Javid Ahmad Sheikh & Ors. Vs UT of J&K & Ors.
Central Administrative Tribunal · Srinagar · 22 Sept 2026 · M.S. Latif, Member (Judl.) · Prasant Kumar, Member (Adm.)
Judgment
Per M.S.Latif - Member (J) oral
01/ Through the medium of this petition, the petitioners have, inter alia, sought the following reliefs :
“The Hon’ble court may be pleased to direct the respondents to implement the judgment of the Hon'ble Division Bench dated 26.07.2024 passed in WP(C) No. 220/2024 and WP(C) No. 798/2024 and its implementation order dated 10.09.2025 in respect of the petitioners as well and grant them all benefits extended to similarly situated employees. Further direction is sought to direct the respondents to release all withheld salaries of the petitioners from 2017 till date along with interest and direct them to continue the petitioners in service on regular establishment with all consequential service benefits including annual increments, promotional benefits, and all other entitlement besides the respondents be also directed to comply with all earlier orders passed by the Hon'ble High Court and this Hon'ble Tribunal including orders passed in contempt proceedings in favour of the petitioners. The petitioners have also sought a direction, as an interim measure, that pending final hearing and disposal of this O.A, the respondents be directed to release at least 50% of the withheld salaries of the petitioners on interim basis to enable them to meet their basic livelihood requirements and stay any adverse action including termination, removal, dismissal or any other prejudicial action against the petitioners during the pendency of this petition.”
02/ What emerges from the pleadings in this OA is that the petitioners are aggrieved of the arbitrary, discriminatory and illegal inaction of the respondents in withholding their salary and consequential service benefits since the year 2017 and in denying them parity with similarly situated employees, despite they having been appointed by competent authorities between 1998 and 2008 and, subsequently, regularized in the year 2008, and having continuously served the Health & Medical Education Department for nearly two decades.
03/ Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners were appointed as Sweepers by competent authorities, including the concerned Chief Medical Officer, under the rules and procedure prevailing at the relevant point of time. Their services were regularized in 2008 after years of satisfactory service and the Department itself, vide its communication No. DHSK/Estt-II/648-51 dated 22.05.2013, clarified that the concerned employees were not fake appointees but had been erroneously enlisted in the fake list. Learned counsel submits that despite the official clarification and the continued service of the petitioners, their salaries have remained withheld from 2017. He submits that they have also been the beneficiaries of various orders passed by the Hon'ble High Court and this Hon'ble Tribunal, including orders passed in contempt proceedings, directing their continuation in service and release of their legitimate dues. However, the respondents have failed to extend the benefit of the said orders in their true spirit.
05/ Main grievance of the petitioners, projected in this petition, is that in view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Division Bench issued in WP(C) No. 220/2024, U.T of J&K versus Tawseef Ahmad Mantoo & others, pursuant to which the respondents issued an Implementation Order dated 10.09.2025 in favour of similarly situated employees, but the petitioners, being identically situated, have been singled out without any rational or intelligible basis, though they are entitled to the same treatment, being placed on the same pedestal.
06/ Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners, in this regard, repeatedly approached the respondents by way of representations dated 15.10.2025, 15.02.2026 and 15.06.2026, requesting implementation of the judicial directions, release of withheld salary and extension of the same benefits granted to similarly situated employees but the respondents have failed to consider and decide the said representations. He submits that continued withholding of salary, non-implementation of judicial directions and denial of parity, despite the petitioners’ long and satisfactory service and the Department's own clarification regarding their status, is arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of their legal and constitutional rights, as such, they are left with no efficacious alternative remedy except to invoke the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble court, seeking appropriate directions for implementation of the judicial orders, extension of parity with similarly situated employees and release of their withheld salary and consequential benefits. The petitioners’ have prayed that the respondents be directed to extend to them the benefit of the judgment in WP(C) No. 220/2024 and Implementation Order dated 10.09.2025, maintain their continuity/regular status in service, and release their salary arrears and consequential benefits withheld since 2017.
07/ Learned counsel for the petitioners further submitted that the petitioners’ after rendering several years of continuous and satisfactory service, were brought on to the regular establishment of the department through a formal regularization process and in recognition of their longstanding service and satisfactory performance and they have been serving the department for a cumulative period of nearly two decades. Learned counsel submits that during this entire extended tenure, no question was raised about the propriety, legality, or validity of their appointments. The appointments of the petitioners’ stood the test of time and were accepted and acted upon by all concerned authorities without any objection. However, at some stage, certain appointments in the department came under scrutiny and a list of allegedly fake and irregular appointments was prepared by respondents and, mistakenly, the petitioners’ found their names included in such list of fake appointments despite the fact that their appointments were entirely genuine, regular, and proper in all respects. However, after thorough verification, the department issued Communication No. DHSK/Estt-II/648-51 dated 22.05.2013, explicitly and categorically clearing the petitioners, amongst others, that they were not fake appointees but had been erroneously enlisted in the fake list of appointments, thus, as stated, the communication aforesaid constitutes official vindication of the petitioners appointments and establishes conclusively that their appointments were genuine, regular, and proper. Learned counsel further submits that the petitioners are similarly circumstanced with the petitioners in WP(C) No. 220/2024 supra, whereunder relief has been granted to the petitioners therein, and, as such, petitioners herein cannot be denied the same treatment if it has been granted to the similarly placed others.
08/ Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that notwithstanding the aforesaid departmental vindication in 2013, the respondent authorities arbitrarily and illegally withheld the salaries of the petitioners from the year 2017 without issuing any proper order and without providing any justification or reason and without affording any opportunity of hearing to the petitioners, depriving them and their families of their sole source of livelihood and causing them immense financial hardships and distress.
08/ Be that as it may, after arguing for a considerable period of time, learned counsel for the petitioners fairly submitted that the petitioners would be satisfied if the respondents are directed to treat this petition as comprehensive representation on their behalf and decide the same along with the representations, filed by them earlier, within a stipulated period.
09/ Learned counsel for the respondents submits that he has no objection if this petition is disposed of with appropriate directions, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the respondents.
10/ Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available on record.
11/ Having regard to the limited prayer made by learned counsel for the petitioners and without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, this OA 1036/2026, as requested, is disposed of with the direction to the respondents to treat this petition together with all documents and annexures appended thereto as well as the representation, filed by the petitioners earlier, as a comprehensive representation on their behalf and decide the same by passing a reasoned and speaking order in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions, rules and governing legal framework, of course, subject to their eligibility and entitlement under law. Needful to be done within a period of four weeks’ to be reckoned from the date a certified copy of this judgement and copy of this O.A is served upon the respondents.
12/ In the backdrop of what has been discussed above, this O.A 1036/2026 is disposed of along with connected M.As, if any.
