Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 09 CAT CK 7078

Ghulam Mohi Ud Din Mir Vs Union Territory Of Jammu & Kashmir & Anr.

Central Administrative Tribunal · Srinagar · 23 Sept 2026 · M.S. Latif, Member (Judl.)

Open full page

Judgment

12 paragraphs · 1,044 words

M.S.LATIF, M (J) oral

01/ Through the medium of this petition, the petitioner has sought the following relief :

“The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to direct the non-applicants to consider the representation of the applicant dated 24.12.2025 by granting the benefit of regularization retrospectively from back date to the services of applicant as Chowkidar ( Class-IV) on the same analogy as has been done in case of Suheela Aziz and Manzoor Ahamd Dar and release all consequential benefits in favour of the applicant on account of such consideration and consider his on the strength of and on the analogy of Order No. 265/DSEK of 2022 dated 06.04.2022 passed in case of Manzoor Ahmad Dar V/s State and Ors and accordingly maintain the seniority of applicant as Teachers on the basis of his retrospective regularization. The petitioner has further sought a direction as an interim measure that pending final decision on this O.A, the respondents be directed to consider the representation/s of the applicant by passing a speaking order on the analogy of Order No. 265/DSEK of 2022 dated 06.04.2022 passed in case of Manzoor Ahmad Dar V/S State and others.”

02/ The short grievance of the petitioner, as emerges from the pleadings in this O.A, is that he was appointed as Chowkidar on leave arrangement in the School Education Department and is aggrieved of non-consideration of his representation dated 24.12.2025, seeking benefit of regularization retrospectively from back date.

03/ Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner has been deprived of the benefit of regularization, though similarly situated candidates namely Suheela Aziz and Manzoor Ahmad Dar, have been regularized by the respondents. The petitioner, while seeking enforcement of his legal, constitutional and statutory rights, has averred in the petition that he was initially appointed on Leave Arrangement Vacancy of Chowkidar, which was subsequently extended from time to time and he continued to discharge his duties on the said arrangement/vacancy for a long time. Learned counsel submitted that apprehending that his services may not be allowed to continue despite approval granted by the competent authorities, the petitioner, in terms of various representations and writ petition sought indulgence of the Hon'ble High Court for his continuation and the Hon'ble High Court by virtue of order 15/07/1993 passed direction to the respondents to allow the petitioner to continue and discharge his duties. Learned counsel submitted that the petitioner continued to perform his duties right from 04/03/1993 without any break.

04/ Learned counsel submitted that in the year 2010, the State Legislature enacted the J&K Civil Service (Special Provisions) Act, 2010. The said Act was made applicable from 24.04.2010 and the petitioner was brought within its preview and his services were regularized accordingly by issuance of regularization order bearing Government Order No. 620-Edu of 2012 dated 02/08/2012. However, due to some adverse consequences which followed against the petitioner after his regularization, he was constrained to file writ petition before the Hon'ble High Court with some other similarly situated candidates, who also approached to the Hon'ble High Court through the medium of various writ petitions and one such petition was filed by Suheela Aziz which has been allowed and the said candidate has been granted the benefit of regularization retrospectively with effect from the date she became eligible for the said regularization. Learned counsel submitted that the benefit of judgment passed in case titled Suheela Aziz Versus State of J&K and others in LPAW NO. 133/2002 was extended to other similarly situated candidates including Manzoor Ahmad Dar who was also granted the same treatment and benefit on the same analogy in terms of order No. 265/DSEK of 2022, dated 06.04.2022.

05/ The grievance of the petitioner herein, as stated, is that, he has not been given the same treatment as has been permitted in case of Suheela Aziz and Manzoor Ahmad Dar, as such, he approached the respondents by way of a fresh representation dated 24.12.2025, seeking similar treatment/benefit as has been granted to his counterparts aforementioned. It is submitted that since the petitioner had filed various representations seeking regularization even before passing of the Act of 2010, and has also filed some more representations seeking same treatment and benefit as has been granted to Suheela Aziz and Jahan Ara, Zafar ul lah Shah and Manzoor Ahmad Dar, but, to his amazement, the respondent department has miserably failed to consider the representations of the petitioner by playing delaying tactics and, as stated, they have granted the benefit to others purely on pick and choose basis and discriminated the petitioner without any justifiable cause, which is violative of the Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

06/ Be that as it may, after arguing the matter for a considerable period of time, learned counsel for the petitioner fairly submitted that the petitioner would be satisfied if the respondents are directed to treat this petition as comprehensive representation of the petitioner and decide the same as expeditiously as possible in accordance with law.

07/ Learned counsel appearing for the respondents submit that he has no objection if the present O.A is disposed of with appropriate directions, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the respondents.

08/ Heard learned counsel for the parties at length, perused the material available on record.

09/ Having regard to the limited and innocuous prayer made by learned counsel for the petitioner and without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, the present O.A is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to treat this petition together with all documents and annexures appended thereto as well as the representations, if any filed by the petitioner earlier, as a comprehensive representation and consider and decide the averments put forth therein by passing a reasoned and speaking order in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions, rules and governing legal framework, of course, subject to the petitioner’s eligibility and entitlement under law and provided there is no legal impediment in doing so. Needful to be done within a period of six weeks from the date a certified copy of this order and copy of this O.A is served upon the respondents.

10/ In the backdrop of what has been discussed above, this O.A 1050/2026 is disposed of along with connected M.As, if any.