Ankit Chaudhary Vs The Chairman, Staff Selection Commission & Anr.
Central Administrative Tribunal · Principal Bench, New Delhi · 22 Oct 2026 · Manish Garg, Member (J) · Anand S Khati, Member (A)
Judgment
By Hon’ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J):
Since the issues involved in the present batch of Original Applications are similar and arise out of the rejection of the candidature of the applicants at different stages of the recruitment process for the post of Civil Motor Driver (Ordinary Grade), Post Code NR32623, advertised under Phase-XI/2023, the same were being taken up together for hearing and are now being disposed of through this common order with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
The individual Original Applications, however, involve certain peculiar discrepancies relating to the particulars furnished in the online application forms vis-à-vis the supporting documents produced by the applicants during the stage of Document Verification and scrutiny.
The principal issues raised in the present batch of OAs, inter alia, include discrepancies in the dates and period of experience, mismatch in the name of the employer or organisation, variation in the particulars of educational institutions, discrepancy in the roll number mentioned in the Class X certificate, and differences in the particulars relating to the nature of employment.
In O.A. No. 327/2026, the issue relates to a discrepancy between the period of experience mentioned in the application form and that reflected in the supporting documents.
In O.A. No. 343/2026, the discrepancy concerns the dates of the relevant period of experience.
In O.A. No. 468/2026, the applicant is stated to have mentioned the school in the application form differently from the particulars appearing in the experience certificate.
In O.A. No. 731/2026, the discrepancy pertains to the commencement date of experience mentioned in the online application form vis-à-vis the experience certificate.
In O.A. No. 741/2026, the issue concerns a mismatch in the roll number mentioned in the Class X certificate.
In O.A. No. 742/2026, the discrepancy relates to a mismatch in the name of the organisation mentioned in the online application form vis--à-vis the relevant supporting document.
In O.A. No. 743/2026, the issue concerns a mismatch in the name of the organisation mentioned in the online application form and the experience certificate.
In O.A. No. 744/2026, the discrepancy relates to the description of the employer or nature of employment in the application form vis-à-vis the experience certificate.
In O.A. No. 745/2026, the issue concerns discrepancies in the name of the organisation and the dates mentioned in the application form and the experience certificate.
In O.A. No. 2459/2026, the applicant challenges rejection at the stage of scrutiny on the ground of an alleged mismatch in the name of the organisation and the dates, notwithstanding the experience certificates relied upon by the applicant.
The remaining matters in the present batch also arise from the rejection of candidature on account of discrepancies in the particulars furnished in the application forms and the supporting documents.
The common thread running through the arguments advanced by learned counsel for the applicants is that the rejection of applicants candidature on account of discrepancies in the particulars furnished in the online application forms vis-à-vis the supporting documents is unjustified, particularly where, according to them, such discrepancies are inadvertent in nature and do not affect their substantive eligibility for the post.
Learned counsel contended that the applicants possessed the requisite driving experience and other prescribed qualifications as on the crucial date, and that the supporting certificates produced by them sufficiently establish the same.
It is applicants’ case that variations in the name of the employer or organization, the particulars of the educational institution, or the dates and period of experience ought not to have resulted in rejection of candidature without examining whether such discrepancies had any material bearing upon the fulfillment of the prescribed eligibility conditions.
According to learned counsel for the applicants, the respondents have adopted an unduly technical approach by treating such discrepancies as fatal, without appreciating the distinction between an inadvertent error in an application form and a material misrepresentation affecting eligibility.
The principal contention advanced on behalf of the applicants is that they are not seeking any relaxation of the essential qualifications, any alteration of the eligibility criteria, or the benefit of experience acquired after the crucial date. Rather, they seek consideration of their candidature on the basis of the qualifications and experience which, according to them, they already possessed and which are reflected in the supporting documents submitted by them.
It was submitted that the relevant clauses of the recruitment notice, particularly Clauses 10.5 and 11.8, ought to be construed harmoniously and applied in a manner that takes into account the nature and consequence of the discrepancy in each case. Learned counsel accordingly contended that, where the underlying documents are genuine and the prescribed eligibility requirement is otherwise satisfied, an inadvertent or clerical error should not automatically lead to rejection of candidature unless the discrepancy is found to affect substantive eligibility or the fairness of the selection process.
