of the answer sheets, it has to be done in the manner so prescribed. Therefore, the reasoning given by the Division Bench of the High Court that on account of lapse of time, the writ petitioner might have attempted the answer sheet in a different language is not justified as the use of different language itself disentitles the writ petitioner from any indulgence in exercise of the power of judicial review.”

13.

In the light of what has been held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Vijay Singh (supra) as well as in the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to above, we are of the considered view that the impugned order dated 22.03.2011 (Annexure-A/1) and subsequent impugned enquiry report and impugned orders of penalty are not sustainable in the eyes of law and accordingly, the same deserve to be set aside.

14.

In light of the aforesaid, the present O.A. is allowed in the following terms:-

i.

Impugned order dated 11.09.2013 (Annexure-A/2) passed by the Disciplinary Authority and order dated 14.08.2014 (Annexure-A/3) passed by the Appellate Authority are quashed and set aside;

ii.

The applicant shall be entitled for all consequential benefits;

iii.

The aforesaid directions shall be complied with by the respondents, as expeditiously as possible, and preferably within eight weeks from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.

15.

Ordinarily, keeping in view of the settled position of law, we would have accorded liberty to the respondents to initiate departmental enquiry against the applicant, if they so decide, in accordance with law, however, since the allegations levelled against the applicant relate to the year 2007 and the applicant is stated to have retired in the year 2019 i.e., more than seven years back, we are of the considered view that the matter deserves to be put to a quietus and we order accordingly.

16.

There shall be no order as to cost.

17.

Pending M.A., if any, shall also stand disposed of accordingly.

18.

Original records produced by the respondents have been returned to them as received.