M/s. Manda Developers And Builders @APPELLANT@Hash State of Rajasthan & Ors

Rajasthan High Court 14 Sep 2018 Civil Writ No. 5106 of 2013, 8498, 8519, 8638, 8639, 8713, 8729, 8734, 8735, 8981, 9038, 9041, 10294, 10295,11652, 211, 9039 of 2009 (2018) 09 RAJ CK 0055
Bench: Single Bench
Result Published
Acts Referenced

Judgement Snapshot

Case Number

Civil Writ No. 5106 of 2013, 8498, 8519, 8638, 8639, 8713, 8729, 8734, 8735, 8981, 9038, 9041, 10294, 10295,11652, 211, 9039 of 2009

Hon'ble Bench

Sandeep Mehta, J

Advocates

Rekha Borana, Hemant Choudhary, Keshav Pareek, N.S. Rajpurohit, D.P. Dhaka

Final Decision

Allowed

Acts Referred
  • Central Excise Act, 1944 - Section 3
  • Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 - Section 3(1)
  • Constitution of India, 1950 - Article 226

Judgement Text

Translate:

Ø-la-,Lkexzh dk fooj.k,ek=k,"mRikn ‘kqYd

esa NqV dh nj","mRikn ‘kqYd

esa izkIr NqV

dh dqy

jkf’k

1-,lhesUV csx,57039 ux,RS 20@izfr ux,RSÂ 1140780/-

vuqPNsn dk laf{kIr fooj.k,dk;kZy; }kjk izLrqr vuqikyuk,"v/khvfHk- dh

fVIi.kh",eq-vdh fVIi.kh,"ys[kk ijh{kk dh

fVIi.kh

mRikn “kqYd NwV dk izek.k i= vfu;fer

:i ls tkjh djus esa foQy jgus ls ifj;kstuk dh

ykxr esa deh dk vHkko jkfâ€​k :i;s 70-09

yk[kA vkj-MCY;w-,l-vkj-ih- ls lEcfU/kr

dk;ksaZ chds&6 o chds&7 dh vfHkys[kksa

dh tkap esa ik;k fd fcM ds Hkkx lh ds

vkbVe 13-3 esa vafdr mYys[kkuqlkj fcMj

}kjk izLrqr dh tkus okyh njksa esa lHkh

VsDl] M~;wVht ,oe~ ysoht lfEefyr ekuh

tkosxhA blh vuqlkj ,LVhesV cuk, x,A blds

vfrfjDr vkbVe 13-3 ds uhps fn;s x;s uksV

esa mYys[k fd;k x;k Fkk fd ;ksX;rk lwpuk

ds lkFk layXu izi= esa] fcM ds lkFk gh lHkh

oLrqvksa dk uke o ek=k dk mYys[k fcMj

}kjk fd;k tkosxk] ftu oLrqvksa ij fcMj }kjk

NwV dk ykHk izkIr fd;k tkuk gksA ysfdu

nksuksa dk;ksaZ ds fcMj }kjk bl fooj.k ds

fcuk gh fufonk vfHkys[k foHkkx dks izLrqr

fd,A ftlls fl) gksrk gS fd laosndksa }kjk

lHkh VsDl ,oe M~;wVh dks lfEefyr djrs gq,

njsa izLrkfor dh xbZa vkSj mRikn “kqYd

dk ykHk ugha ysuk pkgrs FksA ysfdu

fufonk Lohd`fr mijkUr lhesaV o LVhy ij

mRikn NwV izkIr djus ds fy, vkosnu izLrqr

fd;k x;k] ftl ij funsâ€​kd¼rduhfd½ O;;