In support of these submissions, learned counsel for the applicants have placed reliance upon the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vashist Narayan Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2024) 11 SCC 785 : 2024 INSC 2, and Divya v. Union of India, (2024) 1 SCC 448 as well as the judgment of the High Court of Delhi in Ajay Kumar Mishra v. Union of India, 2016 SCC OnLine Del 6553. Reliance has also been placed upon Rohit Gami v. Union of India through the Chairman, Staff Selection Commission and Others, W.P. No. 19419/2020, decided on 25.03.2026 by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. The aforesaid decisions are relied upon by learned counsel to support their contention that the nature and effect of a discrepancy in a recruitment application must be examined in the context of the applicable eligibility conditions and the supporting material on record, and that an inadvertent error having no material bearing upon substantive eligibility ought to be distinguished from a misrepresentation which affects a candidate’s entitlement to participate in the selection process.
Learned counsel have further referred to Reena Rani v. Union of India, O.A. No. 1409/2021, decided by this Tribunal on 27.09.2022; Union of India v. Sunil Kumar, W.P. (C) No. 4829/2017; and Girish Kumar Sharma v. Union of India and Others, W.P. (C) No. 5719/2023, decided on 08.04.2026, in support of their submissions concerning the treatment of discrepancies in recruitment particulars.
Reference has also been made to Food Corporation of India v. Rajiv Kumar, cited in the written submissions as (2019) 5 SCC 793, and MPSC v. Sandeep Shrivastava, cited as (2019) 6 SCC 362. The judgment in Nisha Khan v. Delhi Police and Another, W.P. (C) No. 12698/2023, decided on 12.12.2025, has also been referred to in the context of the distinction between a discrepancy that affects substantive eligibility and one that is merely technical in nature.
The learned counsel for the applicants sought to distinguish cases in which an incorrect entry results in an impermissible claim to an eligibility benefit or relaxation from the present cases, where their contention is that the prescribed experience was independently possessed on the crucial date. Thus, the common submission of learned counsel is that the impugned rejections ought not to be sustained merely on account of a mismatch in the particulars furnished in the online application forms, without examining the nature of the discrepancy, the genuineness and contents of the supporting documents, and its actual impact, if any, upon the applicants’ eligibility under the recruitment notice. It was, therefore, urged that the candidature of each applicant be considered in the light of the applicable eligibility conditions and the documents placed on record and further prayed that the impugned orders rejecting applicants’ candidature be set aside and the respondents be directed to consider their candidature for the post of Civil Motor Driver (Ordinary Grade), in accordance with the applicable recruitment conditions and the documents placed on record, by treating the discrepancies in question as inadvertent and non-material, wherever the same do not affect substantive eligibility.
Per contra, the common submission of learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents was that the rejection of the applicants’ candidature, wherever warranted on account of discrepancies in the particulars furnished in their online application forms vis-à-vis the relevant supporting documents, is in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Notice of Examination.
It was contended that the particulars furnished by a candidate in the online application form are material for the purposes of verification of identity, educational qualifications and eligibility, and that the candidature remains provisional until the requisite particulars and supporting documents are duly verified.
Mere participation in the examination or securing marks above the prescribed cut-off does not confer any vested right upon a candidate to be selected or appointed, particularly where a discrepancy affecting the correctness or verification of the declared particulars is subsequently noticed.
Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the Commission is required to apply the conditions stipulated in the Notice of Examination uniformly to all candidates in order to maintain fairness, transparency and the sanctity of the recruitment process.
It was argued that candidates are expected to furnish correct and complete particulars in their application forms and that an error cannot be treated as merely clerical or typographical in nature solely because the candidate claims it to have been inadvertent.
According to the respondents, the materiality of a discrepancy must be assessed with reference to the particular information involved and its relevance to identity verification, registration records, educational qualifications or the prescribed eligibility conditions. Where the discrepancy concerns an essential or material particular, the respondents contended that its acceptance or correction after submission of the application cannot be permitted in a manner inconsistent with the Notice of Examination or so as to confer an impermissible relaxation upon an individual candidate.
