Shankar Dial Vs Amir Haidar and Others

Allahabad High Court 24 Feb 1880 (1880) ILR (All) 752
Bench: Division Bench
Result Published

Judgement Snapshot

Hon'ble Bench

Pearson, J; Oldfield, J

Final Decision

Dismissed

Judgement Text

Translate:

Oldfield, J.@mdashThe decree-holder, appellant before us, sought to attach certain property in execution of his decree, and the judgment-debtors

objected that they held the property, not as their own property, but as superintendents of an endowment to which the property belonged, and they

objected to the attachment. The Court of First Instance released the property from attachment on the objections taken. The decree-holder

appealed to the Judge, who dismissed the appeal on the ground that, with reference to the value of the subject-matter, it lay to the High Court. The

decree-holder has now appealed to this Court. A preliminary objection appears to us to be valid, to the effect that there is no appeal, and that the

decree-holder''s proper remedy is by regular suit.

2. The objections taken to the attachment were of the nature of those to be dealt with u/s 278 and following sections, Civil Procedure Code, and

the remedy for the party dissatisfied is u/s 283 by regular suit. The case is not altered by the circumstance that the objectors were the judgment-

debtors. It has been held frequently that the provisions of Section 278 and following sections apply equally to the objections by parties to the suit

as by strangers, when their objections are of the nature of those with which those sections deal.--Haris Chandra Gupto v. Srimati Shashi Mala

Gupti 6 B.L.R. 721: In the matter of the petition of J.B. Rainey 6 B.L.R. 725: Chunder Kant Surmah v. Bungshee Deh Surmah 6 W.R. 61. We

dismiss the appeal with costs.

From The Blog
Supreme Court: Hindu Succession Act Excludes Tribal Daughters
Oct
22
2025

Story

Supreme Court: Hindu Succession Act Excludes Tribal Daughters
Read More
Supreme Court Alarmed at 8.82 Lakh Pending Execution Cases
Oct
22
2025

Story

Supreme Court Alarmed at 8.82 Lakh Pending Execution Cases
Read More