vks-,l-Mh-] flapkbZ jktLFkku t;iqj }kjk

nksuksa iSdstksa ds fy,] NwV izkIr djus

gsrq izek.k i= tkjh fd, x,A bl NwV dk ykHk

jkT; ljdkj dks LFkkukarfjr ugha fd;k x;kA

tkjh izek.k&i= vuqlkj nksuksa dk;ksaZ ds

fu’iknu gsrq 17180 eSfVªd Vu

¼3]43]606 cSx½ lhesaV dh vkoâ€​;drk

FkhA ftl ij 400@& :i;s izfr eSfVªd Vu

mRikn “kqYd] bl ij 2 izfrâ€​kr dh nj ls

fâ€​k{kk vf/kHkkj ls dqy jkfâ€​k

70]09]440@& :i;s dk ykHk nksuksa

QeksaZ dks izkIr gksxkA foHkkx }kjk bl

izek.k&i= dks vukoâ€​;d tkjh djus ,oa NwV

ds ykHk dks jkT; ljdkj dks LFkkukarfjr ugha

djus dk izko/kku vuqca/k esa lfEefyr ugha

fd;k x;kA bl izdkj Vs.Mj Lohd`fr ds ckn

izkIr vkosnu ds vk/kkj ij NwV dk izek.k&i=

izkIr djus ls laosndksa dks jkfâ€​k 70- 09","¼1½ DykWt 13-3 esa ftu djksa vkSj

izHkkjksa dk mYys[k fd;k x;k gS] ftudks

lfEefyr djrs gq, nj izLrkfor dh tkuh Fkh

ds dj ,oa izHkkj lkekU;r% fuekZ.k

dk;ksaZ ij tks fuft QeksaZ@laosndksa ls

djok;s tkrs gSA mu ij yxus okys dj ,oa

izHkkj gS u fd mRikn “kqYd dh

NwVA ¼2½ 13-3 ds uhps vafdr

uksV ds vuq:i ftl NwV dk mYys[k fd;k

x;k gS] og dj ds :i esa izkfIr u gksdj

dsUnz }kjk jkT; dks nh tkuhs okyh NwV

gS] tks vizR;{k :i ls izkIr dh tk ldrh gS

rFkk ;g NwV foâ€​o cSad ds

ØsfMV@_.k ls gksus okys leLr

dk;ksaZ ij Lor% ykxw gSA vr % ;g

NwV bl dk;Z fo’ksâ€​k ds fy, ugha

gS rFkk bl NwV dh fujarj miyC/krk Hkh

fufâ€​pr ugha gS D;ksafd uksV esa

laosnd dks ;g funsZ’k fn;k x;k gS fd

og ,slh miyC/k NwV ij fopkj dj ldsxk ,oa

NwV ugha miyC/k gksusa ij jkT; ljdkj

{kfriwfrZ ugha djsxh rFkk og O;fDrxr :i

ls mRrjnk;h gksxkA vr% NwV dk ykHk

vizR;{k :i ls fy;k tkuk Fkk tks fd fy;k x;k

gS] D;ksafd nj Lohd`r gksrs gh QeZ }kjk

izek.k i= gsrq vkosnu fd;k x;kA

mYys[kuh; gS fd dsUnz ljdkj dk ;g

Notification la0 108@95 lh-bZfnukad 28-

05-95] ftlds vuqlkj foâ€​o cSad ls foRr

iksf’kr ifj;kstukvksa esa fuekZ.k ds

dke vkus okyh oLrqvksa] tks fd dsUnzh;

mRikn VsjhQ dh ch lwph esa lfEefyr gS]

bu oLrqvksa dks mRikn “kqYd ls

eqDr fd;k x;kA ;g uksfVfQdsâ€​ku

loZfofnr ,oa izdkfâ€​kr gS ftldk fd bl Js.kh

ds QeksaZ@laosndks dks fufâ€​pr :i ls

bldk Kku gksxkA pwafd fuekZ.k dk;Z

Through Rate ls djok;s tk jgs gSA vr%

fuekZ.k lkexzh foHkkx }kjk vkiwfrZ

ugha dh tkrh gSA bl fLFkfr esa mRikn

“kqYd izR;{k :i ls dVkSfr laHko ugha

gS] D;ksafd QeZ }kjk fuekZ.k lkexzh

[kqys cktkj ls Ø; dh tkosxh vkoâ€​;d",,,

yk[k :i;s dk vns; ykHk nsdj] jkT; dks’k

dks gkfu igqapkbZA","ugha gS fd mlesa bldks NwV izkIr gqbZ

gks ,slh fLFkfr esa foHkkx lkexzh dh

xq.koRrk dh tkap dj ldrk gS] u fd mRikn

“kqYd dh NwV dhA vr% ,slh fLFkfr

esa lkexzh ij mRikn “kqYd dh NwV

dh izkfIr lqfufâ€​pr djuk laHko ugha gSA

vr% ,slh fLFkfr esa DykWt 13-3 ds

mn~nsâ€​; ds vuq:i QeksaZ }kjk nj bl

NwV dk fopkjkFkZ j[krsa gq, gh dh xbZ

Fkh] ftldk vizR;{k :i ls dk;Z dh ykxr ij

izHkko iM+k gSA fcM MkD;wesaV ds

izk:i esa] laosnd }kjk lkexzh dh ek=k dk

mYys[k ugha fd;k x;k tks fd NwV ugha

izkIr djus dk izek.k ugha gS] blds vfrfjDr

ek=k dk vfUre fu/kkZj.k ,Eiyks;j }kjk gh

fd;k tkuk Fkk rFkk uksV ds

funsZâ€​kkuqlkj ,slh ek=k dk mYys[k] nj

izLrkoksa ds lkFk@le; djus dk mYys[k u

gksdj ;g funsZfâ€​kr fd;k x;k gS fd

vko’;d izek.k i= tkjh djokus gsrq

fu/kkZfjr izi= esa lwpuk,a izLrqr djsxkA

rn~ukuqlkj losand@QeZ }kjk i`Fkd ls

fn;s x;s vkosnu ij jkT; ljdkj }kjk NwV dk

izek.k i= tkjh fd;k x;k gSA tks fd mfpr

,oa oS/k gSA uksV ds vuq:i mDr DykWt

dh vuqikyuk lqfuf’pr ugha gksus dh

fLFkfr esa ^^nj izLrko Non Responsive

treat djrs gq, Reject dj fn;k tkosxk^^]

tcfd mPp Lrjh; lfefr }kjk bl izdj.kksa dks

Lohd`r fd;k x;k gSaA vr% ;g ekuuk mfpr

gS fd NqV ij fopkj djusa ds mijkUr gh

njsa izkIr gqbZ gSa rFkk rnukuqlkj NwV

ds fy, izek.k i= Hkh mPp Lrjh; lfefr }kjk

tkjh fd;k x;k gSA blh ifjis{; esa fu;ekuqlkj

gh Bsdsnkj }kjk mRikn “kqYd dh

NwV yh xbZ gSA vr% iSjk fujLr djus dk

Je djkosaA",,,

From The Blog
ITAT Mumbai Rules Full Addition for Bogus Purchases, Rejects 8% Estimation
Dec
13
2025

Court News

ITAT Mumbai Rules Full Addition for Bogus Purchases, Rejects 8% Estimation
Read More
Supreme Court’s Call for Speedy Trials: Lessons from Sanjay Dutt’s Appeal and Provisions in BNS
Dec
13
2025

Court News

Supreme Court’s Call for Speedy Trials: Lessons from Sanjay Dutt’s Appeal and Provisions in BNS
Read More