It was further submitted that the opportunity, if any, provided under the recruitment notice for correction of particulars must be availed of in accordance with the prescribed procedure and within the stipulated period.
A candidate cannot, according to the respondents, claim an unrestricted right to rectify material discrepancies at a subsequent stage, particularly during or after Document Verification, when the terms of the recruitment process do not permit such correction. The respondents maintained their stand that treating materially incorrect particulars as inconsequential merely on the assertion that the candidate otherwise fulfils the eligibility criteria would undermine uniform application of the recruitment conditions and may result in unequal treatment of similarly situated candidates.
With regard to the judgments relied upon by the applicants, the learned counsel for the respondents contended that the applicability of each decision must be examined in the light of the facts of the case in which it was rendered, the nature of the discrepancy involved and the relevant conditions of the recruitment notice. It was submitted that a judgment concerning an inadvertent error which does not affect substantive eligibility cannot automatically be applied to a case involving an incorrect or inconsistent declaration of a material particular necessary for establishing identity or verifying eligibility. The respondents accordingly maintaineded their stand that the decisions cited by the applicants do not dispense with the obligation to furnish correct particulars or confer a general right to have discrepancies rectified after the prescribed stage of the selection process.
The respondents thus contended that the impugned decisions cannot be characterized as arbitrary, disproportionate or hyper-technical merely because the applicants dispute the materiality of the discrepancies noticed in their respective cases. According to learned counsel, each candidature is required to be assessed in accordance with the applicable recruitment conditions and the material available on record, and where a discrepancy is found to be material and inconsistent with the prescribed requirements, rejection of candidature is justified. On these grounds, the respondents opposed the relief sought in the respective Original Applications and prayed that the same be dismissed.
Learned counsel for the respondents have also placed reliance upon the judgment dated 30.04.2026 passed by the Principal Bench of this Tribunal in Shivayti Chaudhary v. Staff Selection Commission & Others, O.A. No. 641/2025. Relying upon the said decision, it was contended that the correctness of the particulars furnished by a candidate in the online application form is material to the recruitment process and that a discrepancy affecting the verification of identity or eligibility cannot be treated as a mere clerical or typographical error in every case. The respondents submitted that the candidature of an applicant remains subject to verification of the particulars declared in the application form and that mere participation in the examination or securing marks above the prescribed cut-off does not, by itself, confer any right to selection or appointment. It was further contended that the conditions stipulated in the Notice of Examination are required to be applied uniformly to all candidates and that a material discrepancy cannot be permitted to be rectified at a subsequent stage in a manner contrary to the prescribed recruitment procedure. On this basis, the respondents sought to sustain the impugned rejection of candidature in cases where, upon examination of the relevant facts and documents, the discrepancy is found to affect a material particular or the verification of eligibility.
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties and perused the pleadings available on record.
6. ANALYSIS :
The discrepancies or errors that occurred in the particulars furnished by the applicants in their respective online application forms are not in dispute. The nature of such discrepancies, as emerging from the pleadings and the material placed on record, is summarized in the tabular chart below:
| Sl. No. | O.A. No. (Year) | Brief Description of the Issue Involved |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | O.A. No. 327/2026 | Mismatch in the period of experience: the online application form mentions 15.12.2018 to 28.02.2023, whereas the experience certificate reflects 01.06.2018 to 26.12.2022. |
| 2. | O.A. No. 343/2026 | Mismatch in the period of experience: the online application form mentions 11.12.2016 to 21.12.2023, whereas the supporting documents reflect 11.12.2016 to 21.12.2022. | |
| 3. | O.A. No. 468/2026 | The online application form mentions “School”, whereas the experience certificate mentions “Vijay Bal Niketan Senior Secondary School, Amarapura (Shahpura), Jaipur”. | |
| 4. | O.A. No. 474/2026 | The applicant possessed the requisite driving experience with Vaidik Inter College from 01.04.2019 to 20.12.2022, but inadvertently entered the end date as 22.12.2022 in the online application form. The candidature was rejected at the Document Verification stage on account of this date discrepancy. | |
| 5. | O.A. No. 731/2026 | Mismatch in the period of experience: the online application form mentions 04.09.2019 to 11.12.2022, whereas the experience certificate reflects 04.10.2019 to 11.12.2022. | |
