Results
High Courts(2026) 10 PAT CK 1748

Munshi Yadav @ Mansi Yadav Vs The State Of Bihar & Ors.

Patna High Court · 15 Oct 2026 · Alok Kumar, J

Open full page

Judgment

19 paragraphs · 1,205 words

Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned counsel for the State.

2.

In the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for the following relief(s):-

“(i)

A direction may be given to the respondent nos. 3 and 4 ad 5 i.e. the District Collector, Siwan and the Circle Officer Siwan Sadar Block, District: Siwan to not disturb the peaceful possession of the villagers upon the land of Khata No. 598, Survey Plot No. 3931, Area 8 Kathas, 17 Dhurs of Mauza Sarsar, P.S. Siwan Mufassil, Thana No. 199, District: Siwan. The said land recorded in the Khatiyan as Malikan land bakabaje Malik Waste Ajan Veer Puja Asthal, Tauzi No. 4949 Malik Nam Uttim Singh and others.

ii) Further be pleased to restrain the respondents from changing the nature of land which disturb the peaceful fabric of the locality.

iii) Any other relief/ reliefs may be granted to the petitioner as per the law of the land.”

3.

The case of the petitioner is that the land of Khata No. 598, Survey Plot No. 3931, area 8 Kathas 17 Dhurs of Mauza Sarsar, Thana No. 199, Tauzi No. 4949, is recorded in the name of the earlier landlord, Bakabaje Malik Partikadeem, and that in the margin of the record of right prepared on 20 February 1919 it is written as "Ajan Veer Ka Asthan", a Hindu Deity. The petitioner obtained a certified copy of the record on 02.02.2024. The petitioner states that since the institution of the record of rights a Hindu Deity, "Ajan Veer Asthan", has been on the said land and the people of the locality have observed Puja there since immemorial and continuously till today. Recently, with the help of the local Mukhiya, the Government officials want to change the nature of the land by constructing a building upon it, without any initiation of land acquisition proceeding, which disturbs the social fabric of the locality. The local officials raised boundary walls upon the land for taking possession by use of police force, which the local people objected to. A public petition dated 02.02.2024, with the signatures of co-villagers, was sent by post to the Circle Officer, Siwan Sadar, who was not ready to receive a copy of it from the public, and to the District Collector, Siwan as well.

4.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the land is recorded in the Khatiyan as "Ajan Veer Asthan" and that the local public have been performing Puja there since time immemorial and have a right to do so, and that the respondents are changing the nature of the land by constructing a building and raising boundary walls upon it, using police force, without any land acquisition proceeding or legal process. It was further submitted that the petitioner's fundamental rights under Articles 14, 16, 25 and 26 of the Constitution of India are being violated by disturbing the possession of the people over the land.

5.

Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the counter affidavit of Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 itself discloses that the land was transferred to the Excise Department vide Record Transfer No. 01.2020-21 on the basis of the inspection report dated 07.08.2021 and the order dated 28.02.2022 of the District Collector, Siwan, and that the petitioner had no knowledge of the transfer before filing the petition. It was also submitted that the respondents have denied the petitioner's statement that the public has performed Puja there since immemorial, which shows the mindset of the authorities and that the counter affidavit ignores the general public sentiment and religious importance of the place, and that there are many other lands in the same area which may be used by the State.

6.

Learned counsel for the State/Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 submitted that the petitioner has relied on the khatiyan entries, according to which the land of Khata No. 598, Survey No. 3931, area 8 katha 17 dhur, Mauza Sarsar, is recorded as Gair Majarua malik of the nature of paiti kadim and is also the location of Ajaan Veer and that the District Excise Department had raised a demand for land for construction of Women Barack, Hazat and Malkhana. Pursuant to that demand, the transfer of the land was sanctioned by the District Collector, Siwan vide order dated 28.02.2022

7.

Learned counsel for the State/Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 further submitted that, before the transfer was sanctioned, the Circle Officer, Siwan opened Land Transfer Record No. 01/020-21, in which due inquiry was held. A spot inspection was made on 07.08.2021 and a memo of inspection of the same date was prepared and by letter No. 1272 dated 14-09-2020, the Circle Officer, Siwan had proposed the transfer of only 7 katha, leaving aside one katha 1 dhur for the Ajaan Veer asthan.

8.

It was also submitted that the land transfer record showed the following:

(i)the land is paiti kadim under Khata No. 598;

(ii)it was found unoccupied on spot inspection;

(iii)no Jamabandi exists in respect of it;

(iv)no villager raised any objection to the proposal during the inquiry;

(v)

and the Circle Officer, the Deputy Collector Land Reforms, Siwan and the Sub-Divisional Officer, Siwan recommended the transfer.

It was lastly submitted that the worship of Ajaan Veer is being done on the said one katha 6 dhur area.

9.

Having heard the parties and perused the record, it is evident from the revenue record that the land in question is recorded as Gair Majarua malik, of the nature of Paiti Kadim and Ajaan Veer Puja Asthal. In view of the specific stand of the State that the Circle Officer, Siwan had proposed the transfer of only 7 katha of land for a public purpose, to which the villagers have no objection, and proposed to leave one katha and one dhur for the Ajaan Veer asthan, this Court is of the view that there shall be no interference with respect to the public policy of the State. The Courts act as reviewers of the decision-making process, and not of the merit, wisdom, or correctness of the policy itself. Judicial review is limited to examining whether the authority exceeded its statutory power or ignored a fundamental rule. The scope of judicial review in such matters has been explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Yamuna Expressway Industrial Development Authority v. Shakuntala Education & Welfare Society, reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 655, wherein it has been held that interference with a policy decision is not warranted unless it is palpably arbitrary, mala fide, irrational or violative of a statutory provision. In Villianur Iyarkkai Padukappu Maiyam v. Union of India, reported in (2009) 7 SCC 561, it has been held that courts do not examine the wisdom of a policy or whether a better policy is possible. Further, in DDA v. Allottee of SFS Flats, reported in (2008) 2 SCC 672, it has been held that a policy is open to judicial review if it is unconstitutional, dehors the Act or Regulations, beyond the delegated power, or contrary to a statutory or larger policy.

10.

In view of the above, this Court is not inclined to interfere in the policy decision of the state, hence, the present writ petition is dismissed.