Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2020) 01 RERA CK 1832

Daya Ram Yadav Vs A Common Land Welfare Society

Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · 09 Jan 2020 · Ramesh Chandra, Member · G.P. Srivastava, Member · Vijay S Madan, Chairman

Open full page

Judgment

6 paragraphs · 908 words
1.

This is a complaint filed u/s 31 of Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 herein called 'Act' by the Complainant, Sh. Daya Ram Yadav on 23.04.2019 against "A Common Land Welfare Society" a Society registered under the Societies' Registration Act, 1860 with its office at 44-F, Ground Floor, Ward No.9, Kishan Garh, New Delhi-110070. The Complainant has submitted that he is a teacher in Govt. Boys Sr. Secondary School, Khanpur, New Delhi and is a resident of 77, Sai Complex, Chhattarpur Enclave, New Delhi where he resides with his family of seven members. The Complainant has represented that Respondent Society which is registered under Societies Registration Act, 1860 bearing Registration No.S-1769-District South-2014, published an advertisement in February, 2015 in which it was claimed amongst other things that DDA had approved and notified the Land Pooling Policy (LPP) for the Planning Zone of the Zone-L and that the Respondent Society has a Real Estate project by the brand name 'Har Ghar' proposed in Dwarka under the policy. The Complainant has submitted that relying on the advertisement, and the brochure (annexed as Annexure C-1) giving details of the apartment, the Complainant had deposited an amount of Rs.1,99,980/- with the Respondent Society. It was submitted by the Complainant that the Respondent promised to complete the Project by the year 2019 and since the Project had not even started, for long, he asked for a refund from the Society. It was further submitted by the Complainant that the Respondent in pursuance to his request and persuasion for refund issued a cheque (no. 000038 dated 28.02.2017 drawn on HDFC Bank) for Rs.1,88,980/- in February 2017 after deducting Rs.11,000/- as membership charges. It was further alleged that upon presentation for encashment, the above referred cheque for Rs.1,88,980/- bounced with the remarks of 'Insufficient Funds'. Copy of such remarks from the Dena Bank dt.03.03.3017 and 11.05.2017 were annexed with the complaint. He further submitted that as Respondent did not reply to his request for refund, he filed this complaint before this Authority.

2.

After hearing the Complainant, a notice was issued to the Respondent on 16.07.2019. Pursuant to the notice, Sh. Jagdish Kumar, representing Sh. Mahabir Singh, President of the Society appeared on 23.08.2019, and requested for some time to file a detailed reply to the Show Cause Notice. A reply to the Show Cause Notice to the complaint was subsequently filed on 06.09.2019 and a submission was made that the Respondent is exploring the possibility of amicable settlement and requested for 3-4 month's time to make the payment. The President of the Society, Sh. Mahabir Singh appeared in person on 16.10.2019 and submitted that he is ready to make the payment and requested for time until 20 November 2019 to do so. Accordingly, the matter was listed on 26.11.2019. However, on 26.11.2019, Sh. Mahabir Singh, President of the Society did not appear. With a view to provide another opportunity of hearing, the case was adjourned for 10.12.2019, but the Respondent did not appear on 10.12.2019. The Counsel for Complainant, Sh. Praful Jindal has submitted that the Respondent has filed the reply to the complaint and this may be decided on the basis of reply filed by the Respondent as they are not appearing despite service of notices.

3.

Heard the Counsel for the Complainant and perused the record. Without going into the merits of the case regarding functioning of Society or their membership issue and other things which are related to their completion of Real Estate Project, we are considering only the submission made by the Respondent himself in the reply for refund of amount.

4.

It is an admitted case that the Complainant had paid a sum of Rs.1,99,980/- to the Society and Society has admitted that the payment was received by the Society and that on the request of the Complainant, the Respondent had issued a cheque for Rs.1,88,980/- as refund after deducting Rs.11,000/- towards the membership fee and the amount of Rs.1,88,980/- was settled between the parties as the refund amount. This fact is also mentioned in Para-2 of the reply and submission made by the Respondent. On presentation to the Bank for encashment, the said cheque had bounced due to 'Insufficient Funds'. In the prayer clause of reply dt.06.09.2019 filed by Respondent, the Respondent requested this Authority to grant 03/04 months time to pay the said deposited amount to the Complainant. This reply was submitted by Sh. Mahabir Singh, President of the Society supported with affidavit dt.05.09.2019. The President of the Society appeared before this Authority on 16.10.2019 and during the proceedings, he submitted that he wanted to proceed for an amicable settlement by 20 November 2019 but subsequently he did not appear for the last two occasions and despite having been provided ample opportunities for hearing.

5.

In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case, it is clearly an admitted case of refund of Rs.1,88,980/-. The Respondent Society has admitted to the refund and submitted that it is ready to refund as per their prayer clause in the reply itself. Therefore, we are of the view that ends of justice would be met if a direction is issued to the Respondent Society to refund a sum of Rs.1,88,980/- (Rupees One Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand Nine Hundred Eighty only) as a settled amount to the Complainant within a period of 45 days from the date of issue of this order.

No order as to costs.