| 6. | O.A. No. 741/2026 | Mismatch in the Class X roll number: the online application form mentions 0033059, whereas the original document reflects 0033069. | |
| 7. | O.A. No. 742/2026 | Mismatch in the name of the organisation: the online application form mentions “School”, whereas the experience certificate mentions “Zenith Children’s Academy”. | |
| 8. | O.A. No. 743/2026 | Mismatch in the name of the organisation: the online application form mentions “School”, whereas the experience certificate mentions “Heritage High School”. | |
| 9. | O.A. No. 744/2026 | Mismatch in the name of the organisation: the online application form mentions “Transport”, whereas the experience certificate mentions “Dugdh Utpadak Sahkari Samiti”. | |
| 10. | O.A. No. 745/2026 | Mismatch in the name of the organisation and the period of experience: the online application form mentions “School” and the period 25.07.2018 to 30.04.2022, whereas the experience certificate refers to Swamy Nityanand Uchch Madhyamik Vidyalaya and the period 25.08.2019 to 30.08.2022. | |
| 11. | O.A. No. 1861/2026 | The applicant possessed driving experience with S.S. Public School, Shahzadpur, from 26.02.2020 to 28.02.2023, as certified by the employer. However, the experience period was inadvertently entered in the online application form as 01.05.2022 to 28.02.2023, instead of the actual period. | |
| 12. | O.A. No. 1976/2026 | Discrepancy in the name of the organisation mentioned in the online application form vis-à-vis the experience certificate; the applicant claims to have entered “ECP” instead of “NCP Shiksha Samiti”, while asserting that the requisite driving experience was possessed. | |
| 13. | O.A. No. 2459/2026 | The applicant relies upon experience certificates said to establish continuous and cumulative driving experience exceeding the prescribed minimum; however, the candidature was rejected on the stated ground of “Organisation and Date Mismatch”. |
The aforesaid tabular chart reveals that the discrepancies in several cases pertain to the particulars of the organization or employer mentioned in the column relating to experience, wherein, instead of furnishing the complete name of the organization, the applicants have mentioned only the generic expressions “School”, “Transport” or “ organisation” “ date” other incomplete particulars. In certain other cases, the discrepancies relate to the period of experience, including variations in the dates or years mentioned in the online application forms vis-à-vis those reflected in the experience certificates.
We have examined the records of the respective cases and find that the applicants have relied upon supporting documents containing the relevant particulars of their experience, including the name of the organization and the period of employment. The applicants contend that these documents were also uploaded along with their respective online application(s) and no new document is relied upon. The nature of the discrepancies and the contents of the supporting documents, therefore, require consideration in light of the applicable eligibility conditions and the relevant provisions of the recruitment notice.
In order to determine whether the furnishing of complete and accurate particulars in all the prescribed fields of the online application form, in the manner stipulated under the recruitment notice, is mandatory or merely directory in nature, it would be appropriate to examine the relevant clauses of the advertisement governing the submission and verification of applications.
Accordingly, it is necessary to refer to the relevant instructions and conditions prescribed in the application form and the Notice of Examination, which regulate the manner in which candidates are required to furnish the requisite particulars and the consequences of any error, omission or discrepancy therein. The relevant provisions are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:
“9.3.Before applying for the post, the candidates must ensure that they possess the Essential Qualifications including Experience wherever it is prescribed as Essential Qualification and also meet the age-limit as on the crucial date mentioned in Para 9.2 above.
9.5.For posts where experience in a particular field/ discipline for a specified period has been indicated as an Essential Qualification, the applicants must fill the relevant column of the online Application Form and also shall submit self-attested copy of relevant certificates in support of their claim of possession of Experience in that field/ discipline from the Competent Authority along with the print out of the online Application Form, as and when called for by the Commission after the conduct of Computer Based Examination failing which their candidature shall be rejected.
9.6.Selection will be strictly as per Recruitment Rules of the post. It may be noted by the candidates that Equivalency will not be allowed in case it is not mentioned in the prescribed EQ for any category of post in the Notice. In case Equivalency is allowed in the Recruitment Rules, it is the responsibility of the candidates to submit the necessary Documents/ Certificates (Order/ Letter with Number & Date) in support of equivalence, issued by the Government of India/ State Government or by the Competent Authority, as mentioned in the post details against the particular category(ies) of post(s) in the notice, from which he/she obtained the Educational Qualification, failing which his/her application shall be rejected.
