Results
High Courts(2026) 11 UK CK 3258

State Of Uttarakhand & Ors. Vs Mahiman Singh Bora

Uttarakhand High Court · Nainital · 18 Nov 2026 · Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ · Subhash Upadhyay, J

Open full page

Judgment

22 paragraphs · 1,027 words

(Per: Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ.)

1.

State has filed this writ petition challenging judgment and order dated 05.03.2025 rendered by Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal Bench at Nainital in Claim Petition No. 52/NB/DB/2023, whereby claim petition filed by respondent was allowed. State has also challenged order dated 10.11.2025 passed by learned Tribunal, whereby review application filed by State was rejected.

2.

In his claim petition, respondent had challenged order dated 13.03.2023 passed by Executive Engineer, Construction Division, P.W.D., Ramnagar, whereby his claim for pension for ad-hoc services, rendered between 1984 to 1989, was rejected. Learned Tribunal set-aside order dated 13.03.2023 and directed the authority to count the services rendered by respondent in ad-hoc capacity for payment of pensionary benefits. Operative portion of the impugned judgment is reproduced below:-

“11.

Learned Counsel for the petitioner has confined his prayer to count the period spent on the adhoc basis for refixing the pension and payment of pensionary benefit to the petitioner. The order dated 13.03.2023 is liable to be quashed. The claim petition is liable to be allowed. The respondents are directed to count the period spent on adhoc basis for the payment of pensionary benefits. The pension of the petitioner is required to be refixed accordingly and pay the arrears of the pensionary benefits.

ORDER

The claim petition is allowed. The order dated 13.03.2023 is set aside and the respondents are directed to refix the retiral dues of the petitioner after counting the service rendered by him on adhoc basis and pay the pensionary benefits within three months from the date of presentation of certified copy of the judgment. No order as to costs.”

3.

The reliefs, claimed by respondent in his claim petition, are extracted below for ready reference:-

(a)

To set aside the impugned order no. 484/dksVZdsl dated 13.03.2023, issued by respondent no. 6 (Annexure No. 1 to Compilation-I).

(b)

To direct the respondents departments to treat the services of the petitioner, as regularized w.e.f. 21.12.1984 and grant him all service benefits including Pension, Gratuity and other post retiral benefits.

(c)

To refix the Pension, Gratuity and other post retiral benefits on the basis of the last payment certificate, issued by respondent department (Annexure No. 18 to this claim petition) and award interest @ 18% per annum on the delayed of the payment.

(d)

Issue any other suitable order or direction in favour of petitioner, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case.

(e)

Award cost of the claim petition in favour of petitioner.

4.

Learned State Counsel submits that learned Tribunal has not indicated any reason for allowing the claim petition and for directing the authorities to grant pension for the ad-hoc services rendered by respondent between 1984 to 1989.

5.

Learned State Counsel further submits that respondent was given ad-hoc appointment as Junior Clerk in Public Works Department on 21.12.1984 against a short-term vacancy, which had occurred on account of ah-hoc promotion of regular incumbent of that post to the post of Senior Clerk, with the condition that respondent’s appointment will come to an end as and when regular incumbent is reverted back to the position of Junior Clerk. He further submits that petitioner was given regular appointment vide order dated 27.12.1989 passed by Chief Engineer, Kumaon Zone, P.W.D. Almora.

6.

Learned State Counsel drew our attention to order dated 27.12.1989, where it is mentioned that respondent is being given temporary appointment as Junior Clerk and his services would be terminable upon one month notice. Thus, he submits that respondent’s claim for pension cannot be allowed for a period when he was engaged against a short-term/leave vacancy, which had occurred due to ad-hoc promotion of the regular incumbent of the post of Junior Clerk. He submits that whole basis of the judgment rendered by learned Tribunal is one seniority list in which petitioner was erroneously given seniority on the post of Junior Clerk from 21.12.1984, while at the relevant point of time, respondent was serving against a post on which someone else was holding lien.

7.

Learned counsel for the respondent, however, supports the judgment rendered by learned Tribunal by relying upon a judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of C. Yamini & others vs. High Court for the State of Andhra Pradesh & another, reported as (2023) 19 SCC 479.

8.

After pursing the said judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court, it appears that the issue before us is in no manner similar to the facts of the case relied upon by learned counsel for the respondent.

9.

We have carefully perused the impugned judgment rendered by learned Tribunal. Learned Tribunal has not given any reason for holding that respondent is entitled for pension from the date of his initial appointment in 1984. Moreover, learned Tribunal has failed to take note of the nature of appointment given to respondent in the year 1984.

10.

Even though, order dated 21.12.1984 was enclosed as annexure-3 to the claim petition filed before learned Tribunal, however, learned Tribunal overlooked the important aspect that respondent was not appointed against a clear/permanent vacancy, but his appointment was only against a short-term vacancy which had occurred because of ad-hoc promotion of regular incumbent. Thus, the relevant question, which should have been dealt with by learned Tribunal, was the date when the vacancy in question became permanent. Two persons cannot hold lien against one post. Since these aspects have not been considered by learned Tribunal, while deciding claim petition, therefore, we set-aside the impugned judgment dated 05.03.2025 rendered by learned Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal Bench at Nainital in Claim Petition No. 52/NB/DB/2023 and remit the matter back to learned Tribunal for deciding the issue afresh.

11.

Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. No order as to costs.

12.

Learned counsel for the respondent then submits that his client has been paid pension for the regular services rendered by him for the period between 05.01.1990 till his superannuation.

13.

Since there is no dispute regarding respondent’s entitlement for pension for the aforesaid period, therefore, the amount, paid as pension for the said period, shall not be recovered from him.