10.2.Applications must be submitted in online mode only at the official website of SSC Headquarters i.e. https://ssc.nic.in. For detailed instructions, please refer to Annexure-IV and Annexure-V of this Notice.
10.6.Candidates should apply only once for one category of post.
10.7.After successful submission of online application, candidates must take a printout of the application form for submitting the same along with the requisite documents, duly self-attested, as and when called for by the Commission after the conduct of Computer Based Examination.
10.8.The information furnished by the candidates in their applications will be verified by the Commission with reference to the original documents during the Document Verification. During verification of documents, if it is found that any information furnished by the candidate in the application is wrong, his/ her candidature will be rejected forthwith. The candidates should ensure that they have furnished correct information in the application form.
12. Window for Application Form Correction [20.06.2022 till 24.06.2022 (23:00 PM)]
12.1.After the closing date for receipt of online applications, the Commission will provide a period of 5 days to enable candidates to correct/ modify online application parameters, wherein candidates will be allowed to re-submit applications after making requisite corrections/ changes in the onetime registration/ online application data as per their requirement.
12.2.A candidate will be allowed to correct and re-submit his modified/ corrected application two times during the ‘Window for Application Form Correction’ i.e. if he/she has made mistake in his updated application also, he/she will be allowed to resubmit one more modified/ corrected application after making requisite corrections/ modifications. No more corrections in the application form will be allowed under any circumstances.
12.3.Only those candidates will be allowed to make corrections in the application form, whose completed online applications along-with payment of requisite fee, have been received by the Commission within the specified period.
12.4.Latest modified application will be treated as the valid one and the previous application(s) submitted by such candidates will be ignored.
12.5.The Commission will levy a uniform correction charges of ₹ 200/- for making correction and resubmitting modified/ corrected application for the first time and ₹ 500/- for making correction and re-submitting modified/ corrected application for the second time. The correction charges will be applicable to all candidates irrespective of their gender/ categories.
12.6.The correction charges can be paid only by online mode through BHIM UPI, Net Banking or by using Visa, Mastercard, Maestro, RuPay Credit or Debit cards.
12.7.The correction charges once paid shall not be refunded under any circumstances nor will it be adjusted against any other examination or selection.
12.8.Before submission of the corrected application, candidates must check that they have filled correct details in each field of the form. After expiry of ‘Window for Application Form Correction’, no change/ correction/ modification will be allowed under any circumstances. Requests received in this regard in any form like Post, Fax, Email, by hand, etc. shall not be entertained by the Commission and will be summarily rejected.
15.2.The Commission will not undertake detailed scrutiny of applications for the eligibility and other aspects at the time of Computer Based Examination and, therefore, candidature will be accepted only provisionally. The candidates are advised to go through the requirements of educational qualification, experience, age, physical and medical standards etc. as per the requirements of the Post-category they wish to apply for and satisfy themselves that they are eligible for the post(s). Copies of self-attested supporting documents along-with print out of the online application form will be sought at the time of Scrutiny Stage from the shortlisted candidates for the said stage of scrutiny as per Selection Procedure mentioned in Para-18 and at the time of Document Verification. When scrutiny of documents is undertaken at any stage of the recruitment process, if any claim made in the application is not found substantiated, the candidature will be cancelled and the Commission’s decision shall be final.
16. DOCUMENTS VERIFICATION:
16.1All the candidates qualified for Document Verification are required to appear for Document Verification in the Regional Office to which the Post-category belongs, along with the photocopies and original documents as mentioned at Para No.
16.4.18.19. The candidates applying for the examination should ensure that they fulfill all the eligibility conditions for admission to the examination. Their admission at all stages of the examination will be purely provisional, subject to their satisfying the prescribed eligibility conditions. If, on verification, at any time before or after the Computer Based examination, it is found that they do not fulfill any of the eligibility conditions, their candidature for the examination will be cancelled.
20.1.APPLICATIONS/ CANDIDATURE OF APPLICANTS ARE LIABLE TO BE CANCELLED/ REJECTED AT ANY STAGE OF THE RECRUITMENT PROCESS IN THE EVENT OF ALL OR ANY OF THE FOLLOWING:
20.1.1.Applications being incomplete.
20.1.7.Non-forwarding of self attested legible copies of all the relevant certificates/ documents issued by the competent authority, along with the print out of the online Application Forms, in support of the information given in their online Application Forms about their educational qualifications, experiences, percentage of marks obtained, proof of age, proof of category [SC/ ST/ OBC/ EWS/ PwD/ ESM/ CGCE, etc], as and when called for by the Commission after conduct of Computer Based Examination(s).
20.1.10.Non-receipt/late receipt of the printout of the online Application Form along with selfattested copies of the relevant documents at the scrutiny stage.
20.1.16.Any other irregularity.”
It appears that, in view of the large volume of applications received pursuant to the recruitment process, the respondents may have resorted to technological tools, including automated systems, for scrutiny and identification of discrepancies in the particulars furnished by candidates. The increasing reliance on such mechanisms may be attributable to the substantial number of candidates participating in recruitment processes, particularly in the backdrop of large-scale recruitment drives and the limited availability of government employment. However, irrespective of the mode adopted for scrutiny, the application of the prescribed recruitment conditions must be considered in the context of the nature and materiality of the discrepancy involved in each case.
We note that the respondents have placed considerable reliance on the stipulation in the recruitment notice that incomplete application forms are liable to rejection, maintaining that the terms and conditions of the advertisement are binding upon all candidates and cannot be disregarded. The respondents’ approach to the instructions governing the completion of the online application form appears to be guided by the principle of “erring on the side of caution”—that is, adopting a strict and cautious approach to avoid any possibility of error or non-compliance. While the need for strict adherence to the prescribed recruitment conditions cannot be disputed, the question that arises for consideration is whether such an approach warrants rejection in every case, irrespective of the nature and materiality of the discrepancy and its actual impact on the candidate’s substantive eligibility.
In Karnail Singh v. Election Tribunal, Hissar, ((1954) 10 E.L.R. 189), it was observed that the nomination paper of Sher Singh had been rejected on the ground that Column 8 of the nomination form had not been duly filled in. The objection was that the name of the sub-division had not been mentioned in the relevant column. However, the evidence clearly established that there was no difficulty in identifying the candidate and that the candidate himself had pointed out to the Returning Officer the entry relating to his name in the electoral roll. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the defect in question was purely technical in nature and upheld the finding of the Tribunal that the nomination paper had been improperly rejected.
In Pratap Singh v. Shri Krishna Gupta, AIR 1956 SC 140, 141, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that courts should not adopt a technical approach while dealing with election matters and that “it is the substance that must count and it must take precedence over mere form.” However, while appreciating the effect of these observations, it is necessary to bear in mind the issues that arose for consideration in that case. The validity of the nomination was challenged on the ground that the candidate had failed to mention his occupation, as required under Rule 9(1)(i). In examining this issue, the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered the effect of Section 23 of the C.P. and Berar Municipalities Act, 1922, which provided that no act done or proceeding taken under the said Act could be questioned on account of any defect or irregularity that did not affect the merits of the case. The limited question, therefore, was whether the omission in the nomination form affected the merits of the case. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the failure to mention the occupation could not, in any manner, affect the merits of the case.
The dictionary meaning of the term “defect” denotes a “lack or absence of something essential to completeness” and also encompasses “a flaw, fault or imperfection”. However, whether the term includes an omission must necessarily depend upon the context in which it is used. In the facts of the present case, the discrepancies in question may, at best, be construed as instances of inaccurate information furnished in the online application forms. Whether a particular omission or inaccuracy would constitute a defect warranting rejection of candidature must, therefore, be determined in the light of the specific provisions governing the recruitment process and the nature and effect of the discrepancy involved. It is in this context that the broader question arises as to the circumstances in which an omission or inaccurate entry may be treated as a defect sufficient to justify rejection of candidature.
In Rangilal Choudhury v. Dahu Sao and Others (1962 (2) SCR 401), the Apex Court held as under:
“In the circumstances, it must be held that the defect was of an unsubstantial character and would not result in the rejection of the nomination paper. We may in this connection refer to Karnail Singh v. Election Tribunal, Hissar and Others (1951 10E.L.R. 189.), where this Court, observed that it was quite clear, on the evidence, that there was no difficulty in identifying the candidate, and that the candidate himself pointed out to the returning officer his own name in the electoral rolls. Therefore, the defect in columns 2 and 5 was, in the circumstances, held to be a technical one and not of a substantial character. The principle of that case, in our opinion, applies to the present case also, for there is no doubt here that the returning officer found no difficulty in identifying the proposer as well as the candidate and, as a matter of fact, the evidence is that the candidate himself pointed out the place in the electoral rolls where his name was entered.”
The respondents have placed strong reliance upon the decision rendered in Shivayti Chaudhary (supra), contending that the correctness of the particulars furnished by a candidate in the online application form is material to the recruitment process and that a discrepancy affecting the verification of identity or eligibility cannot, in every case, be treated as a mere clerical or typographical error. However, the said decision is clearly distinguishable from the facts and circumstances of the present batch of cases. In Shivayti Chaudhary (supra), the candidature of the applicant for the posts of Youth Assistant Grade-I (Post Code NR10522) and Grade-II (Post Code NR10622), advertised under Phase-X/2022, was rejected vide Rejection List dated 13.11.2024 on the ground that the requisite work experience had not been mentioned in the online application form at the prescribed stage. The only exception was in respect of the candidate who had indicated “Yes” in the relevant field but had failed to furnish the requisite details of such experience. Thus, the discrepancy in the said case pertained to the failure to furnish the prescribed details of work experience in the online application form itself.
In Civil Appeal No. 1 of 2024 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 12230 of 2023), Vashist Narayan Kumar v. State of Bihar & Ors., decided on 02.01.2024, the Apex Court observed as under:
“19.In this case, the appellant has participated in the selection process and cleared all the stages successfully. The error in the application is trivial which did not play any part in the selection process. The State was not justified in making a mountain out of this molehill. Perhaps the rarefied atmosphere of the cybercafe, got the better of the appellant. He omitted to notice the error and even failed to avail the corrective mechanism offered. In the instant case, we cannot turn a Nelson’s eye to the ground realities that existed. In the order dated 22.11.2021 in C.A. No. 6983 of 2021 [Prince Jaibir Singh vs. Union of India & Ors.], this Court rightly observed that though technology is a great enabler, there is at the same time, a digital divide.
20.In one of the cases cited as a precedent in the counter affidavit, before the High Court, Pankaj Paswan vs. State of Bihar Anr., 2015 SCC On Line Patna 8739, the State had taken a defence that many candidates applied in more than one place and hence there could be deliberate tweaking in the date of birth to take advantage of the selection process in more than one district or region. It is very important to notice that there is no such plea taken in the present case. If any such device or trick had been adopted, the State would have easily detected the same and placed the same before the Court. The fact that the same has not been done shows that there was no trick or device resorted to by the appellant. It is a trivial error which appears to be a genuine and bona fide mistake. It will be unjust to penalise the appellant for the same.
21.Learned counsel for the State, in the written submissions, stated that the instructions clearly stipulated that if two or more candidates obtain the same marks in the Physical Eligibility Test, their relative rank in the final merit list could be determined on the basis of their date of birth. The implication in the submission is that the date of birth is a significant aspect. On that basis, he submits that the cancellation ought to be upheld. We do not find merit in the submission. The original date of birth, as available is 18.12.1997, in the educational certificates. There is no dispute that the appellant’s date of birth was, in fact, 18.12.1997. In view of that, we do not see the said clause in the instructions as an impediment for the selection of the appellant.
22.Learned counsel for the State has also, in the written submissions, cited the judgment of this Court in Yogesh Kumar and Others vs. Govt. of NCT, Delhi and Others, (2003) 3 SCC 548. The said judgment is clearly distinguishable. There the issue was about allowing entry of ineligible persons into the selection. While the eligibility prescribed was Teacher’s Training Certificate from a recognized institute or intermediate or equivalent from a recognized Board/University with an elective subject in the required language at the matric level, candidates with B.Ed. degree sought appointment as Assistant Teacher. Negating their claim, this Court held that the B.Ed. qualification cannot be treated as a qualification higher than the Teacher’s Training Certificate, because the nature of the training imparted for grant of certificate and for grant of degree was totally different. In that context, this Court held that deviating from the rules and allowing entry to ineligible persons would deprive many others who could have competed for the post. Yogesh Kumar (supra) has no application to the facts of the present case. Equally distinguishable are the judgments of the Delhi High Court in Rohit Kumar and Another vs. Union of India and Others, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1219 and Pradeep Kumar vs. Union of India and Others, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 239.
23.In the case of Rohit Kumar (supra), the undisputed facts, as is clear from para 10 of the judgment, was that the candidate was declared unsuccessful on two counts, namely, that the OBC certificate uploaded by the candidate was not as per the format as mentioned in the advertisement and additionally on the ground that the date of issuance of the certificate was wrongly mentioned in the online application.
24.In Pradeep Kumar (supra), the identity proof (Aadhaar Card) was not uploaded and instead the self photograph of the candidate has been uploaded. We find that the said two judgments are distinguishable on facts for the reasons set out above.
25.On the peculiar facts of this case, considering the background in which the error occurred, we are inclined to set aside the cancellation. We are not impressed with the finding of the Division Bench that there was no prayer seeking quashment of the results declared over the web. A reading of the prayer clause in the writ petition indicates that the appellant did pray for a mandamus directing the respondents to consider the candidature treating his date of birth as 18.12.1997 and also sought for a direction for issuance of an appointment letter. A Writ Court has the power to mould the relief. Justice cannot be forsaken on the altar of technicalities.”
The question as to whether the aforesaid discrepancies constitute misrepresentation/malafide or impersonation or malpractice for the purpose of securing public employment becomes relevant at the stage of physical verification of documents. Before finalizing the appointment, the recruiting authority is required to verify the authenticity of the claims made by each candidate, particularly since any offer of appointment at that stage remains strictly provisional.
Since human perfection is an ideal that is rarely attainable, inadvertent mistakes are bound to occur. A candidate ought not to be judged unduly harshly merely because technological advancements enable the detection of every such error, provided that the mistake does not alter the prescribed eligibility criteria or fall within the realm of concealment, suppression of material facts, or false declaration, particularly where the candidate acknowledges the error and the same is capable of objective verification.
7. CONCLUSION :
In view of the foregoing discussion and having regard to the nature of the discrepancies involved in the present batch of Original Applications, we are of the considered view that the matter warrants reconsideration by the respondents in accordance with the principles discussed hereinabove. Accordingly, the impugned decisions rejecting the candidature of the applicants, in the respective Original Applications, are set aside, subject to the directions contained hereinbelow.
The respondents are directed to undertake verification of the relevant particulars furnished by each applicant, with particular reference to the original educational certificates, driving licences, and experience certificates relied upon by them. Wherever necessary, the documents shall be referred to the concerned issuing authority or organisation for verification of their genuineness and correctness. Upon receipt of the verification report, the respondents shall consider the candidature of the concerned applicant and, if the applicant is found to fulfil all the prescribed eligibility conditions as on the crucial date and no other disqualification is attracted, proceed further in accordance with the applicable recruitment rules.
It is clarified that the benefit of the aforesaid directions shall be available only where the discrepancy is found to be inadvertent and does not affect the applicant’s substantive eligibility or involve any material misrepresentation, concealment, or suppression of facts. The respondents shall examine the nature and effect of the discrepancy in each case individually and shall not reject a candidature solely on account of a technical or clerical error without considering the supporting documents and the findings of verification.
In the event that an applicant is found eligible upon completion of the aforesaid verification, the respondents shall take appropriate steps for consideration of such applicant for appointment to the post in question, in accordance with the applicable recruitment conditions. If no vacancy is available at that stage, the respondents shall consider the applicant’s case in accordance with law and adjust them against future vacancies.
The entire exercise, as directed above, shall be completed within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The respondents shall communicate a reasoned decision to each concerned applicant.
The applicants shall not be entitled to any monetary benefits for the period during which they were not appointed pursuant to the impugned decisions.
The Original Applications are disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of. to costs
7.8.. Registry is directed to place a copy of this order in each case file of this